
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Wall Mount Hay Rack 16 Gallon 27'' Long Livestock Hay Feeder9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Pasture Hay Feeder 45 Gallon for Farms Hay Grain Livestock9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
BUYYAH 2Pcs Goat Hay Feeder9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
Goat Hay FeederView on Amazon - 5
T TEKE Classic Slow Hay Feeder Hay NetsView on Amazon - 6
T TEKE 2 pcs Classic Slow Hay Feeder Hay NetsView on Amazon - 7
BUYYAH Livestock Hay Feeder 60 GallonView on Amazon - 8
T TEKE Deluxe Slow Hay Feeder Hay NetsView on Amazon - 9
Hay Feeder for GoatsView on Amazon
Morning chores start with hay scattered across the bedding and goats shouting at an empty rack, which is why goat feeder vs hay feeder is worth sorting out before you buy. The direct answer is simple: a hay feeder is a goat feeder built for hay, while a general goat feeder can cover grain and pellets too, so for a herd fed mainly on hay, choose a hay feeder, and for a station that must hold grain as well, choose a 2-in-1 design with a tray. The listings below are all hay feeders, and 2 of them add a grain tray, so this guide compares the two feeder types on stated capacity, mounting, materials and listing contradictions.
Also worth comparing
Goat Hay FeederCheck price on Amazon
T TEKE Classic Slow Hay Feeder Hay NetsCheck price on Amazon
T TEKE 2 pcs Classic Slow Hay Feeder Hay NetsCheck price on Amazon
BUYYAH Livestock Hay Feeder 60 GallonCheck price on Amazon
T TEKE Deluxe Slow Hay Feeder Hay NetsCheck price on Amazon
Hay Feeder for GoatsCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
What goat feeder vs hay feeder really means
A goat feeder is the general term for any feeder a goat eats from, while a hay feeder is the narrower type: a rack, bin or trough shaped to hold hay and keep it off the ground. A general feeder may hold grain, pellets or hay, but a hay feeder is built around long forage, with bars, openings or a rack that goats pull hay through. That distinction matters at feeding time: hay dropped on the ground gets trampled and refused, while hay held in a rack stays clean.
If you would rather go straight to scored products, our best hay feeder for goats roundup scores hay feeders on the same points covered here.
The gear: hay feeders compared
The 4 listings below are all hay feeders, ranked from the strongest overall listing to the thinnest: the BUYYAH rack on a stated warranty and a 2 pack, the FULUPET feeder on capacity, the Texfield station on its grain trough despite unstated capacity and weight, and the UNCOJOY rack, the smallest, with no warranty stated.
| Feeder | Stated capacity | Mounting | Material |
|---|---|---|---|
| BUYYAH wall mount hay rack, 2 pack | 25 gallons | Wall mount | Carbon steel |
| FULUPET pasture hay feeder | 70 gallons | Freestanding | Galvanized steel |
| Texfield hay feeder with grain trough | Not stated | Not stated | Galvanized steel |
| UNCOJOY wall hay rack | 18 gallons | Wall mount | Solid round steel |
BUYYAH wall mount hay rack, 2 pack
The BUYYAH listing states a 40 x 8 x 15.7 inch rack in carbon steel, sold as a 2 pack, with a stated capacity of 25 gallons and a weight of 22.39 pounds. The maker lists a wall-mounted design that saves pen floor space, multiple sides, and large openings for unhindered eating, and says 5 goats can eat at the same time. Tools are offered for installation, the maker calls the rack rust-proof and BPA-free, and the warranty description states 2 Year Manufacturer. One gap to note: the listing does not make clear whether the 25 gallons covers one rack or the pair, so read the capacity line against your pen before ordering.
FULUPET pasture hay feeder
The FULUPET listing states a freestanding pasture feeder in galvanized steel, with a 70 gallon total, a 45 gallon feeder top rack and a 25 gallon feed pan below, plus a bottom grain tray that catches falling forage. The bullets give dimensions of 44 x 23 x 36 inches and a weight of 44.1 lbs, while the spec table gives 36.0 x 23.0 x 44.0 inches and 44.0 pounds, so trust the bullets and title over the spec table when planning the footprint. The maker lists full-welded bars, smooth corners, an open top that takes a standard tarp, pre-drilled holes with hardware, and a quick 10-minute setup, and says to place the feeder on flat ground. No concrete warranty term is stated, only long-term customer support.
Texfield hay feeder with grain trough
The Texfield listing states a 2-in-1 feeding station in galvanized steel, with an upper hay rack and a lower trough for grain or pellets in one location. The spec table gives dimensions of 47.04 x 11.69 x 26.8 inches, and the open design lets you check the remaining forage and refill as needed. The maker lists assembly required, and says to check all connections before use and to inspect the frame, edges and fasteners regularly. The listing leaves capacity and weight unstated, so it is hard to rank against the gallon figures of the other feeders, and mounting is not stated either.
UNCOJOY wall hay rack
The UNCOJOY listing states a wall hay rack in solid round steel with a black paint coating, with a stated capacity of 18 gallons and dimensions of 23.6 x 12.6 x 18.9 inches. The bullets give a weight of 9.03 pounds while the spec table gives 9.04 pounds, a small difference to note when comparing listings. The maker lists a large top opening for easy filling, an edge arc design, and a wall-mounted structure, and says the rack can be installed indoors or outdoors on wooden grids, red brick walls and concrete walls. Assembly uses four components with an instruction manual inside the box, and the warranty description states No warranty.
Reading capacity against your herd
Capacity on these listings is given in gallons of space, not in pounds of hay, and makers measure it differently. The BUYYAH rack lists 25 gallons, the FULUPET feeder lists 70 gallons with a 45 gallon rack and a 25 gallon pan, and the UNCOJOY rack lists 18 gallons, while the Texfield station states no capacity at all. None of these listings converts gallons into a weight of hay, so treat gallons as a way to rank feeders against each other, not as a daily ration.
Some listings also state how many animals can eat at once. The BUYYAH listing says 5 goats can eat at the same time, thanks to its multiple sides and large openings. The other listings state no head count, so for a larger group, 2 racks in separate pens often work better than one rack shared by everyone.
Mounting and where the feeder goes
Mounting decides how stable the feeder is and how easy it is to fill. Wall racks need anchors into something solid: the BUYYAH rack mounts to a wall with tools offered for installation, and the UNCOJOY rack mounts on wooden grids, red brick walls and concrete walls, indoors or outdoors. The FULUPET feeder is freestanding, so it needs flat ground and room for goats to reach from more than one side, and the maker says to place it on flat ground for balance. The Texfield station states no mounting, so check the listing for mounting details before choosing a spot for it.
Think about filling too: a rack by the barn door is easier to refill than one in the back corner, and a wide top opening, which the UNCOJOY listing mentions, makes it easier to drop a flake in from above.
Materials: carbon steel, galvanized steel and coated steel
Material sets how long a feeder lasts outdoors. The listings we compared use these materials:
- Carbon steel: the BUYYAH rack, described as rust-proof by the maker, and BPA-free.
- Galvanized steel: the FULUPET pasture feeder and the Texfield station.
- Solid round steel with black paint: the UNCOJOY rack, which the maker says will not rust or deform even after long-term use.
Steel racks hold up to chewing and climbing better than fabric, and galvanized and coated finishes suit feeders that live outdoors or in a damp barn. The BUYYAH rack is the only one here that states a warranty term, at 2 Year Manufacturer.
Grain trays and 2-in-1 designs
Some feeders add a tray under the hay rack, which is where the goat feeder vs hay feeder line blurs in a useful way. The FULUPET feeder pairs a 45 gallon rack with a 25 gallon feed pan and says the tray catches falling forage to prevent messy trampling. The Texfield station pairs its upper hay rack with a lower trough for grain or pellets, keeping hay and grain in one location. A tray also catches some of the hay goats pull out, though none of these listings measures how much. If you feed grain at a separate time and place, a plain rack without a tray is simpler to clean.
Read the listing twice
Hay feeder listings often contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan the install:
- FULUPET: 44 x 23 x 36 inches in the bullets against 36.0 x 23.0 x 44.0 inches in the spec table, and 44.1 lbs in the bullets against 44.0 pounds in the spec table.
- UNCOJOY: 9.03 pounds in the bullets against 9.04 pounds in the spec table.
- BUYYAH: 25 gallons stated without making clear whether the figure covers one rack or the 2 pack, and a size line reading 25INCH(2PCS) that adds to the confusion.
- Texfield: no capacity and no weight stated at all, so the listing cannot be ranked on gallons against the other feeders.
Measure your wall or pen before ordering and allow for the larger figure. Some listings also make health claims about feeding; we leave those out, because a feeder is equipment, not a health product.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers feeder hardware only. It does not cover how much hay a goat needs, hay types or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.
FAQs from goat keepers
What is the difference between a goat feeder and a hay feeder?
A goat feeder is the general term for any feeder a goat eats from, while a hay feeder is built to hold hay and keep it off the ground. The listings here are all hay feeders, and 2 of them add a grain tray, so they cover both jobs at one station.
Can a hay feeder hold grain too?
Only the 2-in-1 designs here do that by design. The FULUPET feeder pairs a 45 gallon rack with a 25 gallon feed pan, and the Texfield station pairs an upper hay rack with a lower trough for grain or pellets.
How big should a goat hay feeder be?
Listings state capacity in gallons, from 18 gallons on the UNCOJOY rack to 70 gallons on the FULUPET feeder. None converts gallons to pounds of hay, so compare gallons between feeders and leave room at the rack for every goat in the pen.
Do wall hay racks need mounting hardware?
Some do. The BUYYAH listing says tools are offered for installation, the FULUPET feeder comes with pre-drilled holes and hardware, and the UNCOJOY rack mounts on wooden grids, red brick walls and concrete walls. Freestanding feeders such as the FULUPET need no wall mount.
More from the barn
See every hay feeder guide and all feeding and water guides.
More picks: best hay feeders for goats, goat mineral feeders, heated water buckets and goat shelters.
