Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Drain Plug vs Floating Deicer: Which One Should You Buy?

Drain plug or floating deicer? Compare hidden bottom heat against drop-in surface models for permanent tanks and portable setups.

Drain Plug vs Floating Deicer: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1API Stock Tank Water Deicer Universal Drain Plug De-IcerAPI Stock Tank Water Deicer Universal Drain Plug De-IcerView on Amazon
  2. 2Farm Innovators DPH-15 Drain Plug De-Icer for Rubbermaid TanksFarm Innovators DPH-15 Drain Plug De-Icer for Rubbermaid TanksView on Amazon
  3. 3Stock Tank Drain Plug Fit for rubbermaid Commercial 50 70 100Stock Tank Drain Plug Fit for rubbermaid Commercial 50 70 100View on Amazon

Drain plug vs floating deicer is a placement question: a drain plug deicer replaces the tank’s drain plug and heats from the bottom, while a floating deicer rides on the surface and keeps the top open. Drain plug models hide the element where stock cannot reach it; floating models are easier to install and move. Pick the drain plug for permanent tanks and rough stock; pick floating for portability.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Drain plug vs floating deicer: the short answer

A drain plug deicer screws into the tank’s drain opening, usually a standard size like the 1-1/2 inch rubber stopper in the reference listings, and heats the water from the bottom where it is out of reach. A floating deicer sits on the surface and melts the ice from the top. Drain plug models suit permanent tanks; floating models suit tanks you drain and move. Our cast aluminum vs plastic tank deicer guide compares body materials.

What a drain plug deicer does

A drain plug deicer replaces the plug: the element lives at the bottom of the tank, stock cannot chew it, and the cord exits through the drain. The reference listings name drain stoppers from 1-1/2 inch rubber to 6 inch silicone and 3 3/8 inch, 8.57 cm stainless steel: match the deicer to your tank’s drain size. Installation takes one draining; after that it stays put. Our best stock tank for winter guide lists deicers.

What a floating deicer does

A floating deicer drops onto the surface and keeps an open hole in the ice. No installation: drop it in, plug it in, pull it out in spring. It is visible to stock, so curious goats may nose it, and the cord runs over the tank edge. It suits rented barns, borrowed tanks and anyone who moves water around. Our heated bucket vs tank deicer guide covers small setups.

Which deicer for your tank

Choose a drain plug deicer for a permanent tank with rough stock: the element hides at the bottom and the cord exits through the drain. Choose a floating deicer for portability and zero installation: drop in and go. Match the drain plug size to the tank: the listings run from 1-1/2 inch to 6 inches, with 3 3/8 inch, 8.57 cm stainless models in between. For budget picks, our best water trough heater guide lists them.

Feature Drain plug deicer Floating deicer
Placement In the drain, at the bottom On the surface
Drain sizes in the listings 1-1/2 to 6 inch Not applicable
Installation Drain the tank once Drop in
Stock access Hidden from stock Visible, may be nosed
Best for Permanent tanks Portability

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers placement choice only, not wiring or electrical safety. All electric deicers need proper outdoor-rated power. For the main heater guide, our best water trough heater lists options.

FAQs from goat keepers

What size drain plug deicer do I need?

Match it to the tank drain: the listings name 1-1/2 inch rubber, 3 3/8 inch, 8.57 cm stainless and 6 inch silicone stoppers.

Is a drain plug or floating deicer better for goats?

Drain plug for rough stock: the element hides at the bottom. Floating for portability and easy install.

Can I move a drain plug deicer between tanks?

Only by draining and unscrewing it; floating deicers move with a lift.

Do floating deicers keep the whole tank open?

No: they keep a drinking hole open at the surface, which is what stock needs.

Buying advice: sizes, cords and winter habits

Measure the drain first

Drain plug deicers only fit the drain they are made for. The listings name 1-1/2 inch rubber stoppers, 3 3/8 inch, 8.57 cm stainless steel stoppers and 6 inch silicone stoppers: measure your tank’s drain opening before buying, because a deicer that does not seat will leak.

Plan the cord

Drain plug deicers route the cord through the drain, so it stays out of reach and out of the ice. Floating deicers drape the cord over the tank edge, where goats can nose it: route it high and check it through the season.

Think about draining

A drain plug deicer complicates draining: you must unplug and unscrew it before pulling the plug. If you drain the tank often for cleaning, a floating deicer lifts out in seconds.

Match the deicer to the herd

Curious goats mouth everything new. A hidden drain plug element survives nosing and chewing better than a floating unit on the surface. For calm herds, either works; for kids and horned goats, hidden wins.

More from the barn

See every goat feeding guide and our cast aluminum vs stainless steel deicer.

More picks: best water trough heater and heated bucket vs tank deicer.