
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Malco FP1 8 in. Fencing Pliers9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Arrow Electric Staple Gun9.5/10View on Amazon - 3
HAUSHOF Light Duty Staple GunView on Amazon - 4
HAUSHOF Light Duty Staple Gun with 800-Count JT21 Staples &View on Amazon - 5
SHALL Light Duty Staple Gun for WoodView on Amazon - 6
DEWALT Staple GunView on Amazon - 7
THINKWORK Light Duty Staple GunView on Amazon - 8
Arrow JT21CM Professional Light-Duty Staple Gun Chrome SteelView on Amazon
A hand staple gun fires when you squeeze the handle; an electric staple gun fires when you pull the trigger on a motor. For fence work, the hand vs electric staple gun question comes down to how much stapling the job needs: a hand gun suits repairs and short runs, while an electric gun suits long fence lines where squeezing wears out a hand. Every number below comes from an Amazon listing for a staple gun we compared, and all four listings here are manual guns, so read this as a guide to the hand side with notes on where electric drive changes the job.
Also worth comparing
HAUSHOF Light Duty Staple GunCheck price on Amazon
HAUSHOF Light Duty Staple Gun with 800-Count JT21 Staples &Check price on Amazon
SHALL Light Duty Staple Gun for WoodCheck price on Amazon
DEWALT Staple GunCheck price on Amazon
THINKWORK Light Duty Staple GunCheck price on Amazon
Arrow JT21CM Professional Light-Duty Staple Gun Chrome SteelCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Hand vs electric staple gun: the short answer
A hand staple gun is a spring and a lever: you squeeze, it fires one staple. An electric staple gun replaces your squeeze with a motor, so the firing effort stays the same from the first staple to the last. Pick a hand gun for fence repairs, short runs and jobs where you already carry hand tools; pick electric when the job is a whole fence line and the electric listings state the staple sizes you need. If you would rather go straight to the products, the gear section below ranks four hand staple guns on these points.
How each type fires
A manual gun stores your squeeze in a spring and releases it to drive the staple. The listings describe the details that make squeezing easier: the HAUSHOF has an ergonomic wide rubber hand slot with a non-slip groove and what it calls a linear power curve, and it weighs 9.5 oz for one-hand use. The pink SHALL is lighter still at 6.5 oz with an ergonomic wide rubber handle. The SHALL 3-in-1 adds a stepless knob for power adjustment instead of a high/low switch, plus laser-etched marks showing the staple outlet position.
An electric gun does the same job with a motor, so hand strength stops mattering. None of the four listings here is electric, which is worth knowing before you shop: if your fence line is long, look for electric listings that state the same staple types covered below, and compare their stated staple sizes against your wire and posts.
Staple types and sizes
Match the gun to the staple. The HAUSHOF and the pink SHALL take JT21 staples in 1/4, 5/16 and 3/8 in. The HAUSHOF listing gives uses for each length: 1/4 in for window screens and shades, shelf papers and closet lining; 5/16 in for light upholstery and thin materials; 3/8 in for insulation, weather stripping, wire mesh, carpet pads and canvas where material thickness runs up to about 3/16 in. The SHALL 3-in-1 takes D-type (T50) staples from 3/16 to 9/16 in, U-type (T18) from 3/8 to 1/2 in, and T-type brad nails from 3/8 to 9/16 in. The DEWALT is a 2-in-1 tacker, though its thin listing names no staple sizes.
| Staple gun | Staple types | Staples included | Weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| SHALL 3-in-1 | D (T50), U (T18), T (brad) | 3000 | 1.15 kg |
| HAUSHOF light duty | JT21: 1/4, 5/16, 3/8 in | 800 | 9.5 oz |
| SHALL pink light duty | JT21: 1/4, 5/16, 3/8 in | 1600 | 6.5 oz |
| DEWALT DWHT80276 | 2-in-1 tacker | Not stated | 2.4 ounces |
The gear: four hand staple guns ranked
Ranked by our scores, the SHALL 3-in-1 heavy duty gun leads: it takes D-type, U-type and T-type fasteners, ships with 3000 staples and a remover, and states a 365-day manufacturer warranty. Next is the HAUSHOF light duty gun with 800 JT21 staples of 5/16 in, a staple remover and a 9.5 oz body built for one-hand use. Third is the SHALL pink light duty gun: 1600 JT21 staples across the three sizes, a 6.5 oz body and dual high/low power. Last is the DEWALT DWHT80276 carbon fiber 2-in-1 tacker: the listing is thin, naming only the carbon fiber body and a 180-fastener magazine, so it scores on build but loses on stated detail.
Ergonomics separate the middle two. The HAUSHOF lists an ergonomic wide rubber hand slot, a quick-release bottom magazine latch and a reload window that shows when staples run low, plus a fixed clip that locks it for a tool pouch. The pink SHALL answers with a handle lock, an easy-load bottom magazine and the lightest body here at 6.5 oz. The SHALL 3-in-1 is the heaviest at 1.15 kg, but it is also the only one with a stated warranty and the only one that fires three fastener types.
Read the listing twice
Both SHALL listings contradict themselves on staple count: the 3-in-1 title and bullets promise 3000 staples while its spec table says 4000, and the pink gun’s title and bullets promise 1600 while its table also says 4000. Where a listing disagrees with itself, the title and bullets win, so this guide uses 3000 and 1600. The DEWALT listing is thin in the other direction: one bullet naming the carbon fiber body, with the rest of the detail in the spec table. For powered options, see our electric vs battery staple gun and electric vs pneumatic staple gun comparisons.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers staple gun hardware only. It does not cover fence design, wire choice or any animal question. It also does not score electric models; every listing compared here is a manual gun.
FAQs from goat keepers
Is a hand or electric staple gun better for goat fencing?
For repairs and short runs, a hand gun; all four listings here are manual. For a whole fence line, an electric gun saves squeezing; match its stated staple sizes to your wire and posts.
What staples do these guns take?
The HAUSHOF and pink SHALL take JT21 staples in 1/4, 5/16 and 3/8 in. The SHALL 3-in-1 takes D-type (T50) from 3/16 to 9/16 in, U-type (T18) from 3/8 to 1/2 in, and T-type brad nails from 3/8 to 9/16 in.
Do these staple guns come with staples?
Three do: 800 with the HAUSHOF, 3000 with the SHALL 3-in-1, and 1600 with the pink SHALL. The DEWALT listing does not state included staples.
Which staple gun has a warranty?
Only the SHALL 3-in-1: a 365-day manufacturer warranty. The other three listings state no warranty term.
More from the barn
See every fencing and shelter guide. Also see our best staple gun for fence repairs. Also see our fencing pliers vs staple gun. Also see our fence staples vs fence clips. Also see our galvanized vs stainless fence staples.
More picks: electric vs battery staple guns, electric vs pneumatic staple guns and electric fence chargers for goats.
