Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Electric vs Treadle Spinning Wheel: Which One Should You Buy?

Electric vs treadle spinning wheel, compared on motor control, speed, bobbins and fibers, with the prize wheel name clash cleared up for yarn work.

Electric vs Treadle Spinning Wheel: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Yoption Wooden Spinning Wheel with StandYoption Wooden Spinning Wheel with Stand9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2GSOW 20-Inch Spinning Prize Wheel with Adjustable Tripod StandGSOW 20-Inch Spinning Prize Wheel with Adjustable Tripod Stand9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3GADFISH 24 Inch Spinning Prize Wheel with Adjustable 37 to 65GADFISH 24 Inch Spinning Prize Wheel with Adjustable 37 to 659.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Electric Yarn Spinner Winder Spinning Wheel for Wool with 3Electric Yarn Spinner Winder Spinning Wheel for Wool with 3View on Amazon
  5. 5YARNIC Electric Spinning Wheel with Foot PedalYARNIC Electric Spinning Wheel with Foot PedalView on Amazon
  6. 6AUTUMFLATGAO Smart Yarn Spinner MachineAUTUMFLATGAO Smart Yarn Spinner MachineView on Amazon
  7. 7Electric Wool Carder MachineElectric Wool Carder MachineView on Amazon

Morning chores leave wool in a basket by the barn door, and the fiber still needs twist before it becomes yarn for the house. This guide covers electric vs treadle spinning wheel choices by power, control, direction, bobbins and fibers, so you can match the wheel to the yarn work you have in mind. The compared set includes electric yarn spinners and no treadle yarn spinner, so treadle figures are Not stated here and the electric figures carry the comparison. Choose electric for motor control with a foot switch and reverse for plying, and choose treadle for foot powered turning with no motor to plug in.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Electric vs treadle spinning wheel: the short answer

Start with power, then check control, then check bobbins and fibers. An electric spinner suits yarn work where you want the motor to turn the wheel while your hands draft fiber, with speed set by a knob or foot switch and direction set for singles or plying. A treadle wheel suits yarn work where you want your feet to turn the wheel and your hands to draft, with no motor and no power supply in the setup. Because the compared set has no treadle yarn spinner, treadle speed, size and bobbin figures are Not stated here, so compare treadle listings on their own stated figures before you buy.

If you would rather go straight to the products, our best spinning wheel roundup compares wheels on these points.

Power types compared

Power type Example listing Stated speed Control
Electric Gokoudia Electric Yarn Spinner Kit up to 800RPM Foot switch, stepless speed, forward and reverse
Electric HNZVWH Electric Yarn Spinner up to 800RPM Stepless speed, forward and reverse
Treadle No treadle yarn spinner in the compared set Not stated Foot powered, no motor

Electric yarn spinners

The Gokoudia Electric Yarn Spinner Kit and the HNZVWH Electric Yarn Spinner are the electric side of this comparison. Each maker lists a 2-in-1 electric spinning wheel that twists wool fibers into yarn and winds yarn cakes, with forward and reverse for single and plied work. The Gokoudia kit lists 4 Bobbins and a foot controller in Blue, and the HNZVWH spinner lists 3 Bobbins in Black. The Gokoudia ranks ahead here on bobbin count, with 4 Bobbins against 3 Bobbins, while speed and fibers match between the pair. Each maker lists wool, cotton, linen and silk as fibers the machine supports.

Treadle wheels

A treadle wheel is turned by foot power through a treadle, so the wheel moves as you treadle and stops as you stop, with no motor in the drive. That setup suits spinners who want foot control of pace and a wheel that runs with no power supply. No treadle yarn spinner is in the compared set, so treadle speed, bobbin count, size and fiber figures are Not stated here. Read a treadle listing for its own stated drive, bobbin and size figures, and compare those figures with the electric figures in this guide.

Prize wheels with the same name

The Retbtnm Prize Wheel and the WHAUU Prize Wheel share the words spinning wheel, but each maker lists a prize game wheel, not a yarn tool. The Retbtnm wheel lists 24 inch size, 14 Color Slots and height adjustable from 47 to 80 inches, with a marker and eraser for game content. The WHAUU wheel lists 24 Inch size, 12 color slots and height adjustable from 47 to 61 inches, with a dry erase kit and a disk that detaches into 4 panels. Neither prize wheel twists fiber or winds yarn, so neither belongs on the electric side or the treadle side of a yarn comparison.

Speed, control and direction

Speed on the electric side is stated as a maker rated maximum. Each electric maker lists a steel tube motor with a maximum speed of up to 800RPM and stepless speed adjustment, so speed is set across a range up to that figure. The Gokoudia maker lists a foot switch that frees your hands and a stepless speed knob. The HNZVWH maker lists soft start, a snap-in flywheel bearing, a sliding hook flywheel and a frictionless yarn guide. Treat 800RPM as the stated maximum for each electric spinner, not as a measured yarn result.

Direction decides singles and plying. The Gokoudia maker lists forward and reverse dual-mode spinning for single stranded yarn or double-stranded twisting. The HNZVWH maker lists Z-twist for single strand and S-twist for plied yarn, with forward and reverse switching. A treadle wheel changes direction by treadling direction, with no switch figures stated here. If plying is part of your yarn work, check that the listing states reverse or a plied setting in plain words.

Bobbins, winding and fibers

Bobbin count sets how much singles yarn you can hold before plying or winding off. The Gokoudia kit lists 4 Bobbins, and the HNZVWH spinner lists 3 Bobbins, so the Gokoudia holds an extra bobbin in the box as listed. Each electric maker lists a yarn winding function that makes yarn cakes, which pairs with a separate yarn winder for wool if you wind skeins apart from spinning. Bobbin capacity in weight or length is Not stated for either electric spinner.

Fiber support is stated by fiber name. Each electric maker lists wool, cotton, linen and silk, and each lists gradient color and mixed color yarn, with the HNZVWH maker also listing pure color yarn. Those are maker stated fiber names, not a promise for every preparation or staple length. Treadle fiber support is Not stated here, so check a treadle listing for the fibers and yarn types it names.

Size, power supply and placement

Size for the electric spinners is stated as One Size, with no usable footprint in the stated figures, so bench space and storage size are Not stated here. Power is stated as 12V for each electric spinner, with the maker stating connection to an external mobile power supply for outdoor spinning. That 12V figure belongs to the electric side only. A treadle wheel needs floor space for the wheel and treadle and a chair or stool at working height, with size figures Not stated here.

Placement follows power. An electric spinner goes where the 12V supply and foot switch cord reach, on a table or bench as the maker directs. A treadle wheel goes where you can treadle without hitting the wheel or nearby furniture. Measure your bench or floor space and compare it with the size figures a listing states, and allow for bobbins, fiber and finished yarn beside the wheel.

Read the stated figures twice

Stated figures in this set conflict in places that change what you receive, so check size and count before ordering:

  • Gokoudia: the maker gives a size of One Size and dimensions of 0.39 inches; check the size before ordering.
  • HNZVWH: the maker gives a size of One Size and dimensions of 0.39 inches; check the size before ordering.
  • Retbtnm: the maker gives 24 inches and dimensions of 23.0 inches by 23.0 inches by 35.0 inches; check before ordering.
  • WHAUU: the maker gives 24 Inch and dimensions of 12.2 inches by 5.31 inches by 16.93 inches; check before ordering.

For yarn work, the size conflict that matters is the electric spinner footprint, because One Size and 0.39 inches cannot both describe the working machine. Ask the seller for the working size in plain figures, and keep the 800RPM, 12V and bobbin figures tied to the spinner they belong to.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers wheel power and stated spinning figures only. It does not cover yarn quality, fiber preparation, animal care or any health question. Ask a local fiber guild or extension office about fiber preparation and animal care.

FAQs from goat keepers

What is the difference between electric and treadle spinning wheels?

An electric spinner uses a motor, stated here at up to 800RPM with 12V power, stepless speed and forward and reverse. A treadle wheel uses foot power with no motor, and treadle figures are Not stated in the compared set.

Can an electric spinning wheel ply yarn?

Each electric maker lists forward and reverse for plying work. The Gokoudia maker lists single stranded or double-stranded twisting, and the HNZVWH maker lists Z-twist single strand and S-twist plied yarn.

How many bobbins do the electric spinners include?

The Gokoudia kit lists 4 Bobbins in Blue. The HNZVWH spinner lists 3 Bobbins in Black. Bobbin capacity by weight or length is Not stated for either spinner.

Is a prize wheel a spinning wheel for yarn?

No. The Retbtnm wheel lists 14 Color Slots and height from 47 to 80 inches, and the WHAUU wheel lists 12 color slots and height from 47 to 61 inches. Each is a prize game wheel, not a fiber tool.

More from the barn

See every spinning guide and all wool and fiber guides.

More picks: best spinning wheels, mini spinning wheels, yarn winders for wool and drop spindle vs spinning wheel.