Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Pasture Seeder vs Broadcast Spreader: Which One Should You Buy?

Pasture seeder vs broadcast spreader: how the tools differ, when a broadcast spreader suits the job, and 4 spreaders compared by hopper capacity, spread width and warranty.

Pasture Seeder vs Broadcast Spreader: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Scotts Turf Builder EdgeGuard Mini Broadcast SpreaderScotts Turf Builder EdgeGuard Mini Broadcast SpreaderView on Amazon
  2. 2AugFir Tow Behind Broadcast SpreaderAugFir Tow Behind Broadcast SpreaderView on Amazon
  3. 3YITAMOTOR 60 lb Walk Behind Lawn Garden Spreader for SeedsYITAMOTOR 60 lb Walk Behind Lawn Garden Spreader for SeedsView on Amazon
  4. 4X-Seed Pastureland Over-Seeder South with Micro-BoostX-Seed Pastureland Over-Seeder South with Micro-BoostView on Amazon

Pasture seeder vs broadcast spreader is the question when a lawn or pasture needs seed, and the answer starts with how each tool puts seed down: a pasture seeder places seed in the soil, while a broadcast spreader throws seed, fertilizer, salt and ice melt over the ground. None of the spreaders compared here is a pasture seeder, so this guide compares broadcast spreaders only and shows which one suits each job. If you need seed placed in the soil, a broadcast spreader is not the tool; if you need seed scattered over a lawn or pasture, the spreaders below do the job.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Pasture seeder vs broadcast spreader: the short answer

Start with the ground and the job, then pick the spreader. A pull-behind spreader suits a tractor and a large lawn or pasture. An ATV-mounted spreader suits a rack and a wide path. A walk-behind spreader suits a yard you cross on foot. A handheld spreader suits a small patch or a bag you carry. Once the carrier is settled, compare the stated hopper capacity, the spread width and whether the listing states a warranty, and read the listing twice for conflicting numbers. For the pasture side of the job, see rotational grazing vs permanent pasture.

If you would rather go straight to the products, the gear section below ranks 4 spreaders on these points.

Broadcast spreaders compared

Spreader Hopper Spread width Carrier Warranty
Agri-Fab 45-0463 130 lb 10 ft to 12 ft Pull-behind, universal hitch 3 year limited warranty
Buyers ATVS100 100 lb Up to 30 feet ATV rear rack, 12V motor Limited Lifetime
Amazon Basics JC977 0.5 cubic feet Not stated Walk-behind, multi-gear Not stated
Salcod SS00 25 lb Not stated Handheld, shoulder strap Not stated

Agri-Fab pull-behind

The Agri-Fab 45-0463 leads this ranking. Its 130 lb hopper covers up to 1/2 acre or 25,000 sq ft with fewer refills, and the 10 ft to 12 ft spread width gives even distribution with fewer passes. The universal hitch connects to most riding lawn mowers and lawn tractors, including Craftsman, Husqvarna and Cub Cadet. It is built with 1 in steel tubing, an enclosed gear house, a poly hopper, a spreader plate and 13 in x 4 in pneumatic tires, and it weighs 29.4 pounds. The listing states a 3 year limited warranty.

Buyers ATV mount

The Buyers ATVS100 follows it. Its rustproof polyethylene hopper carries up to 100 lb of material, and the included rain cover helps protect the load from moisture and debris. An enclosed 12V motor distributes material across a path up to 30 feet wide, and the manual feed-gate regulator gives control over the hopper opening. It mounts to an ATV rear utility rack; confirm rack fit and load capacity before installation, fasten all hardware, and clean the spreader after corrosive material use. It weighs 18.0 pounds and measures 20.0 inches by 23.0 inches by 13.0 inches. The listing states a Limited Lifetime warranty.

Amazon Basics walk-behind

The Amazon Basics spreader comes next. It spreads grass seed, fertilizer, salt and ice melt evenly, covering up to 5000 square feet in one load, with a multi-gear system and precision control. A steel frame and plastic bin stand up to all-season weather use, and the release cable comes pre-installed for easy assembly. The maker gives 2 weights, 33 pounds and 8.86 pounds; check before ordering. It measures 35.8 inches by 20.0 inches by 28.7 inches, and the size field gives W15 x D33.5 x H28.7 inches.

Salcod handheld

The Salcod SS00 comes last in this ranking. It holds up to 25 pounds of grass seed or fertilizer in a water-resistant bag, with enclosed gears, a rear baffle and an adjustable shoulder strap. The spread rate adjusts for seed, fertilizer, salt and other materials, for more even and accurate application. It measures 6.0 inches by 14.0 inches by 12.0 inches. No warranty term is stated.

Reading hopper capacity against the ground

Capacity on these listings is given in pounds or cubic feet, not in acres, and makers measure it differently. The Agri-Fab hopper holds 130 lb and covers up to 1/2 acre or 25,000 sq ft with fewer refills. The Buyers hopper holds 100 lb. The Amazon Basics bin holds 0.5 cubic feet and covers up to 5000 square feet in one load. The Salcod bag holds up to 25 pounds. Treat capacity as a way to rank spreaders against each other and to count refills, not as a seeding rate: none of these listings states how much seed a given area needs.

A practical approach is to measure the ground, then pick a hopper that covers it with few refills. If you spread a large pasture, the pull-behind or ATV spreader suits the job; if you spread a small yard, the walk-behind or handheld spreader suits it better.

Spread width, hitch and power

Spread width decides how many passes the job takes. The Buyers spreader covers a path up to 30 feet wide with its 12V motor. The Agri-Fab spreader gives a 10 ft to 12 ft spread width from a pull-behind hitch. The Amazon Basics and Salcod listings state no spread width, so compare them on hopper capacity and carrier instead.

Carrier decides what pulls or carries the spreader. The Agri-Fab universal hitch connects to most riding lawn mowers and lawn tractors. The Buyers spreader mounts to an ATV rear utility rack. The Amazon Basics spreader walks behind you with a multi-gear system, and the Salcod spreader hangs from an adjustable shoulder strap. Match the carrier to the machine you already own: a pull-behind spreader needs a tractor or riding mower, and an ATV spreader needs a rear rack with room for the load.

Materials and build

Material sets how long a spreader lasts outdoors. The listings we compared use these materials:

  • Steel tubing with a poly hopper: the Agri-Fab spreader, with 1 in steel tubing, an enclosed gear house and 13 in x 4 in pneumatic tires.
  • Rustproof polyethylene: the Buyers hopper, with an included rain cover.
  • Steel frame with a plastic bin: the Amazon Basics spreader, for all-season weather use.
  • Water-resistant bag with enclosed gears: the Salcod spreader, with a rear baffle and an adjustable shoulder strap.

Steel frames and enclosed gear houses hold up to rough ground better than a bag. A rain cover helps when the load must stay dry, and enclosed gears keep dust and debris out of the moving parts.

Read the listing twice

Spreader listings often contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan the job:

  • Amazon Basics: 33 pounds in the title against 8.86 pounds in the listing details, and 35.8 x 20.0 x 28.7 inches in the product dimensions against W15 x D33.5 x H28.7 inches in the size field.
  • Agri-Fab: 18.11 x 10.68 x 12.4 inches in the listing details, against a 130 lb hopper in the title.

Measure your machine and your ground before ordering and allow for the larger figure. Some listings also describe spreading salt and ice melt; a spreader used for salt needs cleaning after use, as the Buyers listing says.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers spreader hardware only. It does not cover seeding rates, pasture renovation or any question about what seed to sow. Ask your local extension office about seed choice and seeding rates for your pasture.

FAQs from goat keepers

What is the difference between a pasture seeder and a broadcast spreader?

A pasture seeder places seed in the soil, while a broadcast spreader scatters seed, fertilizer, salt and ice melt over the ground. None of the 4 spreaders compared here is a pasture seeder; all 4 are broadcast spreaders.

Can a broadcast spreader seed a pasture?

Yes, for scattering seed over a lawn or pasture. The Agri-Fab spreader covers up to 1/2 acre or 25,000 sq ft per load, and the Amazon Basics spreader covers up to 5000 square feet in one load. Seed placed in the soil needs a seeder, not a spreader.

How wide does a broadcast spreader spread?

The Buyers ATV spreader distributes material across a path up to 30 feet wide, and the Agri-Fab spreader gives a 10 ft to 12 ft spread width. The Amazon Basics and Salcod listings state no spread width.

What hopper size do I need?

Match the hopper to the ground: 130 lb on the Agri-Fab, 100 lb on the Buyers, 0.5 cubic feet on the Amazon Basics and 25 lb on the Salcod. Bigger hoppers mean fewer refills on large ground.

Do broadcast spreaders need a tractor or ATV?

The Agri-Fab spreader is pull-behind with a universal hitch for riding mowers and lawn tractors. The Buyers spreader mounts to an ATV rear rack with a 12V motor. The Amazon Basics spreader is walk-behind, and the Salcod is handheld with a shoulder strap.

More from the barn

See every barn and farm tools guide and all pasture tools guides.

More picks: dump carts for lawn tractors, pallet forks for compact tractors, rotational grazing vs permanent pasture and post hole diggers for compact tractors.