
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Caydo Amish Style Wooden Yarn Swift9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
HAND U JOURNEY Beechwood Niddy Noddy9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Savina Wooden Niddy Noddy for Yarn9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Lampstop Beechwood Niddy NoddyView on Amazon - 5
SPEENSUN Yarn Winder and Swift ComboView on Amazon - 6
Olikraft Yarn Winder and Umbrella Swift SetView on Amazon - 7
Wooden Umbrella Yarn SwiftView on Amazon
A fresh skein straight off the wheel is a loose loop that tangles the moment it is left on its own, and yarn swift vs niddy noddy is the question that decides which tool keeps that loop in order. A swift holds a skein open so yarn can be wound into a ball, while a niddy noddy winds yarn into a skein. Every listing in this guide is a niddy noddy and none is a yarn swift, so the swift side of this comparison rests on what each tool is for rather than on a swift listing. If the job is winding yarn into a skein, pick from the niddy noddies below; if the job is unwinding a skein into a ball, a swift is the tool to look for instead.
Also worth comparing
Savina Wooden Niddy Noddy for YarnCheck price on Amazon
Lampstop Beechwood Niddy NoddyCheck price on Amazon
HAND U JOURNEY Beechwood Niddy NoddyCheck price on Amazon
SPEENSUN Yarn Winder and Swift ComboCheck price on Amazon
Olikraft Yarn Winder and Umbrella Swift SetCheck price on Amazon
Wooden Umbrella Yarn SwiftCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Yarn swift vs niddy noddy: the short answer
Pick a niddy noddy when yarn needs winding into a skein, and pick a swift when a skein needs unwinding into a ball. The two tools do opposite jobs at opposite ends of the same loop of yarn, so the right choice follows the job at hand. The ranked niddy noddies in this guide start with the BENECREAT Wooden Niddy Noddy at 13.4 x 8.3 x 0.78 inches, then the BENECREAT Wooden Niddy Noddy at 7.87 x 6.3 x 0.8 inches, the Savina Wooden Niddy Noddy for a 48-inch skein and the Lampstop Beechwood Niddy Noddy for 1 yard and 1.33 yard skeins. Swift shoppers can start with the best yarn swift roundup, while readers set on a niddy noddy can compare the wider field in the best niddy noddy for yarn roundup.
How a swift and a niddy noddy differ
A swift and a niddy noddy both handle skeins, but at different moments. A swift opens a skein into a wide loop and holds it steady while yarn feeds off into a ball, keeping the strand from tangling as it unwinds. A niddy noddy takes loose yarn and winds it into a neat skein for storage or for the next step in the fiber chain. Buying the wrong tool leaves the job undone: a swift cannot wind a skein, and a niddy noddy cannot hold one open for ball winding.
| Tool | What it does | When to reach for it |
|---|---|---|
| Yarn swift | Holds a skein open while yarn winds into a ball | When a skein needs unwinding into a ball |
| Niddy noddy | Winds yarn into a skein | When loose yarn needs winding into a skein |
Yarn swifts
A yarn swift holds a skein open while yarn winds off into a ball, which keeps the strand from tangling as it unwinds. No swift listing appears in this guide, so the swift side of this comparison has no stated size, material or box contents to compare. Compare the picks in the best yarn swift roundup before ordering.
Niddy noddies
A niddy noddy winds yarn into a skein by hand, looping the strand around a frame until the skein is full. Every listing in this guide is a niddy noddy, and the gear section below ranks them by the specs each listing states. The two BENECREAT picks give full stated sizes and box contents, while the Savina and Lampstop picks give a skein size in the name and little else, so the ranking puts the fuller listings ahead of the thinner ones.
The niddy noddies in this guide
The gear section below lists the niddy noddies in ranked order, with the fuller listings ahead of the title-only listings. Each row gives the stated size, the stated material and what the listing says comes in the box.
| Niddy noddy | Stated size | Material | In the box |
|---|---|---|---|
| BENECREAT Wooden Niddy Noddy, 13.4×8.3×0.78 Inch | 13.4 x 8.3 x 0.78 inches | Wood | 1 set |
| BENECREAT Wooden Niddy Noddy, 7.87×6.3×0.8in | 7.87 x 6.3 x 0.8 inches | Wood | 1 set |
| Savina Wooden Niddy Noddy, 48-Inch Skein Winder | 48-inch skein | Not stated | Not stated |
| Lampstop Beechwood Niddy Noddy, 1 Yard and 1.33 Yard Skein | 1 yard and 1.33 yard skeins | Beechwood | Not stated |
BENECREAT Wooden Niddy Noddy, 13.4×8.3×0.78 Inch
The maker lists this niddy noddy at 13.4 x 8.3 x 0.78 inches, made of sturdy wood with a smooth surface without burrs, and the special shape of the crossbar allows the yarn to slide easily when making a skein. The yarn passes through a groove, then wraps around the winding board until finished, and the listing says the tool keeps the desktop neat and tidy. It ships as 1 set, and the maker calls it a gift for beginners and sewing enthusiasts, for spooling threads and organizing embroidery threads.
BENECREAT Wooden Niddy Noddy, 7.87×6.3×0.8in
The maker lists this niddy noddy at 7.87 x 6.3 x 0.8 inches, made of sturdy wood with a smooth surface without burrs, and the same crossbar shape allows the yarn to slide easily when making a skein. Winding matches the larger pick: pass one end of the yarn through the groove, wrap the yarn around the winding board, and continue until finished. It ships as 1 set, and the maker calls it a gift for beginners and sewing enthusiasts. The smaller stated size suits a shorter skein and a smaller worktop, while the larger pick suits a longer skein.
Savina Wooden Niddy Noddy, 48-Inch Skein Winder
The maker states a 48-inch skein winder in the name and gives no further specs in the listing: no material, no tool dimensions and no box contents are stated. That thin listing is why this pick ranks below the two BENECREAT picks. Check the skein length against the yarn on hand before ordering.
Lampstop Beechwood Niddy Noddy, 1 Yard and 1.33 Yard Skein
The maker states a beechwood niddy noddy for 1 yard and 1.33 yard skeins, and gives no further specs in the listing: no tool dimensions and no box contents are stated. The two stated skein lengths cover a short skein and a longer one, which suits winding more than one skein length with the same tool. Like the Savina pick, this one ranks below the two BENECREAT picks, so check the stated skein lengths before ordering.
Reading skein size before you buy
The listings in this guide state skein size in different ways. The BENECREAT picks state tool dimensions rather than a skein length, at 13.4 x 8.3 x 0.78 inches and 7.87 x 6.3 x 0.8 inches, so the skein they wind follows the frame size. The Savina pick states a 48-inch skein, and the Lampstop pick states 1 yard and 1.33 yard skeins, so those two give the skein length straight away. Match the stated figure to the skein length the yarn needs, and when a listing states tool dimensions only, picture the frame against the skein in mind before ordering.
How to choose the best yarn swift vs niddy noddy
Choosing between a yarn swift and a niddy noddy starts with the job, then moves to the stated size and the stated specs.
Start with the job: making a skein or unwinding one
When loose yarn needs winding into a skein, a niddy noddy is the tool for the job, and the picks in this guide all do that work. When a skein needs unwinding into a ball, a swift is the tool for the job, and no swift listing appears in this guide. Name the job before shopping: skein-making points to the niddy noddy table above, and ball-winding points to a swift roundup.
Match the stated size to the skein
Match the stated size to the skein length the yarn needs. The BENECREAT picks state tool dimensions of 13.4 x 8.3 x 0.78 inches and 7.87 x 6.3 x 0.8 inches, the Savina pick states a 48-inch skein, and the Lampstop pick states 1 yard and 1.33 yard skeins. Longer skeins lean toward the larger stated figures, shorter skeins toward the smaller ones. Readers winding large skeins can also compare the best yarn winder for wool roundup for more winding picks.
Check what the listing actually states
Read the listing for what it states and what it leaves out. The BENECREAT picks state material, size, winding instructions and box contents, while the Savina and Lampstop picks state a skein length and little else. A thin listing leaves the buyer to confirm size and material before ordering. When the listing leaves a question open, the fuller listings in this guide are the safer pick.
FAQs from goat keepers
What is the difference between a yarn swift and a niddy noddy?
A yarn swift holds a skein open while yarn winds into a ball, and a niddy noddy winds yarn into a skein. The swift unwinds a skein, the niddy noddy makes one, so the job at hand decides which tool to buy.
Can a niddy noddy replace a yarn swift?
No. A niddy noddy winds yarn into a skein and cannot hold a skein open for ball winding, while a swift holds a skein open and cannot wind one. The two tools do different jobs at different moments in the winding chain.
What size niddy noddy fits the skein?
Match the stated size to the skein length the yarn needs. The BENECREAT picks state 13.4 x 8.3 x 0.78 inches and 7.87 x 6.3 x 0.8 inches, the Savina pick states a 48-inch skein, and the Lampstop pick states 1 yard and 1.33 yard skeins.
What comes in the box with these niddy noddies?
The BENECREAT picks ship as 1 set, and the Savina and Lampstop listings state nothing about box contents. When a listing states nothing about the box, the tool alone is what the listing promises.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers winding hardware only. It does not cover yarn weights, dyeing, spinning technique or how much yarn a project needs. For those questions, look to a spinning or dyeing guide rather than a hardware listing.
More from the barn
See every spinning guide and all wool and fiber guides.
More picks: best niddy noddy for yarn, best yarn winder for wool, best yarn winder for large skeins and best mini spinning wheel.
