Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Heated vs Unheated Stock Tank: Which One Should You Buy?

Heated vs unheated stock tank: de-icer listings compared by wattage, type and safety, with how to choose for winter goat water.

Heated vs Unheated Stock Tank: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Wufoty 25FT Heated Water HoseWufoty 25FT Heated Water Hose9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Rubbermaid Commercial Products 50-Gallon Stock TankRubbermaid Commercial Products 50-Gallon Stock Tank9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Camco Heated Drinking Water HoseCamco Heated Drinking Water Hose9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4K&H Stock Tank DeicerK&H Stock Tank DeicerView on Amazon
  5. 5API® Stock Tank Water Trough Heater and De-IcerAPI® Stock Tank Water Trough Heater and De-IcerView on Amazon
  6. 6500W Trough Heater & Stock Tank De-Icer500W Trough Heater & Stock Tank De-IcerView on Amazon
  7. 7500W Stock Tank Water Trough Heater De-icer for 41 to 100Gal500W Stock Tank Water Trough Heater De-icer for 41 to 100GalView on Amazon
  8. 8Rubbermaid Commercial Products Brute Stock TankRubbermaid Commercial Products Brute Stock TankView on Amazon
  9. 9Farm Innovators Submersible Stock Tank De-IcerFarm Innovators Submersible Stock Tank De-IcerView on Amazon

The heated vs unheated stock tank question is about winter water: a heated tank uses a de-icer to keep water ice-free, while an unheated tank relies on manual breaking of ice. For goats in freezing weather, a heated tank wins; in mild climates, an unheated tank is fine. This guide explains both using figures from stock tank de-icer listings.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Heated vs unheated stock tank: the short answer

Choose a heated tank when nights freeze: de-icers from 500W to 1500W keep water open. The Farm Innovators H-429 delivers 1500 watts in a 14 by 14 by 6 in submergible unit, the API 7621 is a 1000-watt floater sized for 70 to 100 gallons, and the Qanskm 500W suits 5 to 50 gallon containers. Choose an unheated tank where water never freezes.

How a heated stock tank works

De-icer types and wattages

Floating de-icers ride the surface: the API 7521 is a 1500-watt floater with a 6 ft anti-rub cord, CSA and UL listed, with a 1-year warranty. Submergible de-icers rest on the bottom: the Farm Innovators H-429 is a 1500-watt cast aluminum unit with an anti-chew cord protector. Drain-plug de-icers thread into the tank opening: the Farm Innovators UPH-15 is 1500 watts with an 11 in length and a one year limited warranty. For tank picks, see our best stock tank for goats.

Thermostats and energy

All the listings are thermostatically controlled: they run only when water nears freezing. The Qanskm 500W starts below 35 degrees F and shuts off at 77 degrees F, per its listing. The API 521G is recommended for 100 to 300 gallons. The K&H 1500W works floating or submersible with a protective cage. For winter picks, see our best stock tank for winter.

How an unheated stock tank works

No power, manual ice breaking

An unheated tank needs no cord, no outlet and no thermostat: it is just the tank. In freezing weather the keeper breaks ice by hand, sometimes twice a day. This is workable where freezes are rare and shallow, and where someone is home to check the water.

When unheated wins

Unheated wins in mild climates with no hard freezes, for tanks checked often, and where no 110-volt power reaches the pen. It loses on convenience and on the goats: a tank that freezes solid overnight leaves the herd without water until morning. For heater picks, see our best water trough heater.

Safety and setup

The listings show the safety features to look for: cages and guards around the element (Farm Innovators H-429, K&H, API 521G with a galvanized wire guard), anti-chew cord protectors, and certifications. The API 7521 is CSA and UL listed; the K&H is safety listed. Keep the element fully submerged, per the K&H listing, and keep it free of mineral buildup. For covers, see our best water trough cover for winter.

What this guide does not cover

This guide does not cover heated buckets, which are a separate category, or automatic waterers with built-in heat. It does not cover breaking ice with tools beyond the manual option. For buckets, see our best water trough heater under 50.

FAQs from goat keepers

Which wattage do I need?

The listings range from 500W to 1500W. The Qanskm 500W suits 5 to 50 gallon containers, the API 7621 1000W suits 70 to 100 gallons, and the API 521G 1500W suits 100 to 300 gallons.

Are de-icers safe for plastic tanks?

The Farm Innovators H-429 is stated safe for plastic tanks with a caged barrier, and the K&H is stated safe for plastic, rubber and metal tanks. The Qanskm states aluminum that avoids melting plastic.

Which listings state a warranty?

The API 7521 states a 1-year warranty and the Farm Innovators UPH-15 a one year limited warranty. The others state no warranty term.

Do de-icers run all winter?

No. All the listings are thermostatically controlled and run only when water nears freezing. The Qanskm states it starts below 35 degrees F and shuts off at 77 degrees F.

More from the barn

See every goat feeding guide.

More picks: stock tanks for goats, water trough float valves and stock tanks under 50.