
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Rubbermaid Commercial Products 50-Gallon Stock Tank9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Little Giant Trough-O-Matic Stock Tank Float Valve9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Rubbermaid Commercial Products Stock Tank Float Valve9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Farm Innovators H-418 Ice Chaser Floating Tank De-IcerView on Amazon - 5
API Floating Water Tank Deicer Floating De-Icer with GuardView on Amazon - 6
Dreyoo Floating Pond HeaterView on Amazon - 7
Farm Innovators H-4815 Economical Floating Metal Stock TankView on Amazon - 8
Api Floating Tank De-Icer 1500 WattView on Amazon - 9
Farm Innovators Economical 1000 Watt Floating Tank De-IcerView on Amazon
A floating deicer rides on the surface and keeps a drinking hole open; a submersible deicer sinks to the bottom and heats the whole tank. That is the core of floating vs submersible tank deicer: floating is easy to install and move, while submersible hides from curious goats and heats more evenly. For rough stock, submersible wins; for portability, floating wins.
Also worth comparing
Farm Innovators H-418 Ice Chaser Floating Tank De-IcerCheck price on Amazon
API Floating Water Tank Deicer Floating De-Icer with GuardCheck price on Amazon
Dreyoo Floating Pond HeaterCheck price on Amazon
Farm Innovators H-4815 Economical Floating Metal Stock TankCheck price on Amazon
Api Floating Tank De-Icer 1500 WattCheck price on Amazon
Farm Innovators Economical 1000 Watt Floating Tank De-IcerCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Floating vs submersible tank deicer: the short answer
Buy a floating deicer for easy install and portability: the listings show 250W to 1500W floating units, including a Farm Innovators 1250W cast aluminum float at 7.5 inches and K&H units at 250W and 1500W. Buy a submersible for goat safety and even heating: the listings note convertible units that switch from floating to submersible in seconds. Some units do both, which is the best of both worlds.
How a floating deicer works
A floating deicer sits on the water surface and heats the top layer, keeping a drinking hole open through ice. The listings show the range: Farm Innovators 1250W with a 7.5-inch cast aluminum float, K&H 250W and 1500W pond heaters, API 1500W and 1000W floating de-icers, and a K&H 1000W stock tank deicer. The TURBRO listing adds a 32.8 ft cord. Floating units drop in with no installation: place them on the water and plug in. They are easy to move between tanks and easy to check.
How a submersible deicer works
A submersible deicer sinks to the tank bottom and heats from below, keeping the whole tank ice-free rather than just a surface hole. The listings describe convertible units: one K&H listing says the floating deicer converts to submersible in seconds, and another notes use as a floating stock tank deicer or submersible tank heater with a protective cage and cord clip. Submersible placement hides the element from goats, which matters because goats mouth everything new.
Wattage and tank size
Wattage decides how much ice a deicer fights. The listings show 250W (K&H, small ponds), 1000W (API, K&H stock tank), 1250W (Farm Innovators) and 1500W (K&H, API). Higher wattage suits larger tanks and colder climates. A 250W unit suits a small tank in mild cold; 1000W to 1500W suits stock tanks in hard winter. Match wattage to tank size and climate, not just price.
Goat safety
Goats are the deciding factor. A floating deicer sits where goats drink: they can nose it, chew the cord and push it aside. The listings note protective cages and cord clips on some units, which help. A submersible deicer hides at the bottom, out of reach and out of sight. For kids and horned goats that mouth everything, submersible is safer. For calm herds, a caged floating unit works.
Installation and moving
Floating deicers win on convenience: drop in, plug in, done. They lift out in seconds for cleaning or moving between tanks. Submersible units need placement at the bottom and cord routing, but convertible units switch in seconds per the listings. If you move deicers between tanks often, floating or convertible is the practical choice.
Which one should you buy
Buy floating for portability and easy install: the 1000W to 1500W listings cover stock tanks. Buy submersible or convertible for goat safety: hidden elements survive curious stock. The convertible units that do both are the smart buy for most goat keepers.
| Feature | Floating deicer | Submersible deicer |
|---|---|---|
| Placement | Surface | Tank bottom |
| Listed wattage | 250W to 1500W | Convertible units listed |
| Heats | Surface hole | Whole tank |
| Goat access | Visible, may be nosed | Hidden |
| Install | Drop in | Place at bottom |
| Best for | Portability | Rough stock |
Buying advice: wattage, cords and winter habits
Size the wattage to the tank
The listings span 250W to 1500W. A 250W unit suits a small tank or mild cold; it will not hold a large stock tank open in a hard freeze. The 1000W K&H and API units suit standard stock tanks. The 1250W Farm Innovators and 1500W K&H and API units suit large tanks and the coldest climates. When in doubt, go up a size: an underpowered deicer runs constantly and still loses.
Check the cord length
The TURBRO listing gives a 32.8 ft cord, which reaches distant outlets. Short cords need extension cords rated for outdoor use, which adds a failure point. Measure from tank to outlet before buying.
Plan for the coldest nights
Deicers work hardest on windy nights when the wind strips heat from the surface. A floating deicer fights the wind directly; a submersible heats from below where wind matters less. In exposed locations, submersible has the edge. Break ice manually on the worst nights regardless of type.
Think about cleaning
Tanks need periodic draining and scrubbing. A floating deicer lifts out in seconds. A submersible must be unplugged and lifted from the bottom, which is harder in a full tank. Convertible units that switch types give flexibility for cleaning day.
FAQs from goat keepers
What wattage deicer for a stock tank?
The listings show 1000W to 1500W for stock tanks; 250W suits small tanks in mild cold.
Can a deicer be both floating and submersible?
Yes: the listings describe convertible units that switch in seconds, some with protective cages.
Will goats chew a floating deicer?
They may nose it. Caged units and cord clips help; submersible hides the element entirely.
Do I need a deicer all winter?
When temperatures stay below freezing, yes: goats need open water daily.
More from the barn
See our best water trough heater and the heated bucket vs heated base guide. See every goat feeding guide.
More picks: best water trough heater and heated bucket vs heated base.
