
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
MUCK Arctic Pro Bark Boots9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
MUCK Arctic Sport II Tall Boot9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Tuff Stuff Products MCK70BK Muck BucketView on Amazon - 4
United Solutions TU0014 Utility Tub Muck BucketView on Amazon - 5
Springer Magrath Heavy-Duty Muck BucketView on Amazon - 6
Little Giant CA500A Miller CO Muck CartView on Amazon - 7
FORTEX INDUSTRIES Muck Bucket Brand: FortiflexView on Amazon
A stall full of soiled bedding has to move, and muck bucket vs muck cart is the choice between carrying it in your hands and rolling it on wheels. A bucket suits short carries and tight stalls, while a cart suits long hauls to the muck pile. This guide compares the buckets and the cart in the listings on capacity, handles, wheels and build, so you can match the tool to the barn.
Also worth comparing
Tuff Stuff Products MCK70BK Muck BucketCheck price on Amazon
United Solutions TU0014 Utility Tub Muck BucketCheck price on Amazon
Springer Magrath Heavy-Duty Muck BucketCheck price on Amazon
Little Giant CA500A Miller CO Muck CartCheck price on Amazon
FORTEX INDUSTRIES Muck Bucket Brand: FortiflexCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Muck bucket vs muck cart: the short answer
Pick the bucket when the carry is short and the stall is tight: a bucket goes where a cart cannot turn, and it doubles as a feed or water tub. Pick the cart when the haul is long or the load is heavy: the BBTO cart holds a standard 70 quart muck tub and rolls it on 7-1/2 inch hard rubber wheels. The buckets here hold 70 quarts or 18 gallons, and the Rubbermaid tub adds a 10-year warranty. If you already own a 70 quart tub, the cart adds wheels to the tub you have.
The gear compared
| Gear | Type | Stated capacity | Handles or wheels |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rubbermaid Brute Utility Tub | Bucket | 18 gallons | Built-in handles plus underside handle |
| Little Giant Muck Tub | Bucket | 70 quarts, 17.5 gallons | Two built-in handles |
| Tuff Stuff Muck Bucket | Bucket | 70 quarts | Rope handles |
| BBTO Muck Cart | Cart | Holds a 70 quart tub | 7-1/2 inch hard rubber wheels |
Buckets
The buckets are the simple option: fill, lift, carry, dump. The Little Giant tub lists 70 quarts, which the listing gives as 17.5 gallons, with two strong plastic handles built into the rim and a 21.75 inch diameter by a 17.25 inch height. The Tuff Stuff bucket also lists 70 quarts, with rope handles and 100-percent recycled LDPE flexible plastic, and measures 21.0 by 21.0 by 16.0 inches at 5.6 pounds. The Rubbermaid Brute tub lists 18 gallons, with built-in handles, an underside handle for dumping, a smooth interior and a reinforced rib structure, and measures 25.97 by 21.92 by 17.18 inches. The Rubbermaid is the only bucket here with a warranty term: a 10-year limited warranty.
The cart
The BBTO muck cart is the only wheeled option here: a heavy duty steel frame with hard rubber wheels that holds a standard 70 quart muck tub. It lists a height of about 38.6 inches, a width of 14.6 inches, an 18.9 inch diameter retaining ring that holds the tub, and 7-1/2 inch hard rubber wheels. It weighs 9.81 pounds, and the spec table states a warranty of none. The retaining ring measures 18.9 inches in diameter, while the Little Giant tub measures 21.75 inches in diameter, so check the fit of your own tub against the ring before ordering.
Reading capacity: quarts against gallons
Capacity on these listings is given in quarts for the buckets and in gallons for the Rubbermaid tub, and the Little Giant listing gives both: 70 quarts, which it gives as 17.5 gallons. The Tuff Stuff bucket lists 70 quarts, and the BBTO cart holds a standard 70 quart tub rather than listing a capacity of its own. The Little Giant is also available in 40 quarts, and in 9 other colors. Treat quarts and gallons as a way to rank the tubs against each other, and check the stated diameter and height against the space in the stall and the cart ring before ordering.
Handles, wheels and dumping
Handles decide how a full bucket feels, and wheels decide how far it travels. The Little Giant has two strong plastic handles built into the rim. The Tuff Stuff has rope handles, and the Rubbermaid listing claims its built-in handles are more comfortable than rope handles, and adds an underside handle for control when dumping, plus a smooth interior for easier cleaning. The BBTO cart skips handles entirely and rolls on 7-1/2 inch hard rubber wheels, which the listing says roll smoothly over flat and firm surfaces. Wheels help on flat barn aisles and stall floors, and a bucket with handles helps on steps, mud and tight turns where wheels cannot go.
Materials and build
Build decides how long the gear lasts in a barn. The Little Giant tub is made of tough polyethylene resin that the listing calls impact resistant, and says helps prevent stress cracks and protects against warpage. The Tuff Stuff bucket is made of 100-percent recycled LDPE flexible plastic with a rubber-like quality, and is also impact resistant. The Rubbermaid tub is weather, impact and corrosion resistant, with an integrated rib structure for strength. The BBTO cart is heavy duty steel with hard rubber wheels, built to withstand outdoor elements and heavy loads by the maker’s claim. None of the buckets here states a warranty term except the Rubbermaid, with its 10-year limited warranty, and the BBTO cart states a warranty of none.
Read the listing twice
Muck bucket listings often disagree with themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan the carry:
- Little Giant: 21.75 inch diameter by 17.25 inch height in the bullets, against 21.75 by 25.0 by 17.25 inches in the spec table.
- BBTO: 38.6 inches high and 14.6 inches wide in the bullets, against 20.87 by 19.69 by 6.5 inches in the spec table.
Measure your stall, your aisle and your tub before ordering, and allow for the larger figure. The Tuff Stuff and Rubbermaid listings show no such conflicts.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers muck buckets and carts only. It does not cover wheelbarrows, manure spreaders or composting. For a bigger hauling choice, see our wheelbarrow vs garden cart guide. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about goat health.
FAQs from goat keepers
Should I buy a muck bucket or a muck cart?
It depends on the haul. A bucket suits short carries and tight stalls, and the cart suits long hauls: the BBTO cart holds a standard 70 quart tub and rolls on 7-1/2 inch hard rubber wheels. If you already own a 70 quart tub, the cart adds wheels to the tub you have.
What size muck bucket do I need?
The buckets here list 70 quarts or 18 gallons, and the Little Giant gives both figures for its tub: 70 quarts, or 17.5 gallons. The Little Giant is also available in 40 quarts for smaller jobs.
Do muck buckets come with a warranty?
Only one listing here states one: the Rubbermaid Brute tub lists a 10-year limited warranty. The Little Giant and Tuff Stuff listings state no warranty term, and the BBTO cart states a warranty of none.
Will a 70 quart tub fit the BBTO cart?
The cart is made to hold a standard 70 quart muck tub, and its retaining ring measures 18.9 inches in diameter. The Little Giant tub measures 21.75 inches in diameter, so check the fit of your own tub against the ring before ordering.
More from the barn
See every Farm Carts and Wheelbarrows guide and all Barn and Farm Tools guides.
More picks: wheelbarrow vs garden cart, dump cart vs wheelbarrow, best wheelbarrow and barn boots vs muck boots.
