
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
NORTHSKY 36 Inch High Velocity Industrial Drum Fan9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
ZMISHIBO 52 Inch Ceiling Fan with Lights9.5/10View on Amazon - 3
Amico 42 Inch Low Profile Ceiling Fan with Lights and Remote9.5/10View on Amazon - 4
COMFORT ZONE Box Fan with Carry HandleView on Amazon - 5
Hurricane Classic Floor Box Fan with 3 Speed SettingsView on Amazon - 6
shinic 10" Tabletop Box Fan for BedroomView on Amazon - 7
Genesis 20" Box FanView on Amazon - 8
20" Box Fan with 3-Speed Weather-Resistant MotorView on Amazon - 9
20" 3-Speed Weather-Resistant Box FanView on Amazon
Hay dust hangs in the barn air on a hot afternoon, the goats crowd the shaded side of the pen, and the air barely moves past the feed troughs. Barn fan vs box fan comes down to this: a box fan suits a stall or a doorway where a flat fan can sit and push air, while a pedestal fan suits an open corner where height and oscillation matter. The fans here are box fans and a pedestal fan, and no barn fan is among them. Ranked by stated facts, the pedestal fan leads on features and safety, and the Hurricane box fan leads on stated airflow.
Also worth comparing
COMFORT ZONE Box Fan with Carry HandleCheck price on Amazon
Hurricane Classic Floor Box Fan with 3 Speed SettingsCheck price on Amazon
shinic 10" Tabletop Box Fan for BedroomCheck price on Amazon
Genesis 20" Box FanCheck price on Amazon
20" Box Fan with 3-Speed Weather-Resistant MotorCheck price on Amazon
20" 3-Speed Weather-Resistant Box FanCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Barn fan vs box fan: the short answer
Start with where the fan will sit, then pick the type, then check airflow and build. A box fan suits a stall, a doorway or a bench where a flat fan can sit close to the goats, and a pedestal fan suits an open corner where a tall fan can sweep air across the pen. Once the spot is settled, compare airflow, size, speeds and safety.
The four fans here rank in this order: the Comfort Zone pedestal fan, the Hurricane box fan, the Comfort Zone box fan and the shinic tabletop box fan. The pedestal fan leads on stated features: oscillation, adjustable height, a metal safety grill, ETL listing and a 1 year warranty. The Hurricane box fan leads on stated airflow at 2400 CFM. If the choice is really between a barn fan and an exhaust fan, the barn fan vs exhaust fan guide compares those two.
Four fans compared
| Fan | Type | Size | Speeds | Airflow | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| COMFORT ZONE 16-Inch Pedestal Fan | Pedestal fan | 16 inches | 3 speeds | Not stated | 1 year warranty |
| Hurricane Classic 20-Inch Box Fan | Box fan | 20 inches | 3 speeds | 2400 CFM | 1 year warranty |
| COMFORT ZONE 20-Inch Box Fan CZ200A | Box fan | 20 inches | 3 speeds | 15.03 ft/sec | 1 year warranty |
| shinic 10-Inch Tabletop Box Fan | Box fan | 10 inches | 2 speeds | Not stated | Not stated |
Box fans
Three of the four fans here are box fans. The Hurricane Classic lists 2400 CFM and 1100 RPM with 3 speeds, polymer blades and a robust motor, and measures 20.0 x 20.0 x 3.5 inches at 7.0 pounds. The Comfort Zone CZ200A lists 3 speeds, a carry handle and airflow of 15.03 ft/sec, and measures 20.88 x 5.1 x 22.1 inches at 7.0 pounds. The shinic tabletop fan lists 2 speeds, a 9 inch blade and a 10.8 x 10.3 x 3.9 inch shell, with a safety grill and ETL safety certification. All three sit flat, so they suit a floor, a bench or a windowsill.
The pedestal fan
The Comfort Zone pedestal fan is the only fan here that is not a box fan. It lists a 16 inch fan head, 3 speeds, 90-degree oscillation, adjustable tilt and a telescoping pole that sets the height from 41 inches up to 47-3/8 inches. A quad-pod folding base holds it steady and folds for storage, and the fan lists a metal safety grill, ETL listing and a 1 year warranty. It measures 28.75 x 28.75 x 48.0 inches and weighs 5.8 pounds, so it needs floor space.
Reading airflow against your barn
Airflow is the figure that separates these fans, and only two of them state one. The Hurricane box fan lists 2400 CFM at 1100 RPM, the strongest stated airflow here. The Comfort Zone box fan lists airflow of 15.03 ft/sec, a different unit, so the two figures do not compare directly. The pedestal fan and the shinic fan state no airflow figure at all.
Read the figure the maker states and nothing else. A fan that states no airflow figure can still suit a small space, and the shinic fan says its small size suits a desk or a bedside table, while the pedestal fan says its oscillation spreads air across a room. For a stall or a pen, weigh the Hurricane figure, the only airflow figure in CFM here.
Size and where the fan goes
Size decides where each fan can sit. The pedestal fan measures 28.75 x 28.75 x 48.0 inches with a height that adjusts from 41 inches to 47-3/8 inches, so it stands on the floor and needs a clear corner. The Comfort Zone box fan measures 20.88 x 5.1 x 22.1 inches, the Hurricane box fan measures 20.0 x 20.0 x 3.5 inches, and each weighs 7.0 pounds, so either 20 inch box fan moves easily between stalls. The shinic fan is the smallest here at 10.8 x 10.3 x 3.9 inches with a 9 inch blade.
Measure the spot before ordering and compare it with the stated dimensions. A 20 inch box fan needs a flat surface at least as wide as the fan, and a pedestal fan needs floor space for a base 28.75 inches wide.
Materials and safety grills
Two fans here state a safety grill, and two state an ETL listing. The pedestal fan lists a metal safety grill and ETL listing, and the shinic fan lists a safety grill and ETL safety certification. The Hurricane box fan lists polymer blades and a robust motor with no grill or certification stated, and the Comfort Zone box fan states no safety feature at all.
- Metal safety grill: the Comfort Zone pedestal fan, with ETL listing.
- Safety grill: the shinic tabletop fan, with ETL safety certification.
- Polymer blades: the Hurricane box fan, with a robust motor.
- Carry handle: the Comfort Zone box fan, with no safety feature stated.
A grill keeps fingers and bedding away from the blades, which matters where goats push against a fan. The pedestal fan and the shinic fan are the picks where a grill is stated, and the Hurricane fan is the pick where stated airflow matters more. The Comfort Zone box fan states neither, so it suits a spot the goats cannot reach.
Speeds and controls
Three fans here list 3 speeds and one lists 2 speeds. The pedestal fan lists low, medium and high, and the Hurricane and Comfort Zone box fans each list 3 speeds, while the shinic fan lists 2 speeds on a knob. The pedestal fan adds 90-degree oscillation and adjustable tilt, and the Hurricane fan adds adjustable feet.
Manual controls suit a barn because there is nothing to program. The pedestal fan lists manual controls and tool-free assembly, the shinic fan lists a knob, and the Hurricane fan lists a slim frame that stores away. The Comfort Zone box fan lists a carry handle, so it carries from stall to stall by its handle.
Read the listing twice
Fan listings often disagree with themselves, and the conflicting numbers are usually the ones needed to plan the spot:
- Comfort Zone pedestal fan: the height adjusts from 41 inches up to 47-3/8 inches, while the dimensions list 48.0 inches tall. Allow for the larger figure when measuring floor space.
- Comfort Zone box fan CZ200A: the airflow figure of 15.03 ft/sec appears in the title, and the rest of the listing gives no airflow figure. The title figure is the one to use.
Measure the spot before ordering and allow for the larger figure where two figures disagree.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers fan hardware only. It does not cover barn wiring, wall mounting a fan, or how much ventilation a barn needs. A ceiling fan is a separate choice, covered in the barn fan vs ceiling fan guide, and heating is separate too, covered in the best heater for a goat barn guide. Ask an electrician about barn wiring.
FAQs from goat keepers
Which is better for a barn, a barn fan or a box fan?
A box fan suits a stall or a doorway where a flat fan can sit and push air, and a pedestal fan suits an open corner where height and oscillation matter. No barn fan is among the four fans here. For stated airflow, the Hurricane box fan lists 2400 CFM, the strongest figure here.
How much airflow does a box fan move?
The Hurricane box fan lists 2400 CFM at 1100 RPM, and the Comfort Zone box fan lists 15.03 ft/sec. The pedestal fan and the shinic fan state no airflow figure, so their airflow cannot be compared on numbers.
Are box fans safe around goats?
The pedestal fan lists a metal safety grill and ETL listing, and the shinic fan lists a safety grill and ETL safety certification. The Hurricane and Comfort Zone box fans state no grill or certification, so they suit a spot the goats cannot reach.
What size box fan fits a barn stall?
Measure the stall and compare it with the stated dimensions. The 20 inch box fans measure 20.88 x 5.1 x 22.1 inches and 20.0 x 20.0 x 3.5 inches, and the 10 inch shinic fan measures 10.8 x 10.3 x 3.9 inches.
Do these fans come with a warranty?
Three of them state a 1 year warranty: the pedestal fan, the Hurricane box fan and the Comfort Zone box fan. The shinic fan states 1-year after-sale service and 90-day returnable instead.
More from the barn
See every barn equipment guide and all barn and farm tools guides.
More picks: barn fan vs ceiling fan, best solar barn lights, best heater for a goat barn and best LED barn lights.
