
On this page
Kids crowd the bucket at feeding time, the water runs low before the chores are done, and gravity feeder vs nipple bucket is the choice that decides how often the bucket gets filled and how the kids drink. A gravity feeder keeps food or water flowing from a hopper with no power, while a nipple bucket lets a kid drink on demand from a nipple. This guide compares the two styles using the gravity feeder listings in the comparison, and it is frank about what those listings state and what they leave out: none of them is a nipple bucket, and none states use for goats, kids or calves.
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Gravity feeder vs nipple bucket: the short answer
A gravity feeder keeps food or water flowing from a hopper with no power, and it suits a pen where the feeder can sit flat and the keeper wants a steady supply between refills. The nipple bucket is the other style in this comparison, and this guide cannot score it: the 4 listings in the comparison are all gravity feeders, and no nipple bucket listing was in the set. The gravity listings state food capacities of 152 fl oz, 0.8 gallons, 3.3L and about 6 pound, and water capacities of 135.3 fl oz, 0.8 gallons, 3.3L and 1 gallon. The ZOMISIA and Wefeedy listings state that no electricity is required. For grain feeding, the best goat feeder for grain roundup scores grain feeders on the same points.
Two feeder styles compared
| Style | Example listing | Stated capacity | Power |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gravity feeder | Wefeedy Automatic Cat Feeder and Water Dispenser | 3.3L, food and water | Gravity, no electricity |
| Gravity feeder | Amazon Basics Automatic Pet Water Dispenser and Gravity Food Feeder Set | 152 fl oz food feeder, 135.3 fl oz water dispenser | Gravity |
| Gravity feeder | ZOMISIA Automatic Cat Feeder | 0.8 gallons, food and water | Gravity, no electricity |
| Gravity feeder | HWONMTE Automatic Cat Feeder and Water Dispenser | About 6 pound food, 1 gallon water | Gravity |
| Nipple bucket | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated |
Gravity feeders
Gravity feeders let food or water flow down from a hopper into a bowl as the animals eat or drink, and all 4 listings in this comparison use that design. The Wefeedy set lists 3.3L for food and water, food grade PP and PET with no BPA, and a siphon design for the water feeder. The Amazon Basics set pairs a 152 fl oz food feeder with a 135.3 fl oz water dispenser, lists polypropylene construction with a durable base and transparent hoppers, and lists anti-skid rubber feet and side cut-out handles on the base. The ZOMISIA set lists 0.8 gallons for food and water, a 180-degree rotating assembly so the 2 parts can sit apart or together, and hand washing in cold water only. The HWONMTE set lists about 6 pound of food and 1 gallon of water, a movable stainless steel bowl at the bottom of the feeder, and a spiral and spring valve design that the maker says never leaks. None of the 4 listings states use for goats, kids or calves: all 4 name dogs, cats or small and medium pets, so a goat keeper reading them has to judge the size and the bowl against a kid, not a cat.
Nipple buckets
A nipple bucket is a bucket with a nipple that lets a kid drink on demand, and it is the other style compared here. No nipple bucket listing was in the compared set, so this guide states no capacity, material, size or cleaning method for one. A reader shopping for a nipple bucket should look for a listing that states the bucket size, the nipple count and the material, and check the listing for a stated use with kids or calves before buying. The best calf bucket with lid roundup and the best feed trough for calves roundup cover calf buckets and troughs on the same points.
Reading capacity against your herd
Capacity on these listings is given in fluid ounces, gallons, liters and pounds of food, and the makers measure it differently, so compare like with like. The Amazon Basics set states 152 fl oz of food and 135.3 fl oz of water. The ZOMISIA set states 0.8 gallons for food and water. The Wefeedy set states 3.3L for food and water. The HWONMTE set states about 6 pound of food and 1 gallon of water. None of the 4 listings converts its capacity into a daily ration for a goat, a kid or a calf, so treat the stated capacity as a way to rank the feeders against each other, not as a daily ration.
Some listings also state how long the supply lasts for a pet. The ZOMISIA listing states about 7 days for small pets and 3 days for big pets. The Wefeedy listing states 6 days for small pets and 2 days for large pets. The HWONMTE listing states about 7-9 days for small medium pets and 3-5 days for large pets. These are maker claims about pets, not goats, and a kid drinks and eats on a different schedule from a cat or a dog, so read the day counts as a rough guide to the hopper size, not as a promise for a goat pen.
Materials and cleaning
Material sets how the feeder holds up to daily use and washing. The Amazon Basics set lists polypropylene with a durable base and transparent hoppers that show the food and water levels. The Wefeedy set lists food grade PP and PET with no BPA. The ZOMISIA listing lists natural materials and states hand washing in cold water only, with no dishwasher use. The HWONMTE set lists a movable stainless steel bowl at the bottom of the feeder and recommends hand washing, with dishwasher use only with the heating function off. The Amazon Basics listing states hand wash only. For water, the best automatic waterer for goats roundup compares waterers made for goats on the same points.
Read the listing twice
Feeder listings often contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones needed to plan the pen:
- Amazon Basics: 12.5 x 7 x 12 inches for the feeder and 12.4 x 7 x 12 inches for the waterer in the bullets, against 13.94 x 7.76 x 15.98 inches in the spec table. The title says Pack of 2, and the spec table lists NumberOfItems as 1.
- ZOMISIA: the title states 0.8Gal x 2, and the spec table states 0.8 Gallon x 2, so the capacity agrees across the listing. The spec table lists a weight of 3.7 pounds, a figure with more digits than a scale would give, so read it as a listing artifact rather than a measured weight.
- Wefeedy: the title and the bullets agree on 3.3L for food and water, and the spec table gives 5.2 x 10.6 x 10.2 inches with no weight stated.
- HWONMTE: the spec table gives 7.0 x 7.0 x 3.0 inches, a size that cannot hold 1 gallon of water, against the stated 1 gallon capacity. The spec table also lists a 2 years warranty, and the bullets state a spiral and spring valve design that the maker says never leaks.
Measure the pen and the shelf before ordering, and allow for the larger figure when a listing gives 2 sizes. The best goat water bucket for barn roundup lists barn buckets with stated sizes for the same check.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers feeder hardware only. It does not cover how much feed or water a goat needs, feed types or any health question. Ask a veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.
FAQs from goat keepers
Can a gravity feeder made for pets feed goat kids?
None of the 4 listings states use for goats, kids or calves. All 4 name dogs, cats or small and medium pets, so check the stated size and the bowl against a kid before buying, and look for a listing that states goat or kid use.
How much does a gravity feeder hold?
It depends on the listing. The Amazon Basics set states 152 fl oz of food and 135.3 fl oz of water, the ZOMISIA set states 0.8 gallons, the Wefeedy set states 3.3L, and the HWONMTE set states about 6 pound of food and 1 gallon of water.
Do gravity feeders need power?
No. All 4 listings state gravity feeding, and the ZOMISIA and Wefeedy listings state that no electricity is required.
How do you clean a gravity feeder?
Hand washing is the stated method on the Amazon Basics, ZOMISIA and HWONMTE listings: the Amazon Basics listing states hand wash only, the ZOMISIA listing states hand washing in cold water only, and the HWONMTE listing recommends hand washing. The Wefeedy listing states disassembly, cleaning with clean water, and reassembly.
What is a nipple bucket?
A nipple bucket is a bucket with a nipple that lets a kid drink on demand. No nipple bucket listing was in the compared set, so this guide states no capacity, material or size for one: look for a listing that states the bucket size, the nipple count and the material, and check for a stated use with kids or calves.
Which gravity feeder is smallest?
By stated dimensions, the Wefeedy set lists 5.2 x 10.6 x 10.2 inches, the Amazon Basics set lists 12.5 x 7 x 12 inches for the feeder, and the ZOMISIA set lists 14.1 x 11.6 x 10.9 inches. The HWONMTE spec table lists 7.0 x 7.0 x 3.0 inches, but that size conflicts with its stated 1 gallon capacity, so read it with care.
More from the barn
See every kid bottle and nipple guide and all feeding and water guides.
More picks: best hay feeders for goats, goat mineral feeders, goat grain feeders and feed troughs for calves.
