Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Cheese Making Kit vs Cheese Press: Which One Should You Buy?

Cheese making kit vs cheese press: what each one includes, when a press matters, and which suits beginners, with figures from real listings.

Cheese Making Kit vs Cheese Press: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1New England Mozzarella and Ricotta Cheese Making KitNew England Mozzarella and Ricotta Cheese Making Kit9.5/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Big Cheese Vegan Cheese Making KitBig Cheese Vegan Cheese Making Kit9.5/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Euro Cuisine YM80 Electric Yogurt Maker with 7 Glass JarsEuro Cuisine YM80 Electric Yogurt Maker with 7 Glass Jars9.7/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Ricki's Goat Cheese KitRicki's Goat Cheese KitView on Amazon
  5. 516 pcs Cheese Making Kit for Beginners16 pcs Cheese Making Kit for BeginnersView on Amazon
  6. 6Beginner Cheese Making KitBeginner Cheese Making KitView on Amazon
  7. 7The Big Cheese Beer Lover's Cheese Making Kit 12 BatchesThe Big Cheese Beer Lover's Cheese Making Kit 12 BatchesView on Amazon

The cheese making kit vs cheese press decision is simple: a kit bundles the supplies you need to start making cheese at home, while a press is a single tool that presses curds inside a mold to make firm cheese. Buy a kit if you are starting from scratch; buy a press if you already have cultures, rennet and molds and want to make hard cheese. The listings we checked make the split clear: the New England Cheesemaking mozzarella kit packs 3-ounce citric acid, 3-ounce cheese salt, 5 rennet tablets, 1 yard of butter muslin, a thermometer and a recipe booklet, enough for 20 one-pound batches, while the Grand Way set is a cheese mold with a follower and cheesecloth, a 1.5 L mold the maker says is designed to sustain cheese press weights.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Cheese making kit vs cheese press: the short answer

A kit is a starter bundle: ingredients, tools and recipes in one box. A press is pressing hardware: a mold, a follower and a way to apply steady weight to curds so they knit into a firm wheel. You need a kit once, when you begin; you need a press whenever you make pressed cheeses, which is a style choice rather than a beginner step. Soft cheeses such as mozzarella need no press at all: the New England Cheesemaking kit promises mozzarella in 30 minutes and lists no press among its contents.

What a cheese making kit includes

A full kit covers ingredients, tools and instructions. The New England Cheesemaking mozzarella and ricotta kit includes 3-ounce citric acid, 3-ounce cheese salt, 5 tablets of vegetable rennet, 1 yard of butter muslin, a thermometer and a recipe booklet, weighs 8 ounces, and the maker says it makes 20 one-pound batches with everything included except for the milk. Ricki’s Goat Cheese Kit from the same maker contains 4 goat cheese molds, a 5 pack of chevre culture, 1 yard of reusable butter muslin, a thermometer and a recipe booklet, listed as a 12 piece set at 0.32 kg.

Culture kits are narrower: the Cultures for Health mesophilic starter includes 4 packets of starter culture and 2 rennet tablets, enough for four batches, and the maker says you can culture 5 to 10 gallons of milk in one big batch. The thermophilic starter from the same maker is 4 packets plus 2 rennet tablets, with 2 gallons of milk yielding 10 servings of mozzarella. The Big Cheese vegan kit takes a different path: 20 batches of dairy-free cheese in 6 styles, 610 g, with agar powder as the rennet substitute and no special equipment needed.

What a cheese press does

A press applies steady weight to curds inside a mold, driving out whey so the curd knits into a firm wheel. That step is what separates pressed styles, semi-hard and hard cheeses, from soft ones. The Grand Way set shows the hardware: a cheese mold with a press follower and cheesecloth, 1.5 L capacity, 5.9 by 5.9 by 2.76 inches, 6.4 ounces, made of food grade polypropylene, and the maker states the mold is designed to sustain cheese press weights. Its own bullets call the mold ideal for semi-hard and hard cheeses.

Note what a press does not do: it adds no flavor, no culture and no rennet. It only shapes and firms. If your goal is fresh chevre or mozzarella, a press sits unused; if your goal is a firm wheel that ages, there is no substitute for pressing.

Rennet, cultures and the ingredient question

Kits include the biology; presses assume you already have it. Rennet listings show the range: Danisco sells 10 tablets of vegetable rennet for cheesemaking, and the QG group liquid rennet is a 3 fl oz (88 ml) bottle dosed at 1/2 capful per gallon of milk. Cultures come as direct-set packets, 4 packets plus 2 rennet tablets in both Cultures for Health starters, with the mesophilic version covering feta, farmer cheese, cheddar and more, and the thermophilic version covering parmesan, mozzarella, asiago and swiss.

When you compare a kit against buying a press, ask which side of this list you already own. If the answer is none of it, the kit is the economical route: the New England Cheesemaking mozzarella kit alone covers acid, salt, rennet, cloth, thermometer and recipes. If you already buy cultures and rennet separately, the press hardware is the missing piece.

Cheesecloth and molds

Both sides of the comparison need cloth and molds, but they buy them differently. Cloth listings give concrete specs: the Olicity cheesecloth is 36 by 36 inches, 9 square feet, grade 100 with a 56 by 41 thread count, at 40 g; the FUMILE set is 30 cloths at 20 by 20 inches with 45 by 55 yarns per inch, at 0.46 kg. The Grand Way pressing set includes its own 39 by 36 inch 100% cotton cheesecloth, and Ricki’s kit includes 4 goat cheese molds plus 1 yard of reusable butter muslin.

Cloth lines the mold so curds release cleanly, and the mold gives the wheel its shape. A kit buyer gets these as part of the bundle; a press buyer chooses them to fit the mold, which is why press listings like the Grand Way quote mold capacity in liters and dimensions in inches.

Who should buy which

Buy a cheese making kit if you are starting from zero. The New England Cheesemaking mozzarella kit and Ricki’s Goat Cheese Kit both bundle ingredients, tools and a recipe booklet, and the Cultures for Health starters cover the culture side for 4 batches at a time. See our best cheese making kit for beginners picks for the full comparison.

Buy a cheese press if you already make cheese and want firm wheels. Pressing hardware such as the Grand Way mold, follower and cloth set is what turns curds into semi-hard and hard cheese, and it pairs with whatever cultures and rennet you already buy. See our best cheese press for hard cheeses picks.

Dairy-free makers have a third option: the Big Cheese vegan kit makes 20 batches across 6 styles with no special equipment, so neither a dairy kit nor a press is required.

Read the listing twice

Listings blur the kit-versus-press line, so check the contents before you buy. The Grand Way product is titled a cheese making kit, but its included components are a cheese mold with a press follower and cheesecloth, no cultures, no rennet, no thermometer: it is pressing hardware, not a full cheesemaking kit. The QG group rennet spec table lists a unit count of 5072.1 fluid ounces against a 3 fl oz bottle in the title; trust the title and bullets. The Cultures for Health thermophilic listing gives a size of 0.06 ounces in the spec table, an obvious data oddity; the bullets’ 4 packets plus 2 tablets are the figure to use.

FAQs from goat keepers

Do I need a cheese press to make mozzarella?

No. The New England Cheesemaking mozzarella kit lists no press and promises mozzarella in 30 minutes with citric acid, rennet, muslin and a thermometer.

What do cheese making kits not include?

Milk. The New England Cheesemaking kit states everything is included except for the milk, and the other kits list no milk either.

Can a kit make hard cheese?

The Grand Way mold set is listed as ideal for semi-hard and hard cheeses, but full ingredient kits focus on soft and semi-soft styles. Hard cheese also needs pressing hardware and aging time.

More from the barn

See every cheese making kit guide and all milking guides.

More picks: cheese making kits for beginners, cheese presses for hard cheeses and cheesecloth for straining whey.