
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
TheMilkman Cultured Butter and Buttermilk Starter Culture9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
TOFUDEE Tofu and Paneer Press with Adjustable Dial and Drip9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
SHSH Gouda Hard Cheese Mold for Press9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Kilner Silicone Butter Mold SetView on Amazon - 5
OHOLA Silicone Butter Mold Tray with LidsView on Amazon - 6
Silicone Butter Molds with Lid & SpatulasView on Amazon - 7
Silicone Butter MoldsView on Amazon - 8
Butter Mold With Stainless Steel FrameView on Amazon - 9
2Pack Butter Silicone Mold Tray with LidView on Amazon
The morning milking is done, the cream is churned, and the fresh butter needs shaping before it goes in the fridge. Butter mold vs butter press is the question of how the pat gets its shape, and the short answer is this: a mold forms butter inside a cavity, while a press stamps a pattern onto it. The Kilner set below does both, with pattern plates you press into the mold, and the other three are cavity molds with lids. Four silicone butter molds are compared here by capacity, markings, extras and materials, using only what each listing publishes.
Also worth comparing
Kilner Silicone Butter Mold SetCheck price on Amazon
OHOLA Silicone Butter Mold Tray with LidsCheck price on Amazon
Silicone Butter Molds with Lid & SpatulasCheck price on Amazon
Silicone Butter MoldsCheck price on Amazon
Butter Mold With Stainless Steel FrameCheck price on Amazon
2Pack Butter Silicone Mold Tray with LidCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Butter mold vs butter press: the short answer
A butter mold is a cavity you fill: you pack soft butter in, chill it, and pop out a shaped stick or block. All four listings here are molds of this kind, made from silicone with non-stick release. A butter press, in the traditional sense, is a stamp that presses a design into the top of a formed pat. None of the four is a standalone press, but the Kilner set includes 2 interchangeable pattern plates, a Farm design and a Butter text design, that you press into the mold to stamp the butter. So if you want shaped sticks, any of the four molds does the job; if you want a stamped pattern, the Kilner is the only one here that presses one.
Four butter molds compared
| Mold | Capacity | Markings | Extras | Size |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kilner Silicone Butter Mold | Standard stick | 2 pattern plates | Dishwasher safe | 5.51 x 2.95 x 1.77 in |
| Ptalniy Silicone Butter Mold | 4 sticks, 16 oz | Tbsp marks | Lid, spatulas | 6.7 x 5.7 x 1.3 in |
| UIRNCO Silicone Butter Mold | 16 oz | None stated | Lid, 2 spatulas | 6.8 x 5.7 x 1.3 in |
| Ohola Silicone Butter Mold | Not stated | None stated | Lid | 7 x 5.9 x 1.53 in |
Kilner Silicone Butter Mold: the mold that also presses
The Kilner is the top pick here because it answers both halves of the question. The gray silicone mold measures 5.51 by 2.95 by 1.77 in, sized for a standard stick of butter, and the 2 pattern plates press a Farm design or Butter text design into it. It is dishwasher safe and weighs 82 g. One oddity: the spec table gives dimensions of 6.7 by 3.9 by 2.8 in, which do not match the bullets, so treat the exact size as uncertain and trust the bullets.
Ptalniy Silicone Butter Mold: the measurer
The Ptalniy makes 4 large butter sticks at about 8 tbsp each, with tbsp marks on the sides and bottom of each cavity for portioning. It holds 16 oz, includes a silicone lid and plastic spatulas, and the silicone withstands -40℉ to 446℉, so it goes from freezer to microwave. The purple mold measures 6.7 by 5.7 by 1.3 in at 6.4 oz, and BPA free is stated.
UIRNCO Silicone Butter Mold: the set with spreaders
The UIRNCO set pairs an orange silicone mold with a sealed lid and 2 white plastic butter spreaders for mixing and spreading. It holds 16 oz, measures 6.8 by 5.7 by 1.3 in at 6.72 oz, and the non-stick silicone is safe for fridge, freezer and dishwasher. BPA free is stated. It has no measurement marks, so portioning is by eye.
Ohola Silicone Butter Mold: the simple lidded tray
The Ohola is an orange silicone mold with a lid for keeping butter fresh in the fridge, at 7 by 5.9 by 1.53 in and 0.19 kg. Food-grade silicone and dishwasher-safe care are stated. One contradiction to note: the spec table lists Material Type Free as Not Silicone while the material is silicone, and it lists a stainless steel closure material for a silicone lid; the title and bullets describe a silicone mold with a lid, so we trust those.
What to check before you buy
Capacity is the first number to check. The Ptalniy states 4 sticks at about 8 tbsp each and 16 oz, the UIRNCO states 16 oz, the Kilner is sized for a standard stick, and the Ohola states no capacity. If you churn in volume, the 16 oz molds hold a bigger batch; if you make a stick at a time, the Kilner fits the standard shape. Only the Ptalniy states tbsp markings, which matter if you portion for baking.
Lids and extras come next. The Ptalniy, UIRNCO and Ohola all include a lid, which keeps the butter from picking up fridge odors; the Kilner listing mentions no lid. The Ptalniy and UIRNCO add plastic spatulas or spreaders. All four describe dishwasher-safe silicone, so cleanup is the same chore either way. If you are just starting out with homemade butter, our butter making kit for beginners guide covers the churning side.
Read the spec table against the bullets before ordering. The Kilner bullets give 5.51 by 2.95 by 1.77 in while its spec table gives 6.7 by 3.9 by 2.8 in. The Ohola spec table says Not Silicone in one field while every other field says silicone. When the two disagree, the bullets describe the product and the table is the one to question.
FAQs from goat keepers
What is the difference between a butter mold and a butter press?
A mold shapes butter inside a cavity; a press stamps a pattern onto formed butter. The Kilner set here does both, with pattern plates you press into the mold.
How much butter do these molds hold?
The Ptalniy makes 4 sticks at about 8 tbsp each and holds 16 oz; the UIRNCO holds 16 oz. The Kilner fits a standard stick, and the Ohola states no capacity.
Are silicone butter molds dishwasher safe?
Dishwasher-safe care is stated for the Kilner, Ohola and Ptalniy, and the UIRNCO bullets say the mold is safe in the dishwasher.
Do any of these molds have measurement markings?
Only the Ptalniy states tbsp markings on the sides and bottom of each cavity. The other three state no markings.
More from the barn
See every cheese making kits guide and all milking guides. Also see our butter making kit for beginners and butter making kit for kids guides.
More picks: butter making kits for kids, milk filter socks vs filter discs and milking stools for homesteads.
