
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
BARsics Large 6-Gallon Galvanized Tin Beverage Tub9.3/10View on Amazon - 2
htskwa 304 Stainless Stock Tank Drain Plug Kit9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Sxmprail Stock Tank Drain Plug Kit with 1-1/4 x 3/4 Reducer9.5/10View on Amazon - 4
Behlen Country RE328 294-Gallon Galvanized Round-End TankView on Amazon - 5
Little Giant® Galvanized Steel Automatic Stock WatererView on Amazon
A frozen bucket at morning chores tells you the water setup needs a rethink, and galvanized vs plastic stock tank is the question of which material holds water best through the seasons. This guide compares the two by durability, cleaning and algae, what the galvanized listings state about sizes and coatings, and the contradictions to watch for in the listings. Every number below comes from an Amazon listing we read for this guide.
Also worth comparing
Behlen Country RE328 294-Gallon Galvanized Round-End TankCheck price on Amazon
Little Giant® Galvanized Steel Automatic Stock WatererCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Galvanized vs plastic stock tank: the short answer
Galvanized steel suits a permanent trough that stays put for years, while plastic suits a tank you move, dump and scrub often. Galvanized tubs carry a zinc coating the makers call rust resistant, and they are heavy enough that a goat cannot shove them around. Plastic tanks are lighter and will not dent, but they can crack in hard cold and may need replacing sooner. Pick galvanized for durability in one spot, plastic for light weight and easy handling.
If you would rather go straight to the products, our steel vs poly water trough comparison lines up the two materials with specific listings.
Sizes the listings state
Galvanized tub listings state capacities from 4 gallons to 16 gallons in this data set. The Behrens 16 gallon round tub measures 31 in long, 16.5 in wide and 10.5 in high at 6.8 lb, with wire handles and an offset bottom that raises it off the ground. The Behrens 4 gallon oval tub measures 11 by 8.5 by 5.5 in at 2.4 lb. Stock tank covers hint at the bigger end of the range: the Polar Protector cover fits a 2 by 2 by 6 ft galvanized tank of 170 gallons, and Gecic covers fit 4 ft oval tanks of 100 gallons (49 by 28 by 8 in) and 8 ft oval tanks of 300 gallons (97 by 37 by 12 in).
| Listing | Stated capacity | Stated size |
|---|---|---|
| Behrens 16 gallon tub | 16 gallons | 31 x 16.5 x 10.5 in, 6.8 lb |
| Behrens 10.5 gallon tub | 10.5 gallons | 28 x 16 x 10 in in spec table |
| Behrens 15 gallon tub | 15 gal title, 12 gallon spec table | 21 x 21 x 11 in in bullets |
| Behrens 4 gallon tub | 4 gallons | 11 x 8.5 x 5.5 in, 2.4 lb |
| Polar Protector cover | Fits 170 gallon tank | 2 x 2 x 6 ft |
| Gecic 4 ft cover | Fits 100 gallon tank | 49 x 28 x 8 in |
| Gecic 8 ft cover | Fits 300 gallon tank | 97 x 37 x 12 in |
Durability: zinc coating against the weather
The galvanized listings lean on the zinc coating. The Behrens 4 gallon tub describes hot dipped galvanized steel with a zinc coating that provides a watertight seal, and calls it rust resistant with an offset bottom that keeps the tub off the ground. The Behrens 15 gallon tub lists rust, fire and heat resistance and says it will not crack or fade. The Behrens 16 gallon tub describes weather-resistant, water-tight construction and calls it rodent-proof, which is the maker’s claim, reported as stated. No plastic tank listing was in this guide’s data, so plastic figures are not stated here; in general, plastic will not rust or dent, but it can crack in hard cold and sun-weathered plastic turns brittle with age.
Algae and cleaning
Algae grows where light, warmth and nutrients meet, and the material changes how you fight it. Galvanized tubs with an offset bottom, like the Behrens 16 gallon and 4 gallon tubs, sit off the ground so the underside dries, and a cover such as the Polar Protector or Gecic covers blocks light and debris. Smooth plastic scrubs clean faster than a rough or pitted surface, whichever material you choose. Covers also cut evaporation and keep leaves and droppings out: the Gecic listings describe waterproof, tear-resistant covers with drawstrings for 100 and 300 gallon tanks.
Weight and moving
Weight is the practical split. The Behrens 16 gallon tub lists 6.8 lb empty, and a full tank of water weighs far more, so a big galvanized tank is a two-person move or a permanent placement. Plastic tanks are lighter to dump, drag and flip for scrubbing, which matters if you clean often. If the tank will never move, galvanized wins on staying put; if you rotate pastures, plastic wins on handling.
Read the listing twice
Stock tank listings contradict themselves, and the conflicts sit in capacity and dimensions:
- Behrens 15 gallon tub: the title says 15 Gal while the spec table says a 12 gallon capacity, and the bullets say 21 by 21 by 11 in while the spec table says 19.2 by 19.2 by 11.2 in.
- Behrens 10.5 gallon tub: the bullets say 24 by 18 by 8 in while the spec table says 28 by 16 by 10 in.
- Behrens 16 gallon tub: the spec table lists the material type as Plastic while the title and bullets describe galvanized steel, so trust the title and bullets over the spec table.
Allow for the smaller capacity when the two conflict, and measure the spot where the tank will sit before ordering.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers tank hardware only. It does not cover water quality, treatments or any animal health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about water and goat health.
FAQs from goat keepers
Which lasts longer, galvanized or plastic?
The galvanized listings claim rust resistance, weather resistance and a zinc coating, with the Behrens 15 gallon tub stating it will not crack or fade. No plastic tank listing was in this guide’s data, so compare material claims across listings before deciding.
Do stock tanks need a cover?
A cover blocks light and debris, which helps with algae and cleaning. The Polar Protector cover fits a 2 by 2 by 6 ft, 170 gallon galvanized tank, and Gecic covers fit 100 and 300 gallon oval tanks.
What sizes do galvanized tubs come in?
The listings we read state 4 gallons, 10.5 gallons, 15 gallons and 16 gallons, with covers sized for 100, 170 and 300 gallon tanks.
Are galvanized tubs heavy?
The Behrens 16 gallon tub lists 6.8 lb empty and the 4 gallon tub lists 2.4 lb, before water is added. Plan placement accordingly, since a full tank is far heavier.
More from the barn
See every water trough guide and all feeding and water guides.
More picks: steel vs poly water trough, automatic waterers for small herds, water trough heaters and waterer vs bucket.
