
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Rubbermaid Commercial Products 50-Gallon Stock Tank9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
RTS Home Accents 50-Gallon ECO Rain Barrel Made with 100%View on Amazon - 3
53 Gallon/200L Collapsible RainWater Collection BarrelView on Amazon - 4
RTS Home Accents Premium 55-Gallon Rain Barrel with RemovableView on Amazon - 5
Rain BarrelView on Amazon - 6
FCMP Outdoor Slim Line Design Rain BarrelView on Amazon - 7
100 Gallon/380L Collapsible RainWater Collection BarrelView on Amazon
The rain barrel vs stock tank question comes down to shape: a barrel catches runoff and hands it back through a spigot behind a screen, while a tank is an open trough that animals drink from directly. Pick a barrel when you want stored rainwater for garden beds, wash water and backup supply, and pick a tank when animals need open access to drink at any hour. The listings below are all closed containers, so this guide compares barrel shapes against each other and spells out where an open trough fits instead.
Also worth comparing
RTS Home Accents 50-Gallon ECO Rain Barrel Made with 100%Check price on Amazon
53 Gallon/200L Collapsible RainWater Collection BarrelCheck price on Amazon
RTS Home Accents Premium 55-Gallon Rain Barrel with RemovableCheck price on Amazon
Rain BarrelCheck price on Amazon
FCMP Outdoor Slim Line Design Rain BarrelCheck price on Amazon
100 Gallon/380L Collapsible RainWater Collection BarrelCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Rain barrel vs stock tank: the short answer
Start with how the water will be used, then pick the shape, then check capacity and fittings. A closed barrel suits stored rainwater that you draw through a spigot into a can or a trough. An open tank suits animals that drink directly, with no spigot between them and the water. Once the shape is settled, compare the stated gallons, the fittings, the material and whether the listing states food-grade plastic, and read the listing carefully for claims that belong to a different use. If you want scored picks rather than guidance, our stock tank rain barrel roundup covers the same ground with products.
The containers compared
| Container | Stated capacity | Fittings | Shape |
|---|---|---|---|
| Step2 Lakewood Rain Barrel | 60 gallons | 3/4 inch brass spigot, mesh screen | Barrel with stand |
| YYLXTEX Collapsible Rain Barrel | 53 gallons | Quick-connect tap, sprinkler | Collapsible barrel, 2mm frame |
| Augason Farms Water Barrel | 55 gallons | 2 plug fittings | Drum, food-grade |
| HOANK Water Storage Drum | 55 gallons | 2-inch NPT and 2-inch Buttress fittings | Tight head drum |
Step2 Lakewood Rain Barrel
The Step2 listing is the fullest rain barrel of the 4, and it leads this guide for that reason. It holds 60 gallons, the largest stated capacity here, and it stands on its own stand, which the listing states improves water pressure and makes filling a watering can easier. A stainless steel mesh screen filters fine particulate while letting water flow, and a 3/4 inch brass spigot comes included. The listing also states that multiple barrels can link together for increased storage and overflow management, and that the double-walled plastic build wipes down with minimal assembly.
YYLXTEX Collapsible Rain Barrel
The YYLXTEX listing is the only collapsible container here, and it is built as a rain catcher from the start. It holds 53 gallons, or 200L as the title also states, inside a 0.6mm 3-layer PVC body with a high-density woven liner and a frame of 2mm support poles. A 5mm mesh screen stops debris at the source, and the kit includes a quick-connect tap, a sprinkler, a hose, a collapsible bucket and plant labels, with setup stated at under 5 minutes. It folds away when the season ends, which no rigid drum here can do.
Augason Farms Water Barrel
The Augason Farms listing is a storage drum rather than a rain catcher, and its strength is the stated food-grade material. It holds 55 gallons of BPA-free, food-grade polyethylene, with 2 built-in plug fittings for filling and draining, and the listing pitches it as long-term emergency water storage for households. It weighs 18.0 pounds and measures 23.438 inches by 23.438 inches by 35.5 inches, and the listing notes the lightweight feel when empty helps with positioning. No spigot or tap is stated, so drawing water means using the plug fittings rather than turning a tap.
HOANK Water Storage Drum
The HOANK listing is an industrial drum first and a water container after that, and it sits last here for that reason. It holds 55 gallons in BPA-free high molecular weight polyethylene, with a seamless tight head design, dual fittings in 2-inch NPT and 2-inch Buttress sizes, and a UN rating for regulated materials. The listing pitches the drum at industrial, laboratory and commercial storage, including chemicals and oils, and it states weather-resistant, UV-stable construction for outdoor exposure. No dimensions are stated, and no rain capture, spigot or drinking use is stated either.
Reading capacity
Stated capacity runs from 53 gallons on the YYLXTEX barrel to 60 gallons on the Step2 barrel, with both drums at 55 gallons in between. The largest figure belongs to the barrel with a stand and a spigot, while the smallest belongs to the collapsible catcher, so capacity alone does not rank these containers: a 55 gallon drum with plug fittings only is harder to draw from than a 60 gallon barrel with a brass spigot. Compare gallons between listings, then check how the water gets out, since a spigot, a tap and a plug fitting are very different chores at the end of a dry week.
Where the water comes from and where it goes
Rain barrels earn their name by catching runoff, and only the Step2 and YYLXTEX listings describe that job. The YYLXTEX barrel pairs its 5mm mesh screen with a quick-connect tap and a sprinkler, so collected water goes straight to garden use, while the Step2 barrel pairs its stainless steel screen with a 3/4 inch brass spigot and a stand that makes filling a watering can easier. Step2 also states that multiple barrels link together, which covers overflow when rain keeps coming after the barrel fills.
The drums work the other way around: water goes in through a fitting and comes out through a fitting, with no roof, screen or spigot story in the listing. Augason states 2 plug fittings for filling and draining, and HOANK states pump fittings in 2-inch NPT and 2-inch Buttress sizes for transferring, draining or filling. Neither drum listing describes rain capture, so a keeper who wants roof runoff should pick a barrel shape, and a keeper who wants animals to drink directly should look past all 4 listings here toward an open trough shape instead.
Materials: HMWPE, food-grade polyethylene, PVC and double walls
Material claims split the 4 listings into two groups: drums built for storage, and barrels built for weather. HOANK states high molecular weight polyethylene that is impact-resistant, UV-stable and weather-resistant, with a seamless tight head design for tight containment. Augason states BPA-free, food-grade polyethylene, the only food-grade claim in this set, which is the material point that matters most if stored water will be used for cooking and hygiene during outages, as that listing describes.
The rain barrels state lighter, weather-facing builds. YYLXTEX states a 0.6mm 3-layer PVC body with a woven liner and a 2mm frame, pitched at tear resistance and all-weather durability, while Step2 states double-walled plastic construction with colors that will not chip, fade, crack or peel. None of the 4 listings states steel, so a keeper who wants a metal container will not find one here.
Setup, linking and moving
Setup effort is where the collapsible barrel pulls ahead. YYLXTEX states setup in under 5 minutes with everything included, and the barrel collapses for storage when it is not needed. Step2 states minimal assembly with an easy wipe down, and its stand is part of the design rather than an add-on, so the barrel arrives ready to elevate and link. Linking is a Step2-only claim here: no other listing states that units join together.
Weight and handling favor the drums when empty. Augason states 18.0 pounds and a lightweight feel when empty, which helps with positioning before filling, while Step2 states 34.0 pounds with assembled dimensions of 46 inches high by 24 inches wide by 20 inches deep. HOANK states no dimensions and no weight, so plan its placement from the 55 gallon figure alone and check the listing before ordering.
Listing gaps to check
Read every listing here for the use it actually pitches, not the use you hope for. HOANK pitches industrial, laboratory and commercial storage, including chemicals and oils, with a UN rating for regulated materials, so its BPA-free plastic does not make it a food-grade drinking barrel, and only Augason states food-grade material. Augason states a warranty field that reads only Manufacturer, with no term attached, and its size field reads only unt, which explains nothing, so both points need a check before buying.
YYLXTEX states that outdoor water costs fall by 20 to 30 percent when using collected rainwater, a marketing claim the listing itself cannot prove for any particular roof or garden. Step2 is the cleanest listing of the 4: its assembled dimensions match its spec table at 46 inches by 24 inches by 20 inches, and its spigot, screen and linking claims all sit in the bullets rather than in a stray spec field. Where a listing stays silent, such as HOANK on dimensions, treat the gap as unknown rather than as a win for any side.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers closed barrels and drums only, because that is what the 4 listings here offer. Open stock tanks, heated troughs and automatic waterers sit outside this set, and so does any advice on treating stored water: check the listing’s stated use and your own local guidance before putting stored water in front of animals. Herd size, daily intake and roof area are also outside this guide, since no listing here states them, so match the stated gallons to your own setup rather than to a rule from elsewhere.
FAQs from goat keepers
Can goats drink straight from a rain barrel?
Not from the containers in this guide. All 4 listings here are closed containers with spigots, taps or plug fittings, not open troughs, so draw the water into a trough or a can for drinking access.
Which container holds the largest amount of water?
The Step2 Lakewood Rain Barrel, at 60 gallons stated, holds the largest stated capacity here, ahead of the 55 gallon drums and the 53 gallon collapsible barrel.
Can rain barrels link together?
The Step2 listing states that multiple rain barrels can link together for increased storage and overflow management. No other listing here states linking.
Is the HOANK drum food-grade?
No food-grade claim is stated for it. HOANK states BPA-free high molecular weight polyethylene pitched at industrial and chemical storage, while Augason is the listing here that states food-grade polyethylene.
How fast does the collapsible barrel set up?
The YYLXTEX listing states setup in under 5 minutes, with a quick-connect tap, hose, collapsible bucket and plant labels included in the kit.
More from the barn
See every water trough guide and all feeding and water guides.
More picks: stock tank rain barrel, stock tank vs kiddie pool, water troughs for goats and livestock water storage tanks.
