Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Slow Feed vs Free Choice Hay: Which One Should You Buy?

A practical guide to feeding goats hay: slow feeder bags and nets against free choice feeding, compared on openings, capacities and waste.

Slow Feed vs Free Choice Hay: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1MKO SHUN 35x31 Inch Slow Feed Hay NetsMKO SHUN 35x31 Inch Slow Feed Hay Nets9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 22pcs Slow Feed Hay Nets for Horses2pcs Slow Feed Hay Nets for HorsesView on Amazon
  3. 3Equiessentials Slow Feed Hay Ball Large Brand: EquiessentialsEquiessentials Slow Feed Hay Ball Large Brand: EquiessentialsView on Amazon

Toss a flake of hay on the ground and it is gone in minutes, half of it trampled into the bedding. In the slow feed vs free choice hay question, the direct answer is that slow feed puts hay behind a net or mesh bag with small openings so goats pull it out a bite at a time, while free choice offers loose hay from a rack or feeder with nothing slowing them down. Slow feed stretches each flake and cuts waste; free choice is simpler and needs less gear. This guide compares how the two work and what the listings actually state.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Slow feed vs free choice hay: the short answer

Start with how much hay hits the ground uneaten. With free choice, goats eat loose hay as fast as they like, and a good share gets pulled out, stepped on and wasted. With slow feed, the hay sits behind mesh: the goat works each bite through an opening, so the same flake lasts longer and less of it ends up underfoot. Slow feed needs a bag or net and takes a minute to fill; free choice needs only a rack, a feeder or a clean spot on the ground.

For scored picks, our best slow feed hay net for small flakes roundup rates five nets, and how to choose a hay feeder for goats covers racks, bags and bins.

What slow feeding is

Slow feeding means the hay stays inside a mesh bag or net, and the goat eats through the openings. The mesh is the whole idea: small holes force small bites. In the listings compared here, openings run from 1 inch on the Country Pride ultra slow feeder net to 3.5 by 1.75 inches on a Derby Originals bag, with 1.2 inch at rest stretching to 1.5 inches on the Gmhortn net and 1.9 inch mesh on the Goatzy bag. Capacities run from 2 to 3 flakes in the Derby Originals and Paris Tack bags to 5 to 6 flakes in the Country Pride net to about 1 bale in the Derby Originals XL bag. Several of these listings name goats outright, including the MIYABALA 3-pack, the Gmhortn 2-pack and the Goatzy bag.

What free choice feeding is

Free choice means loose hay with no mesh in the way: a rack, a wall feeder or a clean pile, and the goats eat at their own pace whenever they like. There is no hardware to buy beyond the feeder itself and no bag to fill, which is why many barns start here. The trade is waste: goats pull, sort and trample loose hay, so more of each bale ends up as bedding than as feed. For a small herd with plenty of hay, that trade is often fine; for a big group or pricey hay, it adds up fast.

The two methods side by side

Slow feed Free choice
What you buy Mesh bag or net with small openings Rack, feeder, or nothing at all
Stated openings 1 inch to 3.5 by 1.75 inches in these listings None; hay is loose
Stated capacity 2 to 3 flakes up to about 1 bale Whatever the rack holds
Refills Fill the bag, hang it, done Top up the rack as needed
Waste Mesh keeps hay contained More pulling and trampling
Best for Stretching hay, easy keepers, bored goats Simple setups, small herds, plenty of hay

Openings, from 1 inch up

The opening size is the setting that matters most. The Country Pride net lists 1-inch openings, the Gmhortn net lists 1.2 inches at rest stretching to 1.5 inches once stuffed, the MIYABALA bale net lists 1.6 inch holes, the Derby Originals XL lists 1.75 inch square openings, the Goatzy bag lists 1.9 inch mesh, the Paris Tack bag lists 2 by 3.5 inch rectangular openings, another Paris Tack bag lists 3 by 3 inch openings, and the Derby Originals four-sided bag lists 3.5 by 1.75 inch openings. Smaller openings mean slower eating and longer-lasting flakes; the Gmhortn listing claims its net slows eating speed by 40 percent. Pick smaller holes for aggressive eaters and larger ones for shy or young goats that might give up on a net that fights back.

Bags, nets and bale nets

Slow feed gear comes in three shapes. Bags hang from a strap or hook: the Derby Originals bags list a patented 4-sided nylon web so goats can eat from any side, the Paris Tack bag lists a top-load design with a velcro flap, and the Goatzy bag lists a quick-fill collar, a waterproof 1000D armor bottom and a stainless steel carabiner. Nets wrap flakes or a whole bale: the MIYABALA bale net fits square bales from 36 by 18 by 18 inches to 45 by 25 by 17 inches and lists an 8-strand rope with a drawstring closure. Fabrics run heavy, from 600D Oxford on the MIYABALA 3-pack to 1680D on its ground-feeding bag. Hang bags and nets at goat height, and check straps and hooks the way you check any barn hardware.

Read the listing twice

Slow feeder listings do not always agree with themselves:

  • Derby Originals XL: the bullets describe a 19 by 19 by 41 inch bag, while the spec table lists the size as 19 by 10 by 41 inches.
  • Paris Tack top-load bag: the warranty bullet says the 6-month warranty is offered by Derby Originals, though the brand on the listing is Paris Tack.

When dimensions or the warranty source disagree, confirm with the seller before you buy. We follow the bullets over the spec table when the two conflict.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers feeding methods and gear only. It does not cover how much hay a goat needs, hay quality or nutrition, or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.

FAQs from goat keepers

Should I slow feed my goats or feed free choice?

Slow feed if hay is pricey, your goats eat too fast, or half of every flake ends up trampled: the listings here show openings from 1 inch to 3.5 by 1.75 inches that stretch each flake. Feed free choice if you want the simplest setup and have hay to spare, since a rack and loose hay need no extra gear.

What size mesh should a slow feeder hay net have?

In these listings, from 1-inch openings on the Country Pride net to 3.5 by 1.75 inches on the Derby Originals bag, with 1.2, 1.6 and 1.9 inch options between. Smaller openings slow aggressive eaters; larger openings suit shy or young goats.

How much hay does a slow feeder bag hold?

From 2 to 3 flakes in the Derby Originals and Paris Tack bags to 5 to 6 flakes in the Country Pride 42-inch net to about 1 bale in the Derby Originals XL bag. Bale nets like the MIYABALA fit whole square bales from 36 by 18 by 18 inches to 45 by 25 by 17 inches.

Can goats use slow feeder hay bags made for horses?

Several listings name goats directly: the MIYABALA 3-pack lists compatibility with goats, the Gmhortn 2-pack names goats and sheep, and the Goatzy bag is sized for horses, goats, sheep and donkeys. Hang the bag at goat height so smaller animals can reach the mesh.

More from the barn

See every slow feed hay nets guide and all feeding and water guides.

More picks: slow feed hay nets for small flakes, hay nets for square bales and goat feeders with hay racks.