
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Weaver Equine Wool Blend Felt Western Saddle Pad9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Harrison Howard Western Bareback Saddle Pad with Matching9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Harrison Howard Wither Pad for Western Saddle9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Professional's Choice 100% Steam-Pressed Wool Felt WesternView on Amazon - 5
Classic Equine Performance Trainer Saddle PadView on Amazon - 6
Eccliy 2 Pcs Wool Blend Felt Western Saddle Pad Liner forView on Amazon - 7
BLACK HOOF Steam Pressed Merino Wool Felt Contoured PadView on Amazon - 8
Mustang Wool Blanket Protector for Horseback RidingView on Amazon
The saddle slips a little by the end of a long ride, and the pad underneath is damp with sweat, which is when the wool vs synthetic saddle pad question comes up: wool felt that wicks moisture, or a synthetic pad built for the same job. The listings in this guide are all wool: steam-pressed wool felt, wool blend felt, and a wool felt center with a Merino fleece bottom, so the wool side is the side with evidence here. Pick wool for the wicking and cushioning the listings state, and check any synthetic pad against the same figures: thickness, size, and fit.
Also worth comparing
Professional's Choice 100% Steam-Pressed Wool Felt WesternCheck price on Amazon
Weaver Equine Wool Blend Felt Western Saddle Pad for HorsesCheck price on Amazon
Classic Equine Performance Trainer Saddle PadCheck price on Amazon
Eccliy 2 Pcs Wool Blend Felt Western Saddle Pad Liner forCheck price on Amazon
BLACK HOOF Steam Pressed Merino Wool Felt Contoured PadCheck price on Amazon
Mustang Wool Blanket Protector for Horseback RidingCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Wool vs synthetic saddle pad: the short answer
Start with the material, then check thickness, size, and fit. Wool felt wicks moisture away from the horse, per the listings, and the pads here run from a 1/2-inch liner to a 1-inch steam-pressed felt. No synthetic pad is among the listings in this guide, so the synthetic side has no listing to compare here; judge a synthetic pad by the same figures the wool listings state: thickness, size, contoured fit, and wear leathers. The pads below are ordered by those figures, with the thickest felt first.
Wool pads compared
| Pad | Material | Thickness | Size | Weight | Best fit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Professional’s Choice steam-pressed wool felt | 100% wool felt | 1 in | 31 x 32 in | 8.0 lb | Long rides and training |
| Classic Equine Performance Trainer | Wool felt, Merino fleece bottom | 3/4 in | 31 x 32 in | 7.05 lb | Training with a fleece bottom |
| Weaver Equine wool blend felt | Wool blend felt | 3/4 in | 30 x 30 in | 5.19 lb | Daily training, trail and barrel work |
| Weaver Equine wool blend felt liner | Wool blend felt | 1/2 in | 30 x 30 in | 1.65 lb | A liner under a saddle pad |
Steam-pressed wool felt
The Professional’s Choice pad is 100% steam-pressed wool felt, 31 by 32 by 1 inches, weighing 8.0 pounds. The listing states a contoured spine with wither relief, a cutback front for shoulder freedom, oversized wear leathers, and a soft felt bottom that wicks sweat and moisture away from the skin. The felt is described as giving impact protection and shock absorption with long lasting durability, and the contoured back is shaped to reduce pressure points and add airflow.
Wool blend felt
The Weaver Equine pads are a wool felt blend in tan, both 30 by 30 inches and contoured to shape to the horse’s back. The thicker Weaver pad is 3/4 inch thick and weighs 5.19 pounds, with a reinforced pad spine and top grain wear leathers, and the listing names daily training, trail and barrel work. The thinner Weaver pad is a 1/2-inch liner weighing 1.65 pounds, with a pad spine and top grain wear leathers, listed as a saddle pad liner and saddle pad protection. Both state shock absorption, extra cushioning, and moisture-wicking action that cools the horse, and both state a close contact fit that reduces saddle roll.
Wool felt with a Merino fleece bottom
The Classic Equine Performance Trainer is black, 31 by 32 inches, weighing 7.05 pounds. It lists a 3/4-inch wool felt center for shock protection, a 100 percent Merino fleece bottom that wicks moisture, and a heavy-duty canvas top for durability, with a contoured design for better fit and comfort. The fleece bottom is the feature that sets it apart from the felt bottoms on the other pads here.
Thickness, size and fit
Thickness runs from 1/2 inch to 1 inch across the pads here. The Professional’s Choice felt is 1 inch thick, the Classic Equine pad and the thicker Weaver pad are 3/4 inch thick, and the Weaver liner is 1/2 inch thick. Size splits the same way: the Professional’s Choice and Classic Equine pads list 31 by 32 inches, and the Weaver pads list 30 by 30 inches. Weights run from 1.65 pounds for the liner to 8.0 pounds for the Professional’s Choice felt, with the Classic Equine pad at 7.05 pounds and the thicker Weaver pad at 5.19 pounds.
Fit is contoured on every pad here. The Professional’s Choice pad states a contoured spine with wither relief and a cutback front for shoulder freedom. The Weaver pads state a contoured shape that reduces saddle roll and cutouts under the wear leathers. The Classic Equine pad states a contoured design for better fit and comfort. Check the contoured spine against the horse’s withers and the pad size against the saddle before ordering.
Wicking and wear
Every pad here states moisture wicking. The Professional’s Choice felt wicks moisture and sweat away from the horse during work, and its soft felt bottom helps keep the horse cool and dry. The Weaver pads state moisture-wicking action that cools the horse. The Classic Equine pad states a Merino fleece bottom that wicks moisture.
Wear leathers guard the points where the saddle rubs. The Professional’s Choice pad lists oversized wear leathers, and the Weaver pads list top grain wear leathers. The Classic Equine pad lists a heavy-duty canvas top for durability instead of wear leathers. For western saddles and the pads that go with them, see our english vs western saddle comparison.
Read the listing twice
Saddle pad listings often contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan the fit:
- Weaver 3/4-inch pad: the title and bullets state 3/4 inch thick, while the spec table lists dimensions of 30 by 30 by 0.00399999999592 inches, a thickness figure that cannot describe the pad.
- Weaver liner: the title and bullets state a 1/2-inch liner, while the spec table lists 30.0 by 30.0 by 30.0 inches, a third figure that cannot be the thickness of a liner.
- Professional’s Choice and Classic Equine: the titles list 31 by 32 inches, while the spec tables list 32.0 by 14.0 by 2.0 inches, which reads as a folded or packaged size rather than the pad laid flat.
Measure the saddle and the horse before ordering and allow for the larger figure. The Weaver liner is listed as a liner, not a standalone pad, so do not expect it to carry a saddle on its own.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers saddle pad materials only. It does not cover saddles, fitting a saddle to a horse, or any health question. Ask your veterinarian about saddle fit and horse health.
FAQs from goat keepers
Is wool or synthetic better for a saddle pad?
It depends on the pad. The listings in this guide are all wool, from a 1/2-inch liner to a 1-inch steam-pressed felt, and each states moisture wicking. No synthetic pad is listed here, so compare a synthetic pad on thickness, size, and fit against these wool figures.
How thick should a wool saddle pad be?
The listings here run from 1/2 inch for the Weaver liner to 1 inch for the Professional’s Choice felt, with 3/4 inch on the Weaver pad and the Classic Equine pad. The 1-inch pad states impact protection and shock absorption, the 3/4-inch pads state cushioning, and the 1/2-inch liner states a padded base.
What size saddle pad do I need?
Match the pad to the saddle and the horse. The Professional’s Choice and Classic Equine pads list 31 by 32 inches, and the Weaver pads list 30 by 30 inches. Check the contoured spine and wither relief on the Professional’s Choice pad, and the contoured fit on the Weaver and Classic Equine pads.
Do wool saddle pads wick sweat?
Yes, per the listings. The Professional’s Choice pad states wool felt that wicks moisture and sweat away from the horse, the Weaver pads state moisture-wicking action, and the Classic Equine pad states a Merino fleece bottom that wicks moisture.
More from the barn
See every horse tack guide and all horse care guides.
More picks: english vs western saddle, leather vs nylon horse halter, panniers for pack saddles and corded vs cordless horse clippers.
