Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Hay Tarp vs Hay Bale Bag: Which One Should You Buy?

Hay tarp vs hay bale bag: with no tarp listed, this guide compares 4 hay bale bags on fabric, zippers, straps, ventilation and warranty.

Hay Tarp vs Hay Bale Bag: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1NordNynk Hay Bag for Horses and GoatsNordNynk Hay Bag for Horses and Goats9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Majestic Ally Premium Nylon Hay Bag for Horses and LivestockMajestic Ally Premium Nylon Hay Bag for Horses and LivestockView on Amazon
  3. 3Cashel Rolling Bale Bag Regular SizeCashel Rolling Bale Bag Regular SizeView on Amazon
  4. 4Tough 1 Nylon Hay Tote Bag in PrintsTough 1 Nylon Hay Tote Bag in PrintsView on Amazon
  5. 5Cashel Rolling Bale Bag Hay bag HaybagCashel Rolling Bale Bag Hay bag HaybagView on Amazon
  6. 6Weaver Leather Hay Bale BagWeaver Leather Hay Bale BagView on Amazon
  7. 74 Pcs Hay Bag Hanging Goat Feeder Tote with Adjustable Strap4 Pcs Hay Bag Hanging Goat Feeder Tote with Adjustable StrapView on Amazon

Hay tarp vs hay bale bag is a choice between covering a stack where it sits and carrying a bale where it needs to go, and the listings compared here cover the bag side only: no hay tarp is listed among them. This guide compares hay bale bags on fabric, zippers, straps, ventilation and warranty, so you can pick the bag that fits your bale and your barn. A storage bag suits a bale that moves between barn and trailer, while a slow feed bag suits feeding that needs to slow down and cut waste.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Hay tarp vs hay bale bag: the short answer

Start with the job, then pick the bag. A tarp covers a stack in place, while a bag carries a bale and stores it between feedings. The listings here are bags, so the choice inside this guide is between storage bags and slow feed bags: the Majestic Ally storage bag leads on stated build, with 1200 D nylon, a three-sided wraparound zipper and a 06 Month Manufacturing warranty, and the QWORK bag follows with a 2 pack, a ventilation system and a three-sided full wraparound zipper. Pick a storage bag to move and store a bale, and pick a slow feed bag to hang at the fence and slow the eating.

If you would rather start from feeders, our best hay feeder for goats roundup scores hay feeders on the same points.

The bags compared

Bag Material Size or pack Warranty
Majestic Ally Hay Bale Storage Bag 1200 D nylon 44.0 by 20.0 by 16.0 inches, Large 06 Month Manufacturing
QWORK Hay Bale Storage Bag 420D Oxford cloth 2 pack, holds a full sized bale Not stated
Majestic Ally Premium Nylon Hay Bag Premium nylon, PP webbing Not stated 01 Year
Harrison Howard Slow Feed Hay Bag Oxford cloth, coated outer Not stated Not stated

Storage bags

Storage bags carry a bale and keep it covered between feedings. The Majestic Ally storage bag lists 1200 D water repellent nylon with ultra-strong stitching, a three-sided wraparound zipper, full around carry straps with cross-stitched fastening and padded handles, and a size of 44.0 by 20.0 by 16.0 inches in Large. The QWORK bag lists 420D Oxford cloth that is tear resistant, a three-sided full wraparound zipper, durable straps with cross-stitch fastening, and a 2 pack that holds a full sized bale and folds fully when not in use. A storage bag suits a bale that moves from barn to trailer, and the zipper and straps decide how easy it is to load and carry.

Slow feed bags

Slow feed bags hang at the fence and meter hay through holes or a grid, so less hay lands on the ground. The Majestic Ally slow feed bag lists premium nylon with heavy-duty polypropylene webbing on the front and bottom, reinforced stitching with bar-tack support, quick-adjust straps for a customizable fit, and small holes that encourage slow feeding. The Harrison Howard bag lists Oxford cloth with a coated outer, an extra large opening at the top, a large grid-opening on the side, and a sturdy hanging strap that adjusts to hang in stables, trailers or on fences. The maker says the grid-opening is a slow feed design that helps reduce wastage, and the bag keeps hay contained and off the ground. Slow feed bags sit beside slow feed hay nets as a way to slow feeding at the fence.

Reading the fabric and the build

The listings here use 4 materials:

  • 1200 D nylon: the Majestic Ally storage bag, water repellent, with ultra-strong stitching.
  • Premium nylon with PP webbing: the Majestic Ally slow feed bag, with reinforced stitching and bar-tack support.
  • Oxford cloth with a coated outer: the Harrison Howard bag, described as anti-wearing by the maker.
  • 420D Oxford cloth: the QWORK bag, described as tear resistant by the maker.

The 1200 D nylon lists a higher denier figure than the 420D cloth. Stitching matters as much as fabric: cross-stitched fastening on the Majestic Ally storage bag and the QWORK bag, and bar-tack support on the Majestic Ally slow feed bag, are the stated reinforcements.

Zippers, straps and carrying

Zippers and straps decide how a bag loads, hangs and carries. The Majestic Ally storage bag and the QWORK bag each list a three-sided wraparound zipper, which opens the bag wide for loading a bale. The Majestic Ally storage bag adds full around carry straps with cross-stitched fastening and padded handles, and the QWORK bag adds durable straps with cross-stitch fastening. The slow feed bags hang rather than carry: the Majestic Ally slow feed bag lists quick-adjust straps, and the Harrison Howard bag lists a sturdy hanging strap on top that adjusts. Check the strap and the zipper before you buy.

Capacity and pack sizes

Capacity is stated as a size, a pack count or a bale, and the listings state it differently. The Majestic Ally storage bag lists a size of 44.0 by 20.0 by 16.0 inches in Large, the only size figure among the 4 bags. The QWORK bag lists a 2 pack and says it holds a full sized bale of hay, and it folds fully when not in use. The Harrison Howard bag lists an extra large opening at the top and a large size that holds plenty of hay, without a size figure. The Majestic Ally slow feed bag lists no size figure and no pack count. Match the stated size to your bale before ordering.

Ventilation and slow feeding

Ventilation and slow feeding pull in opposite directions, and each bag picks a side. The QWORK bag lists a ventilation system the maker says keeps hay dry and fresh. The Majestic Ally slow feed bag lists small holes that encourage slow feeding, and the Harrison Howard bag lists a large grid-opening that controls feeding speed. The Majestic Ally storage bag lists no ventilation feature and no slow feed feature. If the bag will store a bale, ventilation matters; if the bag will hang at the fence for feeding, the holes and the grid matter more.

Read the listing twice

Measure your bale before ordering, then match the figure to the bag. The Majestic Ally storage bag is the only bag with a stated size, at 44.0 by 20.0 by 16.0 inches in Large, so it is the only bag you can match to a bale by the numbers. The QWORK bag says it holds a full sized bale without a size figure, and the slow feed bags give no size figure at all. Warranty terms split the same way: the Majestic Ally storage bag lists a 06 Month Manufacturing warranty and the Majestic Ally slow feed bag lists a 01 Year warranty, while the Harrison Howard bag and the QWORK bag list no warranty term. Check the strap, the zipper and the warranty term in the same pass, and ask the maker about any figure that is missing.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers bag hardware only. It does not cover hay types, how much hay a goat needs, or any health question. It does not cover tarps: no tarp is listed among the products compared here, so a tarp needs its own check before you buy. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.

FAQs from goat keepers

Should I buy a hay tarp or a hay bale bag?

Buy a bag to carry and store a bale, and a tarp to cover a stack in place. The bags compared here are storage bags and slow feed bags, and no tarp is listed among them, so check a tarp on its own before you buy.

What size hay bale bag do I need?

The Majestic Ally storage bag lists a size of 44.0 by 20.0 by 16.0 inches in Large, and the QWORK bag says it holds a full sized bale. The slow feed bags list no size figure, so measure your bale and match it to the stated size before ordering.

Are hay bale bags good for slow feeding?

The Majestic Ally slow feed bag lists small holes that encourage slow feeding, and the Harrison Howard bag lists a large grid-opening that controls feeding speed. Each hangs from a strap, and the grid or the holes decide how fast hay comes out.

Do hay bale bags come with a warranty?

2 of the 4 bags list one: the Majestic Ally storage bag lists a 06 Month Manufacturing warranty, and the Majestic Ally slow feed bag lists a 01 Year warranty. The Harrison Howard bag and the QWORK bag list no warranty term.

What is the difference between a storage bag and a slow feed bag?

A storage bag carries and covers a bale, with a zipper and carry straps, while a slow feed bag hangs at the fence and meters hay through holes or a grid.

Can a hay bale bag hold a full bale?

The QWORK bag says it holds a full sized bale of hay, and it comes as a 2 pack. The Majestic Ally storage bag lists a size of 44.0 by 20.0 by 16.0 inches, so check your bale against that size before ordering.

More from the barn

See every hay feeder guide and all feeding and water guides.

More picks: best hay feeders for goats, goat mineral feeders, heated water buckets and goat shelters.