
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Terro T380 Outdoor Fly Trap9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
STEM Indoor Fan Trap9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Safer Home Plug-In Trap9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Katchy Duo Insect Trap9.5/10View on Amazon
Morning milking brings the flies with it, and by the time the hay is down the barn air is thick with them. The question of types of fly traps comes down to where the flies gather and how each trap catches them. This guide compares the traps on how they work, where they work and what they need from you, using only what the listings state, so you can match the trap to the spot.
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
| # | Product | GoatGear Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Terro T380 Outdoor Fly Trap | 9.7/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | STEM Indoor Fan Trap | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Safer Home Plug-In Trap | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 | Katchy Duo Insect Trap | 9.5/10 | Buy on Amazon |

Terro T380 Outdoor Fly Trap
An outdoor reusable trap with non-poisonous bait included, in a pack of 2, that attracts house flies, barn flies and bottle flies.
Pros
- Outdoor trap that names house flies, barn flies and bottle flies
- Reusable: empties and refills with bait and water
- Non-poisonous bait included with each trap
- Pack of 2, 1 quart size
Cons
- Outdoor use only, per the listing
- Needs bait and water added before it works
- Bait must stay moist; add water as needed
- No warranty term is stated

STEM Indoor Fan Trap
A plug-in indoor fan trap with UV light, a timer and 5 glue traps, that catches mosquitoes, fruit flies and house flies.
Pros
- Fan and UV light work together to attract and trap flies
- Timer for 3, 8 or 12 hours, or continuous 24/7 operation
- Includes 5 glue traps and a 6-foot cord
- No chemical insecticides; family- and pet-friendly when used as directed
Cons
- Listed for indoor or enclosed patio use
- Glue card must be replaced when full
- Only 1 device in the pack
- No warranty term is stated

Safer Home Plug-In Trap
A plug-in indoor trap with UV LED light and glue cards, in a 2-pack that covers up to 800 sq ft.
Pros
- Each device protects up to 400 sq ft, 800 sq ft total
- 2 plug-in devices plus 2 glue cards for multiple rooms
- UV LED light attracts bugs 24/7
- No chemical insecticides; safe around children and pets when used as directed
Cons
- Listed for indoor use
- House flies are not named among the insects it attracts
- Glue cards need replacing as they fill
- No warranty term is stated

Katchy Duo Insect Trap
An indoor trap with a 360-degree ring light, a scent pod and fan suction, that catches fruit flies, gnats and mosquitoes.
Pros
- 360-degree ring light and removable scent pod for liquid bait
- Five adjustable light and fan settings, plus an automatic mode
- Fan suction and a hidden glue board; no zapper needed
- Includes 4 glue boards; contact-free disposal
Cons
- Not effective on house flies, per the listing
- Glue boards need replacing every 3 to 4 weeks
- No coverage area is stated
- No warranty term is stated
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Types of fly traps: the short answer
Start with where the flies gather, then pick the trap that works there. Plug-in UV glue traps suit indoor rooms, fan traps with a scent pod or a timer suit kitchens and enclosed patios, and a bait trap suits the outdoors where barn flies gather. The how fly traps work guide explains the types and setup in more detail.
Trap types compared
| Trap | Where it works | How it catches | Stated coverage | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Terro T380 | Outdoors | Bait and water | Not stated | |
| STEM Fan Trap | Indoors or enclosed patio | UV light and fan | Not stated | |
| Safer Home Plug-In | Indoors | UV LED light and glue cards | Up to 400 sq ft per device | |
| Katchy Duo | Indoors | Ring light, scent pod and fan | Not stated |
Coverage is the gap to watch: only the Safer listing states a coverage figure, up to 400 sq ft per device. The Terro listing states no coverage area, and it is the only outdoor trap in this guide.
The traps in this guide
Each trap below handles one part of the job: the Terro takes the outdoor barn flies, the STEM and Safer take indoor rooms, and the Katchy takes fruit flies and gnats where a scent pod helps.
How to choose the best types of fly traps
Indoor or outdoor first
Start with the pen: the types of fly traps that work in a barn differ from the ones that work in a kitchen. The Terro is the only trap in this guide listed for outdoor use, and it names barn flies. The Safer, STEM and Katchy traps (on Amazon) are listed for indoor use, and the STEM listing also names an enclosed patio. Pick the outdoor trap for the barn, and a plug-in trap for the milking room.
How each trap catches flies
Each trap in this guide catches flies in a different way. The Safer and STEM traps (on Amazon) use UV light to attract flies onto glue cards, with a fan on the STEM pulling insects in. The Katchy adds a scent pod for liquid bait and a 360-degree ring light, with fan suction and a hidden glue board. The Terro uses bait and water in a reusable trap, with a diamond-shaped lid designed to attract more flies. If you want no chemicals, the Safer and STEM listings state no chemical insecticides, and the Terro bait (on Amazon) is non-poisonous.
Glue cards and refills
Glue traps need new cards, and the listings state how often. The Katchy listing states to replace glue boards every 3 to 4 weeks, and it includes 4 glue boards. The STEM listing states to replace the glue card when full, and it includes 5 glue traps. The Safer listing states to replace cards as needed, and the pack includes 2 glue cards. The Terro trap is different: it empties and refills with bait and water, so there are no glue cards to replace. Count the included cards when you compare packs.
Read the listing twice
Fly trap listings contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan the setup. The Katchy spec table gives a height of 0.2 inches, which does not match the fan trap the bullets describe. The Safer and Terro listings both show a warranty description of Warranty with no term attached, so this guide states no warranty term for any trap in this guide. The Katchy listing also writes glue boars where it means glue boards. Read the bullets over the spec table when they disagree.
FAQs from goat keepers
Which fly trap works outdoors?
The Terro T380, the only outdoor trap in this guide. The listing states it attracts and traps flies outdoors, and it names house flies, barn flies and bottle flies. The Safer, STEM and Katchy traps are listed for indoor use.
Do any of these traps use chemicals?
The Safer and STEM listings state no chemical insecticides, and the Terro bait is non-poisonous. The Katchy trap uses a fan, a ring light and glue boards, with no zapper.
How often do the glue boards need replacing?
The Katchy listing states every 3 to 4 weeks, and the STEM listing states to replace the glue card when full. The Safer listing states to replace cards as needed. The Terro trap has no glue cards; it empties and refills with bait and water.
Can the Katchy catch house flies?
No. The listing states the trap is effective on fruit flies, gnats and mosquitoes, and not effective on house flies. The STEM and Terro listings name house flies among the flies they attract.
Which trap states a coverage area?
The Safer trap (on Amazon). Each device protects up to 400 sq ft, for 800 sq ft total across the 2-pack. The other listings state no coverage area.
More from the barn
See every goat enrichment guide and all goat keeping guides.
More picks: fly strips, fly trap DIY, how fly traps work and barn equipment.
