
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
American Floor MatsView on Amazon - 2
Innconee 18 Pcs Horse Stall Mats 4 x 8 ft Plastic Stable MatView on Amazon - 3
Dilunave 1 Heavy Duty Rubber Horse Stall Mats Large HorseView on Amazon - 4
Meitola Horse/Stable MatsView on Amazon - 5
Klyyo Clyro Heavy Duty Rubber Horse Stall Mats 4x6 ft HorseView on Amazon - 6
Dilunave 6 Pack Horse Stall MatsView on Amazon
Stall mats vs trailer mats is the question when a stall floor or a trailer floor needs covering, and the answer starts with where the mat lives: a stall mat stays put in a stall, while a trailer mat must handle a moving floor, ramps and loading. None of the mats compared here is sold as a trailer mat, so this guide compares stall mats only and shows which one suits a trailer too. If you need a mat made for a trailer, check the maker listing for trailer use; if you need a stall floor covered, the mats below do the job.
Also worth comparing
American Floor MatsCheck price on Amazon
Innconee 18 Pcs Horse Stall Mats 4 x 8 ft Plastic Stable MatCheck price on Amazon
Dilunave 1 Heavy Duty Rubber Horse Stall Mats Large HorseCheck price on Amazon
Meitola Horse/Stable MatsCheck price on Amazon
Klyyo Clyro Heavy Duty Rubber Horse Stall Mats 4x6 ft HorseCheck price on Amazon
Dilunave 6 Pack Horse Stall MatsCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Stall mats vs trailer mats: the short answer
Start with where the mat goes, then pick the mat. A thick solid rubber mat suits a stall and a trailer floor. An interlocking tile set suits a large stall you build to size. A light absorbent mat suits a stall topper or a corridor, not a trailer ramp. Once the place is settled, compare the stated thickness, size, drainage and material, and read the listing twice for conflicting numbers. For the barn side of the job, see best stall guards for horses.
If you would rather go straight to the products, the gear section below ranks 4 mats on these points.
Stall mats compared
| Mat | Thickness | Size | Drainage | Material |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| American Floor Mats | 3/8 in | 3 ft x 4 ft | Not stated | Solid rubber |
| Innconee 18 Pcs | Not stated | 4 ft x 8 ft assembled | Drainage holes | Plastic |
| Dilunave Rubber Mat | Not stated | 3 ft x 4 ft | Not stated | Rubber |
| Meitola Absorbent Mat | Not stated | 8 ft x 8 ft | Absorbs liquid | Soft absorbent material |
American Floor Mats solid rubber
The American Floor Mats mat leads this ranking. It is a heavy duty stall mat in thick, durable solid black rubber, 3/8 in thick and 3 ft by 4 ft, at 48.0 inches by 36.0 inches by 0.375 inches. The maker says it is manufactured in the US from high quality raw materials and does not contain any rubber substitutes. Liquids and solids wipe or brush off, so the mat is easy to clean. The listing also says these rubber mats are perfect for floor protection under heavy equipment, including horse trailers, farm equipment and other related machinery.
Innconee interlocking tiles
The Innconee set follows it. The set includes 18 pcs of horse stall mats in a modular design, so you can arrange and combine the tiles to create the size and layout you need. Each tile measures about 15.8 x 15.8 inches, and the set assembles into about 47.4 x 94.8 inches, or 4 x 8 ft. The tiles have large drainage openings that help reduce the buildup of liquids, oils and water on the floor, and the textured surface gives reliable traction. The tiles can be trimmed to fit smaller spaces, and cleaning is simple: rinse with water to remove dirt and waste.
Dilunave rubber mat
The Dilunave mat comes next. It is a heavy duty rubber horse stall mat of about 3 x 4 ft, made from rubber materials that the maker says can bear heavy horse hooves without cracking or warping easily. The material is water-resistant and non-slip, and the textured surface provides traction, preventing slips and falls for animals and humans, even when wet. The dense material absorbs impact and reduces noise from footsteps, dropped weights or hooves. It suits stables and other livestock, such as cows, sheep and pigs.
Meitola absorbent mat
The Meitola mat comes last in this ranking. It is a soft absorbent mat of 8 ft by 8 ft that weighs 4.0 pounds, with a non-slip underlay on the bottom that prevents shifting and keeps liquids from leaking through. The soft material absorbs liquid and keeps the stable dry and clean, and the upper layer provides insulation and a comfortable environment for young horses. Lay the mats in a corridor, stall or barn and fix the edges with tape or nails; when soiled, hose them off and dry them for reuse.
Reading thickness against the job
Thickness is stated for one mat only: the American Floor Mats mat at 3/8 in thick. The other listings state no thickness, so compare them on size, material and use instead. A thick mat suits a stall with heavy hooves and a trailer floor with heavy equipment; a thin mat suits a topper or a corridor where the floor below does the work.
Size decides how much floor one mat covers. The American Floor Mats mat and the Dilunave mat each cover 3 ft by 4 ft. The Innconee set assembles to 4 ft by 8 ft, and the tiles can be trimmed to fit smaller spaces. The Meitola mat covers 8 ft by 8 ft in one piece. Measure the stall or trailer floor before ordering, and allow for the larger figure where listings disagree.
Drainage, grip and cleaning
Drainage decides whether liquid pools on the floor. The Innconee tiles have large drainage openings that let water, snow and slush pass through, and the perforated design traps dirt and debris. The Meitola mat absorbs liquid instead of draining it, which keeps the stable dry and clean. The rubber mats have no drainage holes stated; they wipe, brush or hose clean.
Grip decides whether hooves slip. The Innconee tiles have a textured surface for reliable traction, and the Dilunave mat has a textured surface that prevents slips and falls, even when wet. The Meitola mat has a non-slip underlay that keeps it from shifting. Cleaning is simple across the set: rinse with water, hose down, sweep or wipe, and let the mat dry before reuse.
Materials: rubber, plastic or absorbent
Material sets how long a mat lasts under hooves. The listings we compared use these materials:
- Solid rubber: the American Floor Mats mat, manufactured in the US with no rubber substitutes.
- Heavy duty rubber: the Dilunave mat, made to bear heavy hooves without cracking or warping.
- Plastic: the Innconee interlocking tiles, with drainage holes and a textured surface.
- Soft absorbent material: the Meitola mat, made of environmentally friendly materials.
Rubber mats hold up to hooves and heavy equipment better than an absorbent mat. Plastic tiles trade weight for drainage and a modular fit. An absorbent mat suits a dry stall topper, not a wet trailer floor.
Read the listing twice
Mat listings often contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan the install:
- Innconee: about 15.8 x 15.8 inches per tile in the bullets against 16.93 x 16.93 inches in the listed dimensions.
- American Floor Mats: 3/8 in thick in the title, 0.375 inches in the product dimensions and 0.38 in in the size field.
- Dilunave: 0.08 inches thick in the listed details, which reads thin beside a heavy duty rubber mat; the title and bullets state no thickness.
Measure your stall or trailer floor before ordering and allow for the larger figure. Some listings also describe use in garages, kennels, cabinets, doorways, car trunks and gardening; a mat that suits a stall may not suit every one of those places.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers mat hardware only. It does not cover bedding, stall design or any question about horse health or hoof care. Ask your local extension office about flooring and bedding for your barn.
FAQs from goat keepers
Can I use a stall mat in a horse trailer?
Yes, if the maker names trailers. The American Floor Mats listing says its mats are perfect for floor protection under heavy equipment, including horse trailers. The other listings name stalls, barns and sheds, not trailers.
How thick should a stall mat be?
Only one listing here states a thickness: the American Floor Mats mat at 3/8 in thick. The other listings state no thickness, so compare them on size, material and use.
Do stall mats drain?
Some do. The Innconee tiles have large drainage openings that help reduce the buildup of liquids, oils and water on the floor. The Meitola mat absorbs liquid instead of draining it, and the rubber mats wipe clean.
How do you clean stall mats?
Rinse with water, hose down, sweep or wipe. The Innconee mats rinse with water, the Dilunave mat takes a hose-down, sweep or wipe, and the American Floor Mats mats wipe or brush clean. The Meitola mat hoses off and dries for reuse.
What size stall mat do I need?
Match the mat to the stall: 3 ft by 4 ft on the American Floor Mats and Dilunave mats, 4 ft by 8 ft assembled on the Innconee set, and 8 ft by 8 ft on the Meitola mat. The Innconee tiles can be trimmed to fit smaller spaces.
More from the barn
See every barn and farm tools guide and all tractor implements guides.
More picks: stall guards for horses, lightweight wheelbarrows, automatic horse waterers and barn fans vs exhaust fans.
