
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Olicity Grade 90 Cheesecloth9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
POYAKU Water Bottle 40 oz9.2/10View on Amazon
After the morning milking, when the milk still needs straining before it goes into the jar, the grade 40 vs grade 90 cheesecloth question decides which weave to reach for. The listings in this comparison do not line up neatly: one describes a genuine cheesecloth roll, and the other describes an insulated water bottle. This comparison sets out what each listing actually states, so a buyer can see which side has real cloth behind it.
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick verdict: choose the grade 90 side for straining, as the Olicity example shows with its 44×36 thread count and a tighter weave that strains with one layer instead of three. Do not buy the grade 40 example for straining at all: its listing describes an insulated water bottle, not cloth, so it cannot answer the grade 40 question. A buyer who specifically wants grade 40 cheesecloth should look for a listing that actually describes cheesecloth before ordering.
Two examples

Olicity Grade 90 Cheesecloth
A reusable unbleached cotton cheesecloth roll with a stated 44x36 thread count, for straining foods and cooking.
Pros
- Grade 90 weave with a stated 44x36 thread count
- Tighter weave means one layer instead of three when straining, as stated
- Closed edges with no shed lint, as stated
- Reusable with a simple rinse, as stated
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- No safety certification is stated
- No pre-cut sheets are listed; the roll must be cut to a desired size
- Reuse needs a simple rinse each time, as stated

POYAKU Water Bottle 40 oz
An insulated stainless steel water bottle, not a cheesecloth, whose listing states cold up to 24 hours and hot up to 12 hours.
Pros
- Food grade 18/8 stainless steel, BPA-free, as stated
- Keeps drinks cold up to 24 hours and hot up to 12 hours, as stated
- Comes with 3 lids, 2 straws and 1 straw brush, as stated
- Lifetime warranty, as stated
Cons
- Not a cheesecloth: no thread count, weave or straining use is stated
- No weight is stated in the listing
- The title lists 4 sizes, so the buyer must pick the 40 oz Indigo Crush variant
- Its lids suit drinking on the go, not straining
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Also worth comparing
CheeseclothCheck price on Amazon
Cheesecloth RollCheck price on Amazon
Bememo 1 Roll Bleached Cheesecloth 100% Cotton BulkCheck price on Amazon
DeRoyal BIDF4436350-BX Grade 90 Extra Fine Weave StrainerCheck price on Amazon
8 PCS Reusable CheeseclothCheck price on Amazon
Grade 40 vs grade 90 cheesecloth: side by side
| Cheesecloth | GoatGear Score | Grade | Thread count | Size | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Olicity Grade 90 Cheesecloth | 9.5/10 | Grade 90 | 44×36 | 3x45Ft, 135 Sq Ft | 1.2 pounds |
| POYAKU Water Bottle 40 oz | 9.2/10 | Not stated | Not stated | 40 Ounces | Not stated |
Every spec repeats the brand’s rating from its listing (collected on 4 November 2026).
What grade 90 means in the Olicity listing
Grade 90, in this listing, means a tighter weave: the Olicity cloth features a 44×36 thread count, and the listing states that the higher threads per square inch give a tighter weave. That tighter weave means one layer instead of three when straining foods, which matters at the pail, since layering and re-layering cloth wastes time during a chore that already has enough steps. The cloth is 100% natural pure cotton, unbleached, with closed edges that prevent small threads from dropping into food, and the listing states no odor, no lint and no chemicals.
The uses named in the listing cover the dairy routine and the kitchen alike: straining almond milk, cold brew coffee and juice, stuffing poultry, wrapping spices, and crafting projects. The roll measures 3x45Ft, or 135 Sq Ft, and can be cut freely to a desired size, so one roll can serve many strainings. The listing also states the cloth can be reused many times with a simple rinse, which makes the roll a repeat-use tool rather than a single-use sheet.
What the grade 40 example actually is
The grade 40 example is not a cheesecloth at all. Its listing describes a POYAKU insulated water bottle in Indigo Crush, size 40 Ounces, made of food grade 18/8 stainless steel with double walls and vacuum copper plating. It keeps drinks cold up to 24 hours and hot up to 12 hours, and it comes with 3 lids that can be switched, 2 straws and 1 straw brush. Nothing in the listing mentions cheesecloth, a weave grade, a thread count or straining, so there is no grade 40 cloth figure here to compare against the grade 90 roll.
The 40 in its title is the 40 oz size, not a cloth grade. The same title lists 32oz, 40oz, 64oz and 128oz options, and this listing is the Indigo Crush 40 oz variant, so a buyer must confirm the size when ordering. Judged as a bottle, the listing is detailed: a straw lid for office and hiking, a spout lid for the beach and camping, and a push-button lid for one-handed drinking. Judged as cheesecloth, it simply does not enter the comparison, and calling it the grade 40 side would mislead a buyer who needs cloth.
Size, weight and the box
On size, the two listings cannot be set side by side, because they measure different things. The Olicity roll measures 3x45Ft, or 135 Sq Ft, with a spec table size of 36 x 540 inch, and it weighs 1.2 pounds. The POYAKU bottle measures 3.95 Inches x 3.95 Inches x 13.3 Inches, and its listing states no weight at all, so the weight comparison ends there.
On the box, the bottle listing is the fuller of the two: 1 water bottle, 3 lids, 2 straws and 1 straw brush. The cloth listing describes one roll, cut freely to a desired size, with no separate pieces in the box. A buyer comparing the two on contents alone would be comparing a bottle kit with a roll of cloth, which is another sign that these listings belong to different searches.
Warranty and listing gaps to check
On warranty, the bottle leads clearly: its listing states a lifetime warranty, while the Olicity listing states no warranty term at all, so the cloth earns no warranty points in the score. On safety features, the bottle lists food grade 18/8 stainless steel that is BPA-free, while the cloth listing states no certification, so the cloth earns no safety points either.
The gaps go further. The bottle listing gives no thread count, no weave and no straining use, so it cannot settle any cheesecloth question. The cloth listing gives no warranty and no pre-cut sizes, and its spec table lists 3 under NumberOfItems while the title describes one roll, so a buyer should confirm the pack count on the listing before ordering. If any of those points decides a purchase, ask the seller before ordering.
Which should you choose?
Choose grade 90 cheesecloth if the job is straining milk, juice or cold brew coffee through a tighter weave that works in one layer, as the Olicity roll shows with its 44×36 thread count, closed edges and reusable cotton. For more cloth options, see the cheesecloth for straining milk picks.
Choose the grade 40 example if the need is actually an insulated bottle for sports, gym or office use, with cold up to 24 hours and hot up to 12 hours, as the POYAKU listing shows with its 3 lids and lifetime warranty. Do not choose it for straining: no cloth, thread count or grade is stated in its listing. Whichever side fits the job, check the listing itself before ordering, since the grade 40 example here is not a cloth grade.
Around the Barn
- Rinse the cheesecloth after use: the listing states it can be reused many times with a simple rinse.
- Cut the roll to the size needed: the listing states it can be cut freely to a desired size.
- Check the bottle lid before carrying: the listing states 3 lids that seal well.
- Keep the straw brush with the bottle: the box includes 2 straws and 1 straw brush, as stated.
FAQs from goat keepers
Is grade 90 cheesecloth finer than grade 40?
From these listings, the comparison cannot be made on fineness. The grade 90 listing states a 44×36 thread count and a tighter weave, while the grade 40 example listing describes a water bottle and states no thread count at all.
Can the grade 40 example strain milk?
No. Its listing describes an insulated water bottle for drinks, with no cloth, no thread count and no straining use. For straining, the grade 90 roll in this comparison is the only cloth listed.
How much cloth is in the Olicity roll?
The listing states 3x45Ft, or 135 Sq Ft, and the roll can be cut freely to a desired size. It is reusable with a simple rinse, as stated.
What comes with the POYAKU bottle?
The listing states 1 water bottle, 3 lids, 2 straws and 1 straw brush. It keeps drinks cold up to 24 hours and hot up to 12 hours, as stated.
Does either listing state a warranty?
The bottle listing states a lifetime warranty. The cheesecloth listing states no warranty term.
Behind the Farm Score
| Product | GoatGear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Olicity Grade 90 Cheesecloth | 9.5 | 30 | 21 | 21 | 0 | 0 |
| POYAKU Water Bottle 40 oz | 9.2 | 9 | 20 | 12 | 5 | 4 |
We translate each weighted point total onto the 9.2 through 9.8 band; ranks never flip, because the conversion is linear.
The GoatGear Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For cheesecloth, safety points need a stated certification or a stated food-safety feature; the bottle lists food grade BPA-free steel, while the cloth listing states none, so the cloth scores zero there. The bottle states a lifetime warranty and the cloth states none, so the cloth scores zero on warranty too. The Olicity roll leads on performance for this search because it is the only actual cheesecloth here, with a stated 44×36 thread count and one-layer straining, while the bottle loses performance points for the search because its listing describes no cloth at all. How we pick explains the weights.
More from the barn
See every cheese making kit guide and all milking guides.
More picks: grade 40 cheesecloth, cheese press bag vs cheesecloth and bleached vs unbleached cheesecloth.
