Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Wood vs Plastic Barn Cat House: Which One Should You Buy?

Wood vs plastic barn cat house: three wood houses and one foldable canvas house compared by material, insulation, size, stated cat capacity and warranty.

Wood vs Plastic Barn Cat House: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Dahivs Large Heated Cat House for OutsideDahivs Large Heated Cat House for Outside9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2GUTINNEEN Large Outdoor Cat HouseGUTINNEEN Large Outdoor Cat House9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3PLEKER 31.5 Inch Heated Outdoor Cat House with Heating PadPLEKER 31.5 Inch Heated Outdoor Cat House with Heating Pad9.7/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Outdoor Cat House Cat House for Outdoor and Indoor UseOutdoor Cat House Cat House for Outdoor and Indoor UseView on Amazon
  5. 5Ketive Insulated Outdoor Cat House Weatherproof Wooden FeralKetive Insulated Outdoor Cat House Weatherproof Wooden FeralView on Amazon
  6. 6Aivituvin Outdoor Cat House Weatherproof Wooden for Feral CatsAivituvin Outdoor Cat House Weatherproof Wooden for Feral CatsView on Amazon
  7. 7PetsCosset Weatherproof 2-Story Outdoor Cat House withPetsCosset Weatherproof 2-Story Outdoor Cat House withView on Amazon
  8. 8Heated Outdoor Cat House Large 2 Story with Escape DoorsHeated Outdoor Cat House Large 2 Story with Escape DoorsView on Amazon
  9. 9Indestructible Heated Cat House for OutsideIndestructible Heated Cat House for OutsideView on Amazon

Barn cats earn their keep around the feed room, and by the time the morning milking is done they are looking for a dry corner out of the wind, which is where the wood vs plastic barn cat house question starts. The plain answer from the listings compared here: choose wood for a house that lives in the barn all winter, because the wood houses in this group state insulated walls, raised floors and roofs that shed rain and snow. One honest note before the details: none of the four listings compared here is a plastic house. Three are wood and one is foldable canvas, so this guide compares what those listings state and says what a plastic house would have to match.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Wood vs plastic barn cat house: the short answer

Start with where the house will sit. A house that stays in one corner of the barn or porch all year suits solid walls and insulation, and that is what the three wood houses here state: insulated liners or foam on all sides, slanted or asphalt roofs, and raised bases or feet that lift the floor off wet ground. A house you move between the barn, the porch and the garage suits the foldable canvas house, which folds flat, assembles without tools and weighs 2.76 pounds. A plastic house would need to state the same things to compete: insulation or a liner, a roof that sheds water, a raised floor and a stated cat capacity. None of the listings here is plastic, so judge any plastic house you find against those stated features.

If you would rather go straight to scored picks, our best barn cat house for small barns roundup compares houses on these points.

The four houses compared

House Material Size Stated capacity Insulation or heat Warranty
Aivituvin Heated Cat House Solid fir wood 39.1 x 18.5 x 19.1 in 1 to 3 cats 6-sided liner, UL heating pad 89 to 116 F 21 years manufacture
GUTINNEEN Insulated Cat House Solid wood 23.6 x 20.9 x 18.3 in 2 cats up to 25 lb 6-sided liner, 0.78 in thermal pad 1 Year Manufacturer
Ketive Insulated Cat House Fir wood 22.4 x 18.5 x 18 in 1 to 2 cats up to 22 lb 6-side foam, 0.4 in foam core Not stated
H HONG RI SHENG Cat House Waterproof canvas 16.93 x 15.75 x 16.93 in (Large) Pets under 13.2 lb (Large) Removable inner pad Not stated

Aivituvin Heated Cat House (wood, heated)

The Aivituvin is the largest house here at 39.1 x 18.5 x 19.1 inches and 26.4 pounds, built from solid fir wood with a 6-sided insulated liner. It adds a UL heating pad with automatic temperature control stated at 89 to 116 F and a high-temperature protection device, and the maker states room for 1 to 3 cats. Assembly uses pre-drilled holes and is stated at approximately 30 minutes. The warranty is stated as 21 years manufacture, which is the longest term in this group as written.

GUTINNEEN Insulated Cat House (wood)

The GUTINNEEN is a solid wood house at 23.6 x 20.9 x 18.3 inches and 21.1 pounds, with a thermal liner on all six sides and a removable 0.78 in thermal pad on the floor. A slanted roof sheds rain and snow and the raised base lifts the floor off wet ground. The maker states room for two kittens or one cat up to 25 lb, assembly with a screwdriver in about 20 minutes, and a 1 Year Manufacturer warranty.

Ketive Insulated Cat House (wood)

The Ketive house is fir wood at 22.4 x 18.5 x 18 inches and 17.0 pounds, with insulation foam on 6 sides and a 3-layer wall built around a 0.4 in foam core. It has an openable asphalt roof, a PVC door flap, raised feet and an escape door, and the maker states an interior size of 1.68 square feet for 1 or 2 small cats weighing up to 22 pounds. No warranty term is stated.

H HONG RI SHENG Cat House (canvas, foldable)

The H HONG RI SHENG house is the odd one out on material: waterproof canvas that folds flat, with a removable inner pad and tool-free assembly. The Large size is stated at 16.93 x 15.75 x 16.93 inches for pets under 13.2 lb, and the house weighs 2.76 pounds, far lighter than the wood houses. It can be used with a heating pad, but the pad is not included. No warranty term is stated.

Wood vs plastic: what changes in the barn

Material decides three things in a barn: how the house handles wet floors, how it handles cold nights, and how much work it is to move. The wood houses here answer the first two with stated features: raised bases or feet, slanted or asphalt roofs, sealed panels and insulated liners or foam. The canvas house answers the third: it folds flat for storage and travel and assembles without tools, which none of the wood houses claim. A plastic house sits between those poles in most catalogs, light like canvas and rigid like wood, but since no listing here is plastic, this guide cannot score one. When you compare a plastic house against these four, ask the same questions: is insulation or a liner stated, is the floor raised, does the roof shed water, and what cat capacity and warranty are stated?

Size and stated cat capacity

Capacity on these listings is given as a cat count, a weight limit, or both. The Aivituvin states 1 to 3 cats in a 39.1 inch wide house. The GUTINNEEN states two kittens or one cat up to 25 lb. The Ketive states 1 or 2 small cats weighing up to 22 pounds, with an interior size of 1.68 square feet. The canvas house states pets under 13.2 lb in the Large size and under 8.8 lb in the Medium size, which makes it a single-cat house for most barn cats. Measure the corner you have in mind before ordering, and leave room for the house to sit clear of feed sacks and water buckets.

Insulation and heat

Three of the four houses state insulation. The Aivituvin pairs a 6-sided insulated liner with a UL heating pad stated at 89 to 116 F. The GUTINNEEN pairs a 6-sided thermal liner with a removable 0.78 in thermal pad. The Ketive uses insulation foam on 6 sides with a 0.4 in foam core in a 3-layer wall. The canvas house has a removable inner pad and can be used with a heating pad that is not included. If a heated house is the goal, our best heated outdoor cat house roundup scores heated models, and the best cat house outdoor guide covers unheated houses.

Read the listing twice

Cat house listings contradict themselves on the numbers you need for planning:

  • H HONG RI SHENG: the Large size is stated at 16.93 x 15.75 x 16.93 inches in the bullets and 15.0 x 16.0 x 15.0 inches in the details.
  • Ketive: the warranty field reads “Need to Assemble”, which is not a warranty term, so treat the warranty as not stated.
  • Aivituvin: the warranty is stated as 21 years manufacture, far longer than the 1 Year Manufacturer term on the GUTINNEEN, so read the warranty paperwork when the house arrives.

Measure your space before ordering and allow for the larger figure where two are given.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers cat house hardware only: materials, sizes, insulation and stated capacities. It does not cover cat health, feeding or behavior. Ask your veterinarian about health questions for barn cats.

FAQs from goat keepers

Is wood or plastic better for a barn cat house?

From the listings compared here, wood is the stated option for a house that stays in the barn: the three wood houses state insulated walls, raised floors and roofs that shed rain and snow. No listing here is plastic, so judge a plastic house by whether it states the same features.

Which of these houses fits two cats?

The Aivituvin states room for 1 to 3 cats, the GUTINNEEN states two kittens or one cat up to 25 lb, and the Ketive states 1 or 2 small cats weighing up to 22 pounds. The canvas house states pets under 13.2 lb in the Large size.

Do these cat houses come with heat?

Only the Aivituvin includes heat: a UL heating pad with automatic temperature control stated at 89 to 116 F. The canvas house can be used with a heating pad, but the pad is not included.

How long does assembly take?

The GUTINNEEN states about 20 minutes with a screwdriver, and the Aivituvin states approximately 30 minutes with pre-drilled holes. The canvas house is tool-free and folds flat. The Ketive listing does not state a clear assembly time.

More from the barn

See every barn cat gear guide and all farm dogs and barn cats guides.

More picks: best barn cat houses for small barns, best cat houses outdoor, best heated outdoor cat houses and best heated cat houses for two cats.