Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Weigh Tape vs Hanging Scale: Which One Should You Buy?

Weigh tape vs hanging scale: four tapes compared by stated length, accuracy and lock type, with the listing gaps to check before you buy.

Weigh Tape vs Hanging Scale: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1VEVOR Digital Crane ScaleVEVOR Digital Crane Scale9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2SWTHM Fishing Tournament Weigh In Fish BagSWTHM Fishing Tournament Weigh In Fish Bag9.3/10View on Amazon
  3. 3BRINGERPET Calf Sling for WeighingBRINGERPET Calf Sling for Weighing9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Beyond Fishing Digital Fish Scale with Tape Measure 110 lbBeyond Fishing Digital Fish Scale with Tape Measure 110 lbView on Amazon
  5. 5Sullivan's Calf Scale Weigh TapeSullivan's Calf Scale Weigh TapeView on Amazon
  6. 6Coburn Holstein Dairy Weigh Tape-English/Spanish Brand: CoburnCoburn Holstein Dairy Weigh Tape-English/Spanish Brand: CoburnView on Amazon
  7. 7Coburn Dairy Goat Weigh TapeCoburn Dairy Goat Weigh TapeView on Amazon
  8. 8Coburn 44552 by Breed Dairy Weigh TapeCoburn 44552 by Breed Dairy Weigh TapeView on Amazon

A goat on the fence at feeding time is the wrong moment to discover you have no way to weigh her. Weigh tape vs hanging scale comes down to this: a hanging scale reads weight directly, while a tape reads a girth measurement that you then convert, but every one of the four listings compared here is a tape, and none of them states a weight conversion or a hanging scale. So within this set you are choosing a tape by stated length and accuracy, and looking at the scale guides linked below when you want a direct weight reading.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Weigh tape vs hanging scale: the short answer

Buy the hanging scale when you need a direct weight reading, and buy a tape when you want a light, pocketable tool for a quick estimate in the pen. The four listings in this guide are all tapes: a 60 inch soft tape, an 80 inch retractable body tape, a push-button body tape with no stated length, and an athletic finger wrap that is not a weighing tape at all. None of the four is a hanging scale, and none states a weight conversion, so none of them reads pounds on its own. For actual scales, our best hanging scale for animals roundup scores four of them.

Four tapes, no scale: what the listings cover

Style Example listing Stated length Stated accuracy
Retractable body tape Perfect Measuring Tape 80 inch 80 inches / 2 meters Measures to 1/16 inches
Soft sewing-style tape GDMINLO 60 inch 60 inches ±1/16 inch per 10 feet (±0.16%)
Push-button body tape MyoTape MT05 Not stated Not stated
Athletic finger wrap LYFT-RX hook grip tape 5 yard rolls, 3 roll pack Not stated

Perfect Measuring Tape 80 inch

The Perfect Measuring Tape listing describes an 80 inch (2 meter) retractable body tape with a stainless steel blade, a vinyl body and a push-button pin lock. The bullets say the yellow side automatically calculates body circumference with no adding or subtracting on your part, and the listing states it measures to 1/16 inches. Like the other tapes here, the listing gives no weight conversion, so it reads girth, not pounds.

GDMINLO 60 inch

The GDMINLO listing describes a soft, flexible 60 inch tape with inches on one side, a centimetre scale on the reverse, a slide lock and portability as an additional feature. The stated accuracy is ±1/16 inch per 10 feet (±0.16%). The title calls it a vinyl ruler while the spec table lists the blade material as Metal, so read the title’s vinyl claim as the maker’s own words.

MyoTape MT05

The MyoTape listing states push-button retraction and a locking feature for a snug measurement, with a sturdy vinyl tape, and lists arms, chest, waist, thighs, hips and calves as measurable. No length is stated anywhere in the listing, which makes it the thinnest spec sheet of the four. The title also stuffs in the phrase “myotape mouth tape”, which the bullets never mention.

LYFT-RX hook grip tape

The LYFT-RX listing is not a weighing tape at all: it is a 97% cotton, 3% spandex finger wrap for hook grip in weightlifting, sold as a 3 roll pack of 1.5-inch by 5 yard rolls. It belongs in a gym bag, not a barn tote. It ranks last here because it answers a different question entirely.

Reading the tape: accuracy and markings

Two of the four listings state an accuracy, and two do not. The GDMINLO listing states ±1/16 inch per 10 feet (±0.16%), and the Perfect Measuring Tape listing states it measures to 1/16 inches. The MyoTape and LYFT-RX listings state no accuracy at all. Markings differ too: the GDMINLO has inches on the front and a centimetre scale on the reverse, while the Perfect Measuring Tape has a yellow side that the bullets say calculates circumference for you. The MyoTape relies on its push-button lock to hold the tape snug while you read it.

A finer graduation only matters if you can read it on a moving goat. A 1/16 inch mark is small, and a goat that will not stand still makes any tape an estimate. The lock type matters more in practice: a slide lock (GDMINLO) or a push-button pin lock (Perfect Measuring Tape) holds the tape so both hands are free for the animal.

Length: 60 inches, 80 inches or not stated

The GDMINLO states a 60 inch blade, and the Perfect Measuring Tape states 80 inches (2 meters). The MyoTape states no length, and the LYFT-RX states 5 yard rolls that wrap a finger, not a goat. Pick the length that covers the animal in front of you: a tape that will not reach around the heart girth is useless, and the listing will not tell you what it cannot reach.

Width is a smaller point but it is stated: the GDMINLO blade is 0.5 inches wide, and the Perfect Measuring Tape is 0.51 inches (13 millimeters) wide. A wider tape kinks less when you pull it around a barrel, though neither listing says that; both just state the width.

Where the listings disagree with themselves

Tape listings contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need:

  • GDMINLO: the title calls it a “Vinyl Ruler” while the spec table lists the blade material as Metal. The product details give 60 x 1 x 0.2 inches while the spec table gives a blade width of 0.5 inches. Trust the title and bullets over the spec table.
  • MyoTape: the title includes “myotape mouth tape”, which appears nowhere in the bullets or spec table. It reads like keyword stuffing, not a feature.
  • Perfect Measuring Tape: the bullets claim quality since 1912 and over 100 years of production from Toledo, Ohio, which agree with each other. The spec table’s “Measurement Accuracy: High” is vague next to the bullets’ stated 1/16 inches; use the bullets.
  • LYFT-RX: no internal contradiction, but the listing is a finger wrap for lifters, so every spec on the page answers the wrong question for weighing a goat.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers weighing hardware only. It does not cover how much a goat should weigh, feed rations or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.

FAQs from goat keepers

Which should I buy, a weigh tape or a hanging scale?

Buy the hanging scale when you need a direct weight reading. Buy a tape when you want a light tool for a quick estimate. None of the four listings in this guide is a hanging scale, so see the scale comparisons below for actual scales.

Can I use a body measuring tape on a goat?

The GDMINLO and Perfect Measuring Tape listings describe body and sewing use, not livestock. Both state inch markings that would read a heart girth, 60 inches and 80 inches respectively, but neither states a weight conversion, so neither reads pounds.

Do these tapes convert inches to pounds?

No. None of the four listings states a weight conversion or a weight scale printed on the tape. A tape here reads length only.

What length tape do I need?

The listings state 60 inches for the GDMINLO and 80 inches (2 meters) for the Perfect Measuring Tape; the MyoTape states no length. Pick the length that covers the animal you measure, because a tape that will not reach around the girth is useless.

Is the LYFT-RX tape a weigh tape?

No. The listing describes a 97% cotton, 3% spandex finger wrap for hook grip in weightlifting, sold as a 3 roll pack. It does not measure weight.

Do any of these tapes state a warranty?

None of the four listings states a warranty with a concrete term, so there is no warranty score in this guide. The Perfect Measuring Tape listing invites buyers to message with issues, but that is not a stated term.

More from the barn

See every weight tape and scale guide and all our livestock scale guides.

More picks: weigh tape vs livestock scale, hanging scale vs platform scale, hanging scales for animals and livestock scales for goats.