
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Fitted PickRubermaid 150 Gal Trough Cover9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
Small Tank PickiBirdie 2x2x4 Stock Tank Cover9.5/10View on Amazon - 3
Big Tank Pick3×8 Foot Oval Tank Cover 2-Pack9.4/10View on Amazon
The best water trough cover for winter keeps ice off the water and heat in the trough: a fitted cover that matches your tank size, with a zipper for access. This list compares five covers on size and fit, from a 150-gallon oval Rubermaid to a 2-pack of 3×8 foot oval covers, plus three more picks.
Also worth comparing
COSFUN 100 Gallon Oval Stock Tank CoverCheck price on Amazon
Waterproof Stock Tank Cover for 100 Gallon Rubbermaid StockCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick picks
- Fitted Pick Rubermaid 150 Gal Trough Cover: 150-gallon oval cover with zipper: 61 by 42 by 9.5 inches. Check price on Amazon
- Small Tank Pick iBirdie 2x2x4 Stock Tank Cover: 2 by 2 by 4 cover: 49 by 26 by 12 inches, 1 year warranty. Check price on Amazon
- Big Tank Pick 3×8 Foot Oval Tank Cover 2-Pack: 3×8 foot oval 2-pack with zipper for 300-gallon ovals. Check price on Amazon
| Cover | Size | Fit |
|---|---|---|
| Rubermaid 150 Gal Trough Cover | 61 x 42 x 9.5 in | 150 gallon oval |
| iBirdie 2x2x4 Stock Tank Cover | 49 x 26 x 12 in | 2 x 2 x 4 tank |
| 3×8 Foot Oval Tank Cover 2-Pack | 97 x 37 x 12 in | 300 gallon oval |
| 3×8 Oval Stock Tank Cover 2X | 97 x 37 x 12 in | 300 gallon oval |
| 2Pack Outdoor Faucet Covers | 8.5 x 6.7 x 2 in | Faucets, not troughs |
Scores are our own rankings; all figures come from the listings.
Best water trough cover for winter: five compared
The Rubermaid 150 gallon oval cover leads: 61 by 42 by 9.5 inches with a zipper, made for the 150-gallon oval stock tank. The iBirdie 2x2x4 cover is the small-tank pick: 49 by 26 by 12 inches, 1.5 pounds, with a 1 year manufacturer warranty. The two 3×8 foot oval covers are the big-tank picks: 97 by 37 by 12 inches for 300-gallon ovals, sold as 2-packs with zippers. The faucet covers are the outlier: 8.5 by 6.7 by 2 inches for outdoor faucets, not troughs.
Rubermaid 150 Gal Trough Cover
The Rubermaid 150 gallon oval stock tank cover with zipper: 61 by 42 by 9.5 inches. It suits the 150-gallon oval trough.
iBirdie 2x2x4 Stock Tank Cover
The iBirdie 2 by 2 by 4 stock tank cover: 49 by 26 by 12 inches, 1.5 pounds, 1 year manufacturer warranty. It suits smaller tanks.
3×8 Foot Oval Tank Cover 2-Pack
The 3×8 foot oval stock tank pool cover with zipper: 97 by 37 by 12 inches, 2-pack, for 300-gallon ovals.
3×8 Oval Stock Tank Cover 2X
The second 3×8 foot oval cover: 97 by 37 by 12 inches, 2-pack with zipper, for 300-gallon ovals.
2Pack Outdoor Faucet Covers
The 2-pack outdoor faucet covers for winter: 8.5 by 6.7 by 2 inches. They suit faucets and spigots, not water troughs.
FAQs from goat keepers
What size cover fits a 150-gallon oval trough?
The Rubermaid 150 gallon cover: 61 by 42 by 9.5 inches with a zipper.
Which cover has a warranty?
The iBirdie 2x2x4: 1 year manufacturer warranty.
Which covers fit 300-gallon ovals?
The two 3×8 foot oval covers: 97 by 37 by 12 inches, 2-packs with zippers.
Do I need a zipper on a trough cover?
A zipper gives access to the water without removing the whole cover, which matters in winter.
Can I use faucet covers on a trough?
No. At 8.5 by 6.7 by 2 inches they fit faucets, not troughs.
More from the barn
See every goat feeding and water guide and all heated water bucket guides.
More picks: heated bucket vs heated base and stainless steel vs galvanized water trough.
More picks to compare
Rubermaid 150 Gal CoverAnother 150-gallon oval stock tank cover with zipper access: 61 by 42 by 9.5 inches for winter use.Check on Amazon
Rubermaid 150 Gal Cover PlusA 150-gallon oval stock tank cover with zipper access: 61 by 42 by 12 inches for winter use.Check on Amazon
100 Gallon 600D Tank CoverA 100-gallon stock tank cover in 600D waterproof fabric: 54 by 35 by 10 inches for winter use.Check on Amazon
