
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Best OverallBUYYAH 16 Gallon Hay Rack9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Best Pasture FeederOxphanor Pasture Hay Feeder9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
Best High CapacityLazaluking 67 Gallon Hay Rack9.5/10View on Amazon - 4
Best Compact Wall RackVEVOR 18.5 Gallon Hay Rack9.5/10View on Amazon - 5
Best Hanging ToteINKNOTE Hanging Hay Bag9.3/10View on Amazon
Anyone who feeds goats knows how quickly clean hay ends up trampled into barn bedding, which is why choosing the best hay feeder for goats comes down to waste reduction and durable hardware. We compared five hay feeders by forage capacity, mounting style, frame construction, safety features and stated warranty terms, using only manufacturer specifications from published listings. Our comparison evaluates heavy steel wall racks, a freestanding pasture bunk with a grain catch pan, and a portable hanging feed tote to suit herds of different sizes.
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick picks
Best Overall BUYYAH 16 Gallon Hay Rack: 16-gallon carbon steel wall rack with BPA-free build and 2-year warranty Check price on Amazon
Best Pasture Feeder Oxphanor Pasture Hay Feeder: 45-gallon forage rack with 24-gallon grain catch pan in galvanized steel Check price on Amazon
Best High Capacity Lazaluking 67 Gallon Hay Rack: 67-gallon capacity wall-mounted steel rack with 1-year warranty coverage Check price on Amazon
Best Compact Wall Rack VEVOR 18.5 Gallon Hay Rack: 18.5-gallon cold-rolled steel rack with rounded livestock-safe corners Check price on Amazon
Best Hanging Tote INKNOTE Hanging Hay Bag: Oxford cloth slow-feed bag with breathable mesh and adjustable strap Check price on Amazon
The gear we picked
| # | Product | GoatGear Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | BUYYAH 16 Gallon Hay Rack | 9.7/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | Oxphanor Pasture Hay Feeder | 9.7/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Lazaluking 67 Gallon Hay Rack | 9.5/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 | VEVOR 18.5 Gallon Hay Rack | 9.5/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 | INKNOTE Hanging Hay Bag | 9.3/10 | Buy on Amazon |

BUYYAH 16 Gallon Hay Rack
A 16-gallon carbon steel wall-mounted hay rack rated for up to 5 goats with included installation tools.
Pros
- 16 gallon capacity stated for all-day feeding
- Constructed of durable rust-proof carbon steel
- Listed as BPA-free for livestock safety
- 2-year manufacturer warranty stated
Cons
- Wall mounting requires solid wall or post anchoring
- No lower catch pan to catch loose dropped hay
- Weighs 8 pounds before adding hay

Oxphanor Pasture Hay Feeder
A freestanding pasture feeder pairing a 45-gallon top forage rack with a 24-gallon lower feed pan in powder-coated galvanized steel.
Pros
- Dual compartments with 45 gallon hay rack and 24 gallon feed pan
- Built from robust galvanized steel with black powder coating
- Bottom pan catches dropped forage and keeps feed off the ground
- Freestanding design allows pasture placement without wall mounting
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- Large footprint measuring 23.6 by 43.7 by 35.8 inches requires ample pen space
- Requires open ground space rather than compact wall attachment
- Item weight is not stated in the listing

Lazaluking 67 Gallon Hay Rack
A 67-gallon wall-mounted iron hay rack with an arc bottom design and stated 1-year warranty coverage.
Pros
- 67 gallon capacity is the largest wall-mounted volume listed
- Stated BPA-free steel frame construction
- Arc bottom design increases holding capacity
- 1-year warranty description stated
Cons
- Listing suggests alternative non-agricultural use as a blanket holder
- Weighs 7.27 pounds with relatively lightweight iron construction for its 67-gallon size
- Wall mounting requires sturdy wall or fence support

VEVOR 18.5 Gallon Hay Rack
An 18.5-gallon cold-rolled steel wall rack with powder coating and rounded edges for livestock safety.
Pros
- 18.5 gallon capacity provides all-day forage storage
- Cold-rolled steel with full welding and powder coating
- Smooth rounded corners and edges to avoid livestock scrapes
- Includes instructions and expansion screws for wall installation
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- Lightweight 4.4 pound build compared to other steel racks

INKNOTE Hanging Hay Bag
An Oxford fabric hanging hay tote with breathable nylon mesh sides, adjustable webbing straps, and a 7.9-inch feeding hole.
Pros
- Breathable nylon mesh ventilation gusset helps keep hay dry
- Adjustable webbing strap and metal ring clip for versatile hanging
- 7.9-inch grass outlet hole slows feeding to reduce wasted hay
- Lightweight 10.55-ounce design packs easily for travel and trailering
Cons
- Oxford fabric is more vulnerable to chewing than steel racks
- Holds less hay than rigid 16 to 67 gallon steel feeders
- Care instructions specify manual washing only rather than quick hosing off
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Also worth comparing
T TEKE 2 pcs Classic Slow Hay Feeder Hay NetsCheck price on Amazon
T TEKE Classic Slow Hay Feeder Hay NetsCheck price on Amazon
More picks to compare
Goatzy 25 Gallon Wall Mount Hay RackSuits goat and sheep keepers who want a covered, wall-mounted hay rack.Check on Amazon
VEVOR 80-Gallon Livestock Hay FeederSuits pens and pastures where 10 to 12 goats feed at once.Check on Amazon
Topyznsup 27-Inch Wall Mount Hay RackKeepers with several goats who want a wall-mounted 16-gallon rack, indoors or outdoors.Check on Amazon
Spec comparison
| Feeder | GoatGear Score | Capacity | Mount Type | Material | Warranty | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BUYYAH 16 Gallon Hay Rack | 9.7/10 | 16 gal | Wall mount | Carbon steel | 2-year manufacturer | View on Amazon |
| Oxphanor Pasture Hay Feeder | 9.7/10 | 45 gal rack + 24 gal pan | Freestanding | Galvanized steel | Not stated | View on Amazon |
| Lazaluking 67 Gallon Hay Rack | 9.5/10 | 67 gal | Wall mount | Iron / steel | 1-year | View on Amazon |
| VEVOR 18.5 Gallon Hay Rack | 9.5/10 | 18.5 gal | Wall mount | Cold-rolled steel | Not stated | View on Amazon |
| INKNOTE Hanging Hay Bag | 9.3/10 | 19.7 x 17.7 x 6 in | Hanging strap | Oxford fabric | Not stated | View on Amazon |
Every spec repeats the brand’s rating from its listing (collected on 15 October 2026).
How to choose the best hay feeder for goats
Feeder capacity and herd sizing
Forage capacity determines how often you must haul flakes to the barn. Listed volumes here range from a compact 16 gallons on the BUYYAH rack to 67 gallons on the Lazaluking iron rack, while the Oxphanor pasture feeder provides 45 gallons of hay space above a 24-gallon trough. Small wall racks like the BUYYAH and VEVOR (18.5 gallons) state room for up to 5 animals feeding at once. If you run a larger group or want once-a-day feeding, higher volume helps prevent crowding around the rack.
Wall racks versus freestanding pasture bunks
Mounting location dictates which feeder style keeps forage cleanest. Wall-mounted racks like the BUYYAH, VEVOR, and Lazaluking bolt directly to stall studs or fence rails, lifting forage off muddy barn floors to reduce waste. For open paddocks where no barn wall exists, a freestanding unit like the Oxphanor combines a hay rack with a wide lower pan. In turnout areas without a permanent shelter, pair outdoor feeding stations with sturdy goat shelters so animals can escape wind and wet weather while eating.
Materials and construction compared
Goats will lean, climb, and rub against feed racks, making material strength a critical consideration. Rigid metal feeders like the carbon steel BUYYAH (8 pounds), cold-rolled steel VEVOR (4.4 pounds), and galvanized steel Oxphanor withstand vigorous head-butting without sagging. By contrast, the INKNOTE hanging bag uses Oxford cloth and nylon mesh, weighing only 10.55 ounces; it packs easily for travel but lacks the rigid permanence of steel.
| Feeder | Mounting | Capacity | Material |
|---|---|---|---|
| BUYYAH 16 Gallon | Wall mount | 16 gal | Carbon steel |
| Oxphanor Pasture | Freestanding | 45 gal rack + 24 gal pan | Galvanized steel |
| Lazaluking 67 Gallon | Wall mount | 67 gal | Iron / steel |
| VEVOR 18.5 Gallon | Wall mount | 18.5 gal | Cold-rolled steel |
| INKNOTE Hanging Bag | Hanging strap | 19.7 x 17.7 x 6 in | Oxford cloth |
Reducing hay waste and barn chores
Waste control is the primary reason to install an elevated feeder. Open slats on metal racks and the 7.9-inch opening on the INKNOTE tote bag slow feeding so goats take smaller mouthfuls rather than pulling entire flakes into the bedding. The Oxphanor feeder uses a 24-gallon bottom pan to catch dropped stems before they reach the ground. Near your feeding area, set up dedicated goat mineral feeders to offer free-choice minerals separate from bulk forage, and install heated water buckets to keep winter drinking water flowing.
Around the Barn
- Anchor wall-mounted racks to solid wooden studs or fence posts using the included expansion screws or hardware.
- Position wall racks at a comfortable shoulder height so goats can reach forage without climbing onto the frame.
- Clean out leftover stems and chaff from catch pans and bottom slats daily to keep fresh forage palatable.
- Inspect fabric hanging straps and metal ring clips regularly for signs of wear or loose stitching.
FAQs from goat keepers
How much hay capacity do wall-mounted feeders provide?
Wall-mounted racks in this comparison range from 16 gallons on the BUYYAH feeder to 67 gallons on the Lazaluking iron rack, with VEVOR offering an intermediate 18.5-gallon capacity. Choose larger capacities if you want to refill forage once per day rather than multiple times.
Can a hay feeder also hold grain?
The Oxphanor pasture feeder includes a 24-gallon bottom feed pan beneath its 45-gallon forage rack, keeping grain and forage in separate compartments. Standard wall-mounted wire racks hold hay only and require separate troughs for grain.
Which hay feeders include a stated warranty?
Two feeders state a concrete warranty in their listings: BUYYAH states a 2-year manufacturer warranty and Lazaluking lists a 1-year warranty. The remaining listings do not state a concrete warranty term.
Are steel hay feeders safe for goats?
The listings specify several safety features: BUYYAH and Lazaluking list BPA-free steel construction, and VEVOR features rounded edges and corners designed to prevent livestock scrapes during feeding.
Is a hanging hay bag durable enough for goats?
The INKNOTE hanging bag uses Oxford fabric with breathable nylon mesh ventilation sides and tight stitching, weighing 10.55 ounces. It works well for travel, trailers, and temporary stalls, though rigid steel racks offer longer durability against aggressive chewers.
Behind the Farm Score
The GoatGear Score weighs performance (capacity, feeding openings and waste control), build materials, value, safety and warranty. For hay feeders, safety means smooth or rounded corners that prevent scrapes, BPA-free surfaces, and firm wall mounting that keeps heavy racks stable during eager feeding. Two of the five listings state a concrete warranty term. How we pick explains the weights.
| Product | GoatGear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BUYYAH 16 Gallon Hay Rack | 9.7 | 30 | 22 | 21 | 8 | 4 |
| Oxphanor Pasture Hay Feeder | 9.7 | 33 | 22 | 21 | 7 | 0 |
| Lazaluking 67 Gallon Hay Rack | 9.5 | 28 | 19 | 20 | 6 | 2 |
| VEVOR 18.5 Gallon Hay Rack | 9.5 | 27 | 19 | 20 | 6 | 0 |
| INKNOTE Hanging Hay Bag | 9.3 | 23 | 18 | 19 | 0 | 0 |
We translate each weighted point total onto the 9.2 through 9.8 band; ranks never flip, because the conversion is linear.
More from the barn
See every hay feeder guide and all feeding and water guides. Also see our best goat shelter. Also see our best goat feeder with hay rack. Also see our best hay rack for sheep. Also see our how to choose a hay feeder for goats. Also see our milking bucket with strainer. Also see our hay feeder for field.
More related guides (180)
- milking apron with towel pockets
- mineral feeder with flap
- best heated waterer under 100
- best sheep shears under 60
- best poly wire under 30
- best poly tape under 50
- best slow feed hay net for small flakes
- best automatic waterer under 40
- best cheese press under 50
- creep feeder vs bunk feeder
- hay net vs hay rack
- ademon automatic animal drinking water bowl review
- bottle feeding vs lamb bar
- round bale vs square bale feeder
- nipple bucket vs kid bottle
- metal vs plastic goat feeder
- wall mount vs hanging hay feeder
- fastrack glass water bottle review
- best water trough float valve under 25
- behrens round galvanized steel tub review
- best stock tank under 50
- cast aluminum vs plastic tank deicer
- drain plug vs floating deicer
- floating vs submersible tank deicer
- farm innovators hb-60p review
- farm innovators hpf-100 review
- best hay feeder for baby goats
- best heated water bucket for outdoor pens
- wood vs metal hay feeder
- best nipples for goat kids
- best water trough cover for winter
- best goat water bucket for pasture
- hay feeder vs hay net
- hay rack vs hay feeder
- heated vs unheated stock tank
- stainless vs plastic water bucket
- lamb bar vs nipple bucket
- best goat water bucket for barn
- mineral feeder vs grain feeder
- best goat water bucket for kids
- silicone vs plastic kid bottles
- best goat feeder for two goats
- best hay net for two goats
- heated bucket vs automatic waterer
- best goat water bucket for hobby farms
- best automatic waterer for hobby farms
- best goat water bucket for milking does
- stainless steel vs silicone kid bottles
- best water trough heater for plastic tanks
- rubber vs plastic water bucket
- cotton vs nylon lead rope
- best goat grooming kit for travel
- brass vs plastic float valve
- bleached vs unbleached cheesecloth
- stainless steel vs glass kid bottles
- knotted vs knotless hay net
- best goat feeder for three goats
- galvanized vs plastic feed pan
- best poly wire for 5 acres
- wire fence cutters vs bolt cutters
- best goat water bucket for four goats
- feed trough vs feed pan
- best goat water bucket for large goats
- best pig feeder for weaners
- best pig waterer for weaners
- creep feeder vs hay feeder
- best stock tank de-icer for cattle
- hay ring vs hay net
- best cattle waterer for small farms
- best nipple drinkers for pigs
- best automatic waterer for milking does
- hopper vs trough pig feeder
- round hay rack
- stock tank large
- best goat hay feeder for wall
- best calf bottle carrier under 15
- best stock tank de-icer under 60
- best water tank brush under 15
- solar vs electric livestock water pump
- heated water hose thermostat
- water bucket hanger
- hay colour rack c-shape
- hay ball vs hay net for goats
- kid bottle soft spout
- water trough sensor
- feed bucket vs feed pan
- feed scoop livestock
- feed scoop pigs
- heated water hose brass fittings
- best kid nipple covers under 10
- best brush for cleaning bottles under 10
- best nipple waterer for sheep
- best automatic waterer for beginners
- best feed bucket with clip under 20
- best pig feeder for weaners under 50
- pig feeder hanging
- hay feeder tall
- hay feeder slow
- best heated water hose for stock tanks
- best water tank brush for stock tanks
- best automatic waterer for llamas
- best stock tank with lid under 100
- best hay rack for goats
- best pig waterer for hot weather
- best calf bottle funnel under 10
- best nipple waterer for sheep under 15
- best livestock solar water pump under 100
- heated water hose vs trough heater
- best heated water hose for goats
- aluminum vs stainless steel stock tank
- hay manger feeder
- best goat feeder for mixed herds
- best heated waterer for llamas
- goat feeder vs sheep feeder
- best hay bag for goats under 30
- rain barrel vs stock tank
- hanging waterer vs automatic waterer
- best goat grain feeder for small farms
- hay bale hooks
- goat feeder vs hay feeder
- best hay bale hooks under 25
- nipple waterer
- best livestock water storage tank under 100
- livestock waterer bowl
- best livestock bowl waterer under 30
- galvanized vs stainless hay feeder
- digital feed scale
- best digital feed scale under 30
- wood vs metal goat feeder
- corner hay rack vs round hay rack
- calf bucket with lid
- best livestock solar water pump for small farms
- best bale spear for large square bales
- best sheep feeder for hobby farms
- pig feeder vs sheep feeder
- stock tank vs water bucket
- bale spear vs hay bale hooks
- best tall hay feeder under 50
- water tote sizes
- what is a puzzle feeder
- feed scoop with measurements
- goat waterer ideas
- calf hutch size
- goat hay feeder ideas
- goat mineral feeder ideas
- how to adjust float valve in water tank
- cattle feed bunk dimensions
- water trough cover vs insulation wrap
- round bale feeder ideas
- water trough heater vs insulation wrap
- gravity feeder vs nipple bucket
- dimensions of hay bale
- do goats eat hay
- fly trap diy
- stock tank vs water tote
- how does a moisture meter work
- how to use a moisture meter
- how to clean bottle sterilizer
- do i need a bottle sterilizer
- goat feeder ideas
- water tank sizes and dimensions
- frost free hydrant vs hose bib
- hay tarp vs hay bale bag
- plastic vs metal stock tank
- best brush for grill cleaning
- best brushes for ceramic glaze
- best brush for metal paint
- best brush for cleaning wood deck
- best heated water hose for camper
- best hay feeder for horse stall
- slow feed hay net vs hay feeder
- best heated water hose under 100
- hay spear with pins
- best goat water bucket for winter
- best automatic waterer under 60
- best goat hay rack under 75
- float valve vs ball valve
- slow feed hay net vs hay rack
- best nipple waterer for pigs
- best stock tank for small farms
More picks: browse milking stands, hoof trimmers and fencing and shelter.
