
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Lindy's Stainless Steel Seamless 1-Gallon Milk Jug with Tight9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
JoyJolt 32 Oz Glass Milk Bottles with Lids and Pourer9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Speak Naturals Half Gallon Plastic Milk Jug9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Jura 72570 Glass Milk ContainerView on Amazon - 5
Mumufy 24 Pcs 32 oz Plastic Milk Jugs with LidsView on Amazon - 6
The Dairy Shoppe Heavy Glass Milk BottlesView on Amazon
Morning milking leaves milk to strain, chill and store, and the vessel you pour into shapes how easy that chore stays. This guide answers milk jug vs milk can directly: the listings compared here are all jug-style containers for storing and serving milk, and none of them is listed as a milk can, so a buyer who wants a can should look past this set. The listings below are ranked by stated capacity, material, lid style and cleaning, and this guide flags where a listing disagrees with itself.
Also worth comparing
Jura 72570 Glass Milk ContainerCheck price on Amazon
Mumufy 24 Pcs 32 oz Plastic Milk Jugs with LidsCheck price on Amazon
The Dairy Shoppe Heavy Glass Milk BottlesCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Milk jug vs milk can: the short answer
Pick a jug-style listing here when the job is storing milk in the fridge and pouring it at the table. The Stock Your Home jug, the NETANY carafes and the Amrules pitcher all hold milk for storage or serving, with stated capacities from 12 ounces to 64 oz and materials of glass, plastic or stainless steel. No listing in this set uses the word can in its title, so a buyer who wants a can should check that the listing names a can and states its material and lid before buying.
In rank order, the listings below run from the Stock Your Home glass jug to the NETANY glass carafes, then the NETANY plastic carafes, with the Amrules frothing pitcher last for storage use.
Jug-style listings compared
| Listing | Stated capacity | Material | Lid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stock Your Home 64 oz Glass Bottle | 64 oz | Glass | 3 white caps |
| NETANY Set of 4 Glass Carafe | 1 liter | Glass | Acrylic lids |
| NETANY Plastic 50 Oz Water Carafe | 50 oz | Plastic | Flip lid |
| Amrules Milk Frothing Pitcher | 12 ounces | Stainless Steel | Not stated |
Capacities are stated by each maker in its own unit, and the listings do not convert between units, so compare the figures as stated rather than ranking by converted volume.
Stock Your Home glass jug
The Stock Your Home listing states a glass jug with a 64 oz capacity, 3 white caps, and a height of 10.5 inches with a length of 5 inches and a width of 3 13/16 inches. The maker lists the jug as dishwasher safe, reusable, stain resistant and odor resistant, and lead-free, while the caps are not dishwasher safe. The listing states the pack holds 1 jar with its caps for fridge storage of milk, honey, maple syrup, jam and sauces.
Read the capacity figures with care: the bullets state 64 oz, while the spec table lists capacity as 4 pounds. The bullets carry the clearer figure, so this guide uses 64 oz.
NETANY glass carafes
The NETANY glass listing states a set of 4 carafes, each with a 1 liter capacity and a size of 10.4 inches tall and 3.6 inches wide. The maker lists thicker glass with shatter resistance and crack resistance, acrylic lids that are BPA-free and lead-free, and a narrow neck for gripping and pouring. The listing states the carafes are dishwasher safe, while also stating the glass is not for boiling and hot water.
For a fridge door or a brunch table, the set gives a spare carafe for each use, since the pack holds 4 carafes with 4 lids.
NETANY plastic carafes
The NETANY plastic listing states a set of 2 carafes, each with a 50 oz capacity, a square body with a narrow neck, and a flip lid with a rubber sealing plug for air tightness. The maker lists thick plastic that is BPA-free and lead-free, a wide mouth for adding ice cubes, fruit and tea bags, and a tab that stays open when pouring. The listing states hand wash only and that the carafes are not dishwasher safe.
The height figures disagree: the bullets give dimensions of 3.5 inches by 3.5 inches by 12.4 inches and also give a height of 11.5 inches for fridge fit, while the spec table lists 3.5 inches wide by 12.4 inches tall. Measure the fridge space against the taller figure before ordering.
Amrules stainless frothing pitcher
The Amrules listing states a 12 ounces frothing pitcher in 18/8 stainless steel, listed also as 304 stainless steel, with clear scale marks inside, an ergonomic handle and a latte art pen. The maker lists a mirror finish outside, a hairline finish inside, and steel that is sturdy, rust-resistant and resistant to deformation. The listing states the pitcher is dishwasher safe, with a size of 3.2 inches wide by 3.54 inches tall and a weight of 6.4 ounces.
Placed last for storage use, this pitcher is a frothing pitcher for cappuccino, latte and espresso rather than a storage jug or a can: its stated capacity is 12 ounces, and no lid is stated. It fits a buyer who froths and pours small amounts at serving time, not a buyer who stores a large amount for later.
Reading capacity against your storage
Stated capacities here run from 12 ounces on the Amrules pitcher to 64 oz on the Stock Your Home jug, with 50 oz on the NETANY plastic carafes and 1 liter on the NETANY glass carafes. Because makers state capacity in ounces or liters and no listing converts between units, treat each figure as stated and match it to fridge space and serving needs rather than converting. Check the stated size too: the Stock Your Home jug states 10.5 inches tall, the NETANY glass carafes state 10.4 inches tall, and the NETANY plastic carafes state 12.4 inches tall in their dimensions, so fridge door clearance matters for the taller listings.
For serving at the table, a smaller stated capacity suits pouring by hand, while a larger stated capacity suits keeping milk ready in the fridge. The set counts matter too: a set of 2 or a set of 4 gives spares for rotation, while a pack with 1 jar gives a vessel for the fridge at a time.
Materials: glass, plastic or stainless steel
The listings use these materials:
- Glass: the Stock Your Home jug and the NETANY glass carafes, described by their makers as lead-free, with the Stock Your Home jug also stain resistant and odor resistant.
- Plastic: the NETANY plastic carafes, described by the maker as thick plastic that is BPA-free and lead-free.
- Stainless steel: the Amrules pitcher, described by the maker as 18/8 stainless steel and 304 stainless steel, rust-resistant and resistant to deformation.
Glass suits a buyer who wants a dishwasher safe vessel, while plastic suits a buyer who wants a carafe with a flip lid. Stainless steel suits frothing and serving, with a scale inside for measuring milk as it is poured.
Lids and cleaning
Lid styles differ across the set. The Stock Your Home jug includes 3 white caps, and the caps are not dishwasher safe even though the jug is. The NETANY glass carafes include acrylic lids, and the NETANY plastic carafes include flip lids with a rubber sealing plug. The Amrules pitcher states no lid, listing a latte art pen instead.
Cleaning splits the set into dishwasher safe and hand wash only: the Stock Your Home jug, the NETANY glass carafes and the Amrules pitcher are stated as dishwasher safe, while the NETANY plastic carafes are hand wash only. For daily milk storage, a dishwasher safe listing needs less care after each use, while a hand wash only listing needs washing by hand each time.
Read the listing twice
Milk container listings often disagree with themselves, and the figures that conflict are usually the ones needed for fridge fit:
- Stock Your Home: 64 oz in the bullets against a capacity of 4 pounds in the spec table.
- NETANY plastic: 12.4 inches in the dimensions and 11.5 inches as the height in the bullets, with 3.5 inches wide by 12.4 inches tall in the spec table, and 50 oz in the bullets against a capacity of 3.1 pounds in the spec table.
- NETANY glass: bullets and spec table agree on 10.4 inches tall and 3.6 inches wide, with no conflict found.
- Amrules: title and bullets agree on 12 ounces and 18/8 stainless steel, with 304 stainless steel also stated in the bullets.
Measure fridge space before ordering and allow for the taller figure where heights disagree.
FAQs from goat keepers
What is the difference between a milk jug and a milk can?
Jug-style listings here hold milk for fridge storage and table serving, while no listing in this set is named as a milk can. A buyer who wants a can should check that the listing names a can and states its material and lid.
What capacities do these listings state?
The Stock Your Home jug states 64 oz, the NETANY plastic carafes state 50 oz, the NETANY glass carafes state 1 liter, and the Amrules pitcher states 12 ounces.
Which listings are dishwasher safe?
The Stock Your Home jug, the NETANY glass carafes and the Amrules pitcher are stated as dishwasher safe, with the Stock Your Home caps not dishwasher safe. The NETANY plastic carafes are hand wash only.
Do these listings include lids?
The Stock Your Home jug includes 3 white caps, the NETANY glass carafes include acrylic lids, and the NETANY plastic carafes include flip lids with a rubber sealing plug. The Amrules pitcher states no lid and includes a latte art pen.
More from the barn
See every milk jars and bottles guide and all milking guides.
More picks: milk jugs with lids, milk bottles with lids, glass milk jar vs milk jug and small stainless steel milk jugs.
