Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Pint vs Quart Glass Milk Jars: Which One Should You Buy?

Pint vs quart glass milk jars: how the two sizes compare for the daily milking routine, fridge space and lids, with four pint-size listings as gear examples.

Pint vs Quart Glass Milk Jars: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Mihlapi 32 oz Mason Jar Pitcher with LidMihlapi 32 oz Mason Jar Pitcher with Lid9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Balter-D 4-Pack 32 oz Glass Mason Jar Pitcher with Pour SpoutBalter-D 4-Pack 32 oz Glass Mason Jar Pitcher with Pour Spout9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3VA1KENE Mason Jar Pitcher Set of 2VA1KENE Mason Jar Pitcher Set of 29.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Ball Regular Mouth Pint Glass Mason JarsBall Regular Mouth Pint Glass Mason JarsView on Amazon
  5. 5Old Fashioned Heavy Glass Half Pint Milk BottleOld Fashioned Heavy Glass Half Pint Milk BottleView on Amazon
  6. 6Old Fashioned Heavy Clear Glass Half Pint Milk BottleOld Fashioned Heavy Clear Glass Half Pint Milk BottleView on Amazon

The morning milking fills the pail, and then comes the daily question of what to pour it into: for most home goat keepers, the answer is pint jars for drinking and quart jars for storage, with the split decided by how much milk the does give each day. This guide compares pint vs quart glass milk jars by size, daily volume, lids and seals, cleaning and the listing gaps to check, using four pint-size listings as gear examples. Every number below comes from an Amazon listing, and we point out where those listings contradict themselves.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Pint vs quart glass milk jars: the short answer

Pick the jar that matches one milking, not one day. A pint jar (16 ounces, per the Ball and JoyJolt listings) suits a single milking from one doe, table servings and sharing with the kids. A quart jar, the larger of the two sizes, suits a full day’s milk from one or two does and takes fewer jars to store the same volume. If you milk two or three does twice a day, quarts cut the jar count; if you milk one doe or pour by the glass, pints are easier to handle and chill faster. Note that none of the four listings below is a quart jar: all are pint-size or smaller, so the quart side of this guide is about the size class, not a specific listing.

If you would rather compare jar styles than sizes, our mason jars vs glass milk bottles comparison scores the same question a different way.

The gear: four pint-size listings

All four listings we compared are pint-size or smaller, ranked here by our scores. The JoyJolt set lists eight 16 ounce bottles with black PP lids, made from thick lead-free soda lime glass, 2.7 inches wide and 6.69 inches tall with a 2 inch mouth, and the lids are stated as 100% leakproof. The bullets name milk among the uses, the set adds labels for naming each bottle, and the listing states a 12 month warranty. The spec table gives an 8 ounce item weight and model JG10307.

The Ball listing is eight 16 ounce regular mouth pint mason jars with SureTight lids and bands, stated as airtight, BPA-free, and freezer and refrigerator safe. The spec table gives 16 fluid ounces, a round clear jar with a twist lock closure, and a 5.8 pound item weight for the set. The bullets call the jars dishwasher safe for cleanup and name jams, jellies and pourable liquids among the uses.

The Bormioli Rocco Quattro Stagioni is a 13.5 ounce glass canning jar and drinking bottle with a gold metal airtight lid and a vacuum seal the listing says you can see and hear when it locks. The bullets state dishwasher and microwave use without the lid up to 158 F, freezer safe, and BPA and phthalate free, with uses from canning to drinks. The spec table gives 3.25 by 3.25 by 6 inches and 9.12 ounces, but lists a 12 count unit against the single-jar title, a mismatch to settle with the seller.

The OXO Good Grips creamer is a 12 ounce glass pitcher with a drip-free spout, a glass lid and two silicone seals, stated as BPA free and airtight. The spec table gives 2.5 by 5.25 inches, a 10.4 ounce weight and model 11212500. One contradiction: the title says dishwasher safe while the bullets say hand wash only, so trust the bullets and wash it by hand.

Matching jar size to your milking

Start with the milk, not the jar. A doe giving a pint or two per milking fills pint jars with nothing left over; a doe giving a quart or more per milking fills quart jars. Two does milked twice a day can fill four quart jars a day, which is eight pint jars, so the quart side wins on fridge shelf space and on lids to wash. One doe milked once a day, or milk poured for the table, favors pints: a 16 ounce jar chills faster, pours without a heavy lift and gets finished before the milk ages.

Think about the fridge too. Eight 16 ounce Ball jars take more shelf slots than four quart jars holding the same milk, but a single open quart goes off faster once opened than a single open pint. Many keepers run both: quarts for the day’s milk going into the fridge, pints for what gets poured at meals.

Lids, seals and cleaning

A jar is only as good as its lid. The listings we compared use four lid styles:

  • Two-piece mason lid and band: the Ball jars, with SureTight lids stated as airtight.
  • Screw-on PP lids: the JoyJolt bottles, stated as 100% leakproof with no inserts.
  • Gold metal vacuum lid: the Bormioli Rocco jar, with a gasket the listing says flexes down to seal.
  • Glass lid with silicone seals: the OXO creamer, with two seals stated as airtight.

Leakproof matters if jars ride in a cooler to a show or a neighbor. The JoyJolt PP lids are the only ones stated as fully leakproof; the mason and vacuum lids seal for storage but are not described as leakproof for transport. For cleaning, the Ball and JoyJolt listings state dishwasher safe, the Bormioli Rocco allows the dishwasher without the lid, and the OXO bullets say hand wash only, which overrules its own title.

Listing Size Lid Dishwasher
JoyJolt bottles 16 oz, 8-pack PP screw lids, leakproof Stated safe
Ball mason jars 16 oz, 8-pack SureTight lid and band Stated safe
Bormioli Rocco 13.5 oz Gold metal vacuum lid Jar only, no lid
OXO creamer 12 oz Glass lid, 2 silicone seals Hand wash, per bullets

Glass claims: lead-free and BPA-free

Three of the four listings state material claims. The JoyJolt bottles are stated as lead-free soda lime glass with BPA, phthalate and PABA free lids. The Ball jars state BPA-free construction. The Bormioli Rocco states BPA free and phthalate free. The OXO creamer states BPA free. None of the four states a tempered or heat-strengthened glass claim, so treat all four as standard glass: avoid sudden temperature swings and do not pour boiling water into a cold jar.

Read the listing twice

Jar listings contradict themselves most often on care and count, and those are the details that decide daily use:

  • OXO: dishwasher safe in the title against hand wash only in the bullets.
  • Bormioli Rocco: a 12 count unit in the spec table against a single 13.5 ounce jar in the title; also, the table lists microwave use as no data while the bullets allow the microwave without the lid up to 158 F.
  • Ball: the 17.31 by 9 by 7.5 inch dimensions describe the 8-pack box, not one jar.
  • JoyJolt: the bullets give 6.5 inches tall while the spec table gives 6.69 inches; close enough to be the same bottle, but measure your fridge shelf against the larger figure.

Measure the fridge shelf before ordering, and count lids and bands, not just jars: the Ball set includes them, the others describe their own closures.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers jar hardware only. It does not cover milk handling, cooling times, pasteurization or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about milk safety and goat health.

FAQs from goat keepers

Should I buy pint or quart jars for goat milk?

Match one milking. Pints (16 ounces) suit a single milking, table servings and small herds; quarts suit a full day’s milk from one or two does and take fewer jars for the same volume.

How many pint jars equal the milk of two does?

It depends on yield, which no listing states. Two does giving a quart each per milking fill four pint jars per milking, or eight pint jars a day over two milkings.

Are mason jars good for milk storage?

The Ball listing states airtight SureTight lids, BPA-free construction and freezer and refrigerator safe glass, which covers milk storage. The listing does not state the jars are leakproof for transport.

Which of these jars are dishwasher safe?

The Ball and JoyJolt listings state dishwasher safe. The Bormioli Rocco allows the dishwasher for the jar without the lid, and the OXO bullets say hand wash only.

Do any of these come with a warranty?

Only the JoyJolt listing states one: a 12 month warranty. The other three state no warranty term.

More from the barn

See every milk jar and bottle guide and all milking guides.

More picks: glass milk jar vs milk jug, mason jars vs glass milk bottles and milk strainers for goat milk.