Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Best Boot Scraper Tray (2026): 5 Picks Compared

Five boot scraper trays compared by size, edge height, material and stated warranty, for muddy boots at the barn door daily.

Top picks

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

How we score

Best Boot Scraper Tray (2026): 5 Picks Compared
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Matace Rubber Boot Tray 55 inBest OverallMatace Rubber Boot Tray 55 in9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2WATANIYA Boot Tray 2-PackBest Two-PackWATANIYA Boot Tray 2-Pack9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Stalwart Boot Tray Large 30 inBest LargeStalwart Boot Tray Large 30 in9.5/10View on Amazon
  4. 4tchdio Boot Tray 16×27.5 inBest for Three Pairstchdio Boot Tray 16×27.5 in9.5/10View on Amazon
  5. 5Stalwart Boot Tray 23.75 inBest Small EntrywayStalwart Boot Tray 23.75 in9.5/10View on Amazon

Mud on boots follows the morning chores inside, and the best boot scraper tray keeps that mess by the door instead of across the floor. This guide compares trays by size, edge height, material and stated warranty, using only what each maker publishes. The picks below cover rubber and recycled plastic trays in short and long sizes, so the right tray depends on the doorway and the boots that cross it.

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Quick picks

  • Matace Rubber Boot Tray 55 in
    Best Overall Matace Rubber Boot Tray 55 in: 55 by 16 inches of rubber with a 1.18 inch raised edge Check price on Amazon
  • WATANIYA Boot Tray 2-Pack
    Best Two-Pack WATANIYA Boot Tray 2-Pack: Two trays, 16.7 by 12.8 inches, with 4 non-slip gaskets Check price on Amazon
  • Stalwart Boot Tray Large 30 in
    Best Large Stalwart Boot Tray Large 30 in: 30 by 15 inches, recycled plastic, 30-day warranty stated Check price on Amazon
  • tchdio Boot Tray 16x27.5 in
    Best for Three Pairs tchdio Boot Tray 16×27.5 in: Holds three pairs, 27.5 by 16 inches, non-slip rubber Check price on Amazon
  • Stalwart Boot Tray 23.75 in
    Best Small Entryway Stalwart Boot Tray 23.75 in: 23.75 by 15.5 inches, recycled plastic, 30-day warranty Check price on Amazon

The gear we picked

Matace Rubber Boot Tray 55 in

Matace Rubber Boot Tray 55 in

Matace9.6/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 55 by 16 inch rubber tray with a 1.18 inch raised edge, made from 100% recyclable rubber for indoor and outdoor use.

Pros

  • 55 by 16 inches, the longest tray in this guide
  • 1.18 inch raised edge keeps water and mud inside
  • 100% recyclable rubber, stated as more non-slip than plastic
  • Suits boots, plants, pet food and car trunks, per the maker

Cons

  • No warranty term is stated
  • 7.0 pounds, the heaviest tray here
  • 55 inches needs a long, clear stretch of floor
  • Single tray only, unlike the 2-pack WATANIYA tray
WATANIYA Boot Tray 2-Pack

WATANIYA Boot Tray 2-Pack

WATANIYA PET9.6/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 2-pack of 16.7 by 12.8 inch trays in 100% recycled polypropylene, with a 1.2 inch raised edge and 4 non-slip gaskets.

Pros

  • Two trays in the pack, one for each door
  • 4 non-slip gaskets keep the tray from sliding
  • 100% recycled polypropylene with a 1.2 inch raised edge
  • Rinses clean with water and towel dries

Cons

  • No warranty term is stated
  • 16.7 by 12.8 inches is the smallest tray here
  • Two small trays instead of one long tray
  • Plastic build where rubber trays offer more grip
Stalwart Boot Tray Large 30 in

Stalwart Boot Tray Large 30 in

Stalwart9.5/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 30 by 15 inch tray in 100% recycled polypropylene with a 1.25 inch raised edge, for indoor and outdoor use.

Pros

  • 30 by 15 inches, the widest plastic tray here
  • 100% recycled polypropylene build
  • Raised edge contains water, sleet, snow and dirt
  • 30 day warranty is stated

Cons

  • No non-slip bottom is stated
  • 30 inches needs a wide entryway
  • Single tray only, no second tray in the box
  • Hard plastic build where rubber trays offer more grip
tchdio Boot Tray 16x27.5 in

tchdio Boot Tray 16x27.5 in

tchdio9.5/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 16 by 27.5 inch rubber tray with raised edges, stated to hold three pairs of shoes or boots.

Pros

  • Stated to hold three pairs of shoes or boots
  • Non-slip rubber build
  • Raised edges contain liquids and debris
  • Flushes clean and air dries

Cons

  • 0.8 inch edge is the lowest here
  • 27.5 inches needs a clear stretch by the door
  • Single tray only, no second tray for another door
  • Stated capacity is three pairs, so more boots need another tray
Stalwart Boot Tray 23.75 in

Stalwart Boot Tray 23.75 in

Stalwart9.5/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 23.75 by 15.5 inch tray in 100% recycled polypropylene with a 1.25 inch raised edge, for indoor and outdoor use.

Pros

  • 23.75 by 15.5 inches, the smaller Stalwart size
  • 100% recycled polypropylene build
  • Raised edge contains water, sleet, snow and dirt
  • 30 day warranty is stated

Cons

  • No non-slip bottom is stated
  • Smaller than the 30 inch Stalwart tray
  • Single tray only, no second tray in the box
  • Hard plastic build where rubber trays offer more grip

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


More picks to compare

  • WATANIYA Boot Tray 2-Pack, TanWATANIYA Boot Tray 2-Pack, TanSame 16.7 by 12.8 inch 2-pack in tan, with 4 non-slip gaskets.Check on Amazon
  • Ottomanson Boot Tray 15 x 30Ottomanson Boot Tray 15 x 3015 by 30 inches with a 1.2 inch raised edge, for boots and pet feeding spills.Check on Amazon
  • BEHERO Rubber Boot TrayBEHERO Rubber Boot Tray16 by 27.5 inch rubber tray with a vintage pattern and raised edge.Check on Amazon
  • FOOTMATTERS Coir Scrubber TrayFOOTMATTERS Coir Scrubber Tray29.5 by 17.5 inch coir mat that strips mud, snow and grass off boots.Check on Amazon

Spec comparison

Tray GoatGear Score Size Edge Material Warranty Amazon
Matace Rubber Boot Tray 55 in 9.6/10 55 x 16 in 1.18 in Rubber Not stated View on Amazon
WATANIYA Boot Tray 2-Pack 9.6/10 16.7 x 12.8 in 1.2 in Recycled polypropylene Not stated View on Amazon
Stalwart Boot Tray Large 30 in 9.5/10 30 x 15 in 1.25 in Recycled polypropylene 30-day View on Amazon
tchdio Boot Tray 16×27.5 in 9.5/10 27.5 x 16 in 0.8 in Rubber Not stated
Stalwart Boot Tray 23.75 in 9.5/10 23.75 x 15.5 in 1.25 in Recycled polypropylene 30-day View on Amazon

Figures come from the product pages and reflect what the maker rates, current as of 21 November 2026.

How to choose the best boot scraper tray

Measure the doorway first

Sizes here run from 16.7 by 12.8 inches on the WATANIYA 2-pack to 55 by 16 inches on the Matace rubber tray, with the Stalwart large at 30 by 15 inches and the tchdio at 27.5 by 16 inches in between. A short tray suits a single door, while the 55 inch Matace suits a long mudroom wall where several pairs wait. Check the width of the doorway before ordering, since a tray that sticks out past the door frame gets kicked and shifted. Pair the tray with a boot dryer for tall boots to dry what the tray catches.

Rubber or recycled plastic

Two trays here are rubber and three are 100% recycled polypropylene, and the choice comes down to grip and weight. The Matace and tchdio rubber trays state non-slip builds, and Matace states rubber is more non-slip than plastic. The plastic trays are lighter in the hand, with the Stalwart large listed at 1.76 pounds and the Stalwart small at 1.15 pounds, while the Matace rubber tray is listed at 7.0 pounds. Rubber suits a tray that stays put by the door, and plastic suits a tray that gets carried out to rinse. See the boot scraper brush cleaner guide for a brush that pairs with a tray.

Edge height holds the mess

The raised edge is what keeps melt water and mud on the tray. Edge heights here are 1.2 inches on the WATANIYA 2-pack, 1.25 inches on both Stalwart trays, 1.18 inches on the Matace and 0.8 inches on the tchdio. A taller edge holds more melt water from snowy boots, while the 0.8 inch edge on the tchdio suits boots that are damp rather than caked. Match the edge to the mess the boots bring in.

Tray Size Edge
Matace Rubber Boot Tray 55 x 16 in 1.18 in
Stalwart Large Boot Tray 30 x 15 in 1.25 in
tchdio Boot Tray 27.5 x 16 in 0.8 in

Where the tray lives

Every tray here is stated for indoor and outdoor use, so the same tray works by the back door in summer and the mudroom in winter. A rubber tray suits a spot that stays damp, while a plastic tray suits a spot that gets carried out to rinse. Keep the tray where boots come off, not where they get stored, so mud stops at the door. A winter boot liner guide covers what goes inside the boots the tray catches.

Warranty and pack size

Only the two Stalwart trays state a warranty term, and both state 30 days. The WATANIYA 2-pack is the only pack of two here, which suits a house with a front door and a back door. The other trays are single trays, so a house with more than one busy door needs another tray for the other door. Check the pack count before ordering, since a single tray covers one doorway.

Around the Barn

  • Set the tray where boots come off, with the raised edge facing the room so melt water stays on the tray.
  • Rinse the tray with water and towel dry it, or flush it and let it air dry, as the makers describe.
  • Keep the non-slip gaskets on the WATANIYA 2-pack against the floor so the tray stays put.
  • Use the long Matace tray where several pairs wait by the door, and the small WATANIYA trays where space is tight.

FAQs from goat keepers

What size boot scraper tray fits a mudroom entryway?

Sizes here run from 16.7 by 12.8 inches to 55 by 16 inches. Measure the doorway first, then pick a tray that sits flat inside the space without sticking out past the frame.

Does a rubber boot tray grip better than a plastic one?

Matace states rubber is more non-slip than plastic, and both rubber trays here state non-slip builds. The WATANIYA plastic tray answers with 4 non-slip gaskets on the bottom.

How do you clean a boot scraper tray?

Rinse the tray with water and towel dry it, or flush it and let it air dry. Stubborn stains can be soaked in water and cleaned with a brush or soft cloth, per the maker.

Which boot scraper tray has a warranty?

Two of the five trays state a warranty term: both Stalwart trays state a 30 day warranty. The other three trays state no warranty term.

Can one boot tray hold three pairs of boots?

The tchdio tray is stated to hold three pairs of shoes or boots at 27.5 by 16 inches. The 55 inch Matace tray is the longest here.

Matace Rubber Boot Tray 55 in
Still deciding? Our top pickMatace Rubber Boot Tray 55 in
Check price on Amazon

Behind the Farm Score

The GoatGear Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For boot trays, performance means size and edge height that contain mud and water, build means the stated material, value means what the stated size and pack offer, and safety means a stated non-slip bottom or rubber grip that keeps the tray in place. Two of the five trays state a warranty term, and both state 30 days. How we pick explains the weights.

Product GoatGear Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
Matace Rubber Boot Tray 55 in 9.6 32 22 20 7 0
WATANIYA Boot Tray 2-Pack 9.6 29 21 21 7 0
Stalwart Boot Tray Large 30 in 9.5 30 21 20 0 3
tchdio Boot Tray 16×27.5 in 9.5 29 20 19 7 0
Stalwart Boot Tray 23.75 in 9.5 28 20 20 0 3

Points become a score between 9.2 and 9.8 by simple proportion, which means a higher point count always reads higher.

More from the barn

See every farm workwear guide and all barn and farm tools guides. Also see our best boot scraper brush cleaner. Also see our best boot dryer XL. Also see our best large boot dryer. Also see our best boot dryer balls. Also see our best boot dryer mat.

More related guides (17)

More picks: browse barn and farm tools, farm workwear and boot dryer mats.