
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Premier 1 ExoTrim™ Serrated Hoof Trimmer Japanese high carbon9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
SZCO Supplies Dual Blade Hoof Knife with Hook and Clip-Point9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
Equine Care Right-Handed Hoof Knife9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
BOTH WINNERS Horse Hoof Pick Brush with Soft Touch HandleView on Amazon - 5
Tough 1 Great Grip Hoof Pick/Brush Brand: Tough 1View on Amazon - 6
BOTH WINNERS 4Pcs Horse Hoof Pick BrushesView on Amazon - 7
Tough 1 Metal Hoof Pick Brand: Tough 1View on Amazon - 8
2 Pcs Horse Hoof Pick BrushView on Amazon - 9
Weaver Leather Right-Handed Hoof Knife with Wooden HandleView on Amazon
A goat comes in from the pasture with mud packed into its hooves, and the chore is clearing it out before the next milking. For hoof pick vs hoof knife, the direct answer is a hoof pick when the job is clearing packed dirt and mud: every listing compared here is a pick with a hook for that job, plus a brush for further cleaning. A hoof knife is a separate tool, and none of the four listings compared here is one, so this guide compares the picks on hook, brush, handle and stated size.
Also worth comparing
BOTH WINNERS Horse Hoof Pick Brush with Soft Touch HandleCheck price on Amazon
Tough 1 Great Grip Hoof Pick/Brush Brand: Tough 1Check price on Amazon
BOTH WINNERS 4Pcs Horse Hoof Pick BrushesCheck price on Amazon
Tough 1 Metal Hoof Pick Brand: Tough 1Check price on Amazon
2 Pcs Horse Hoof Pick BrushCheck price on Amazon
Weaver Leather Right-Handed Hoof Knife with Wooden HandleCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Hoof pick vs hoof knife: the short answer
Buy a hoof pick for routine clearing of packed dirt and mud. All four listings below describe a hook that removes packed dirt and mud, paired with a brush or bristle for further cleaning, and they differ mainly in handle, stated size and whether they come singly or as a set of 4. One point to note before you buy: all four listings describe horse hoof picks, not goat-specific tools, and the Tough 1 listing names horse as the suggested user. If you decide the job needs a knife rather than a pick, our best hoof knife roundup covers knives.
Four hoof picks compared
| Pick | Hook and brush | Handle | Stated size |
|---|---|---|---|
| BOTH WINNERS single pick, purple | Steel hook, bristle brush | Soft touch handle | 6 x 2.5 x 0.5 inches, package |
| Wahl Comfort Grip Hoof Pick | Reinforced steel hook, nylon bristle | Rubber, soft touch | 1 x 1.75 x 7.5 inches |
| Tough 1 Great Grip Hoof Pick and Brush | Strong metal pick, stiff brush | Plastic, soft ergonomic | 7.5 x 3.5 x 1 inches |
| BOTH WINNERS 4-pack | Steel hook, bristle brush | Soft touch rubber | 8.43 x 4.17 x 1.73 inches, package |
BOTH WINNERS single pick, purple
The single BOTH WINNERS pick is a 2 in 1 pick and brush: the listing describes a steel hook that removes packed dirt and mud, with a bristle for further cleaning, and a soft touch handle. The listing also notes a small hole on the handle for hanging the pick when it is not in use, and says the brush can also clean mud from work boots or shoes. Only package dimensions are stated for this listing: 6 x 2.5 x 0.5 inches, with a stated weight of 0.32 ounces.
Wahl Comfort Grip Hoof Pick
The Wahl pick lists a reinforced steel hook for removing packed dirt and mud, a soft touch grip, and nylon bristle. Its handle material is rubber, its stated size is 1 x 1.75 x 7.5 inches, and its stated weight is 3.36 ounces. The listing also describes the design as non-slip and ergonomic, and states a 30 day satisfaction term. Color is black, and the listing sells a single pick.
Tough 1 Great Grip Hoof Pick and Brush
The Tough 1 pick lists a strong metal pick with a stiff brush, a soft ergonomically designed handle, and red color. Its handle material is plastic, its item dimensions are 7.5 x 3.5 x 1 inches, and its stated weight is 3.2 ounces. The listing names horse as the suggested user, and it sells a single pick.
BOTH WINNERS 4-pack
The BOTH WINNERS 4-pack is a set of 4 picks in four colors: neon green, royal blue, purple and red. Each pick is described the same way as the single BOTH WINNERS pick: a steel hook for packed dirt and mud, a bristle for further cleaning, and a soft touch rubber grip handle. The stated package dimensions are 8.43 x 4.17 x 1.73 inches, and the set suits a barn that wants more than one pick on hand, in different colors, for different stalls or users.
Handles, hooks and brushes
Every pick here pairs a metal hook with a brush, so the real differences are in the handle and the brush. The two BOTH WINNERS listings describe a soft touch handle or soft touch rubber grip handle, and say the grip is good to hold when the weather is cold or when hands are wet. The Wahl listing lists a rubber handle with a soft touch grip and describes the design as non-slip and ergonomic. The Tough 1 listing lists a plastic handle with a soft ergonomically designed shape, and pairs it with a stiff brush, while the other three listings describe a bristle brush. If a stiff brush matters to you, the Tough 1 listing is the only one that names one; if a rubber grip matters, the Wahl and BOTH WINNERS 4-pack listings name rubber.
Stated sizes and weights
Stated sizes vary more than the job does, so read them as listing figures, not as a ranking. The Wahl pick lists 1 x 1.75 x 7.5 inches at 3.36 ounces, and the Tough 1 pick lists 7.5 x 3.5 x 1 inches at 3.2 ounces. The single BOTH WINNERS pick lists package dimensions of 6 x 2.5 x 0.5 inches at 0.32 ounces, while the 4-pack lists package dimensions of 8.43 x 4.17 x 1.73 inches at 8.4 ounces for the set of 4. The single-pick weights and the set weight are not directly comparable, since one figure covers one pick and the other covers four, and the single BOTH WINNERS figure is a package figure. Compare the stated size against where the pick will hang: the single BOTH WINNERS pick notes a hanging hole on its handle, which suits a hook by the barn door.
Read the listing twice
Hoof pick listings contradict themselves in small ways, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan around:
- BOTH WINNERS 4-pack: item weight of 8.4 ounces against 8.47 ounces in the package dimensions line.
- BOTH WINNERS 4-pack: the spec table lists material as rubber, while the bullets describe a steel hook with a rubber handle. Trust the bullets: steel hook, rubber handle.
- Tough 1: item dimensions of 7.5 x 3.5 x 1 inches against package dimensions of 7.6 x 3.62 x 1.1 inches.
- BOTH WINNERS single pick: only package dimensions are stated, 6 x 2.5 x 0.5 inches, with no separate item dimensions.
Measure your hanging spot before ordering and allow for the larger figure. Listings also describe horse use throughout, so check the suggested user on the listing if you are buying for goats.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers cleaning tools only: hooks, brushes, handles and stated sizes. It does not cover hoof care procedures, trimming decisions or any animal health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about hoof care and goat health.
FAQs from goat keepers
Should I buy a hoof pick or a hoof knife?
Buy a hoof pick when the job is clearing packed dirt and mud: all four listings compared here describe a hook for that job, plus a brush for further cleaning. A hoof knife is a separate tool, and none of the four listings compared here is one.
Do I need the brush as well as the hook?
All four listings pair the hook with a brush or bristle, and describe the brush as the step for further cleaning after the hook removes packed dirt and mud. A pick without a brush is not among the listings compared here.
Which handle suits wet or cold hands?
The two BOTH WINNERS listings describe a soft touch grip handle that is good to hold when the weather is cold or when hands are wet. The Wahl listing lists a rubber handle with a soft touch grip and describes the design as non-slip, while the Tough 1 listing lists a plastic handle with a soft ergonomically designed shape.
Is one pick enough, or should I buy the 4-pack?
Three listings sell a single pick, while the BOTH WINNERS 4-pack sells a set of 4 picks in neon green, royal blue, purple and red. A single pick suits one hanging spot, while the set suits a barn that wants picks in more than one place.
Are these picks made for goats?
All four listings describe horse hoof picks, and the Tough 1 listing names horse as the suggested user. None of the four listings names goats, so check the suggested user on the listing before buying for a goat herd.
More from the barn
See every hoof trimmer guide and all grooming and handling guides.
More picks: best hoof knife, goat hoof trimmers, hoof knife vs hoof rasp and hoof rasps for goats.
