
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Wall Mount Hay Rack 16 Gallon 27'' Long Livestock Hay Feeder9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
2-in-1 Wall Mount Hay Feeder9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Hay Bag Hanging Goat Feeder Tote with Adjustable Strap9.3/10View on Amazon - 4
BUYYAH Livestock Hay Feeder 60 GallonView on Amazon - 5
Hay Feeder 35 GallonsView on Amazon - 6
Goat Hay FeederView on Amazon - 7
5 Ft Long Goat Hay FeederView on Amazon - 8
BUYYAH 5Ft Stainless Steel Pasture FeederView on Amazon - 9
99 Gallon Galvanized Steel Goat Sheep FeederView on Amazon
Hay on the ground and grain scattered in the bedding are the usual signs that a feeder does not fit the herd, and goat feeder vs sheep feeder is really a question about feeder style, capacity and mounting, not about a separate design for each animal.
Also worth comparing
BUYYAH Livestock Hay Feeder 60 GallonCheck price on Amazon
Hay Feeder 35 GallonsCheck price on Amazon
Goat Hay FeederCheck price on Amazon
5 Ft Long Goat Hay FeederCheck price on Amazon
BUYYAH 5Ft Stainless Steel Pasture FeederCheck price on Amazon
99 Gallon Galvanized Steel Goat Sheep FeederCheck price on Amazon
All the listings in this guide name goats and sheep, with horses and ponies named on some listings as well, so the choice is about the feeder in hand: wall rack or freestanding, gallon capacity or cubic-foot capacity, and steel or fabric build. This guide compares wall-mounted and freestanding hay and grain feeders on stated capacity, mounting, materials, grain trays and listing gaps, so a mixed herd can be fed from a feeder that fits the barn or the pasture.
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
goat feeder vs sheep feeder: the short answer
Start with where the feeder will go, then pick the style, then check capacity and build. A wall rack suits a barn or shed with a solid wall or post. A freestanding feeder suits a pasture or open pen with no wall at all. Once the style is settled, compare the stated capacity, the material and whether the feeder adds a grain tray, and read the listing twice for conflicting numbers.
For a mixed herd, see best goat feeder for mixed herds.
Feeder styles compared
| Style | Example listing | Stated capacity | Mounting |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freestanding | lesolar Hay Feeder 35 Gallons | 30 gal hay + 5 gal grain | Pasture and outdoor yards |
| Freestanding | BUYYAH Livestock Hay Feeder 60 Gallon | 60 gallon grass and 10 gallon shredded grass | Pasture feeder |
| Wall rack | NANANARDOSO 2-in-1 Wall Mount Hay Feeder | 2.5 cu.ft | Wall mount |
| Freestanding | Kojem 4 Ft Long Livestock Feeder | Not stated in gallons | Not stated |
Wall racks
Wall racks keep hay off the floor and leave the pen clear for cleaning. The NANANARDOSO wall rack lists rust-resistant carbon steel, a 2.5 cu.ft feeding capacity and overall dimensions of 24.8" L x 24.4" W x 12.6" H in the bullets. A removable feed tray lets the feeder offer hay and grain in the feeder, and multiple access sides allow animals to eat at once in the listing language. The listing states BPA-free construction, indoor and outdoor use, and included tools and hardware with screws for wall install, so wall mounting leaves floor space clear in stalls or barns.
Freestanding feeders
A freestanding feeder sits on the ground with no wall. The lesolar feeder lists premium galvanized metal with a rust-proof coating, 30 gal hay and 5 gal grain in a single unit, and product dimensions of 31.1 inches x 21.65 inches x 28.74 inches. Its open design and included hardware suit farms, barns, stables, sheep pens and outdoor yards in the listing language. The BUYYAH feeder lists a robust galvanized steel frame, a thickened nylon fabric feeding trough, 60 gallon grass and 10 gallon shredded grass, product dimensions of 51.57 inches x 22.8 inches x 30.5 inches, and an item weight of 30.0 pounds. Assembly needs some screws and takes 10 minutes in the listing language, and the lightweight structure suits farms, sheep sheds, horse farms and courtyards. The Kojem feeder lists heavy duty steel with a powder coated finish, dimensions of 47 x 22.50 x 38 inches in the bullets, and a feeding pan that places grain and collects hay dropped during feeding. Its pan has no sharp or rough edges in the listing language, and pre-drilled holes and assembly instructions suit farms and ranches for sheep, goats and ponies.
Reading capacity against your herd
Capacity on these listings is given in gallons of space or in cubic feet, not in pounds of hay, and makers measure it differently. The lesolar listing states 30 gal hay and 5 gal grain, the BUYYAH listing states 60 gallon grass and 10 gallon shredded grass, and the NANANARDOSO listing states 2.5 cu.ft. Gallons and cubic feet are different units, and none of these listings converts a gallon figure into a weight of hay, so treat gallons as a way to rank feeders against each other within the same unit, not as a daily ration.
The Kojem listing states no capacity in gallons at all, so its size must be judged from its stated dimensions of 47 x 22.50 x 38 inches rather than from a gallon figure. A practical approach is to count the animals in the pen and pick a feeder that leaves room at the rack. If separate groups share a barn, separate racks in separate pens often work better than a shared rack for everyone.
Mounting and where the feeder goes
Mounting decides how stable the feeder is and how easy it is to fill. Wall racks need anchors into something solid; the NANANARDOSO listing includes tools and hardware with screws for wall install. Freestanding feeders need level ground and enough room for animals to reach from different sides. A rack mounted by the barn door is easier to refill than a rack in the back corner, and an open design makes it easier to drop hay in from above and to clean residue out. Place hay feeders away from water buckets so dropped hay stays dry, and keep grain feeding in the tray or pan the listing states rather than mixing grain into the hay rack itself.
Materials: steel, galvanized steel and nylon fabric
Material sets how long a feeder lasts outdoors. The listings in this guide use these materials:
- Carbon steel: the NANANARDOSO wall rack, described as rust-resistant carbon steel and BPA-free by the maker.
- Galvanized steel: the BUYYAH frame and the lesolar feeder, described as galvanized metal with a rust-proof coating by the maker.
- Heavy duty steel with powder coated finish: the Kojem feeder, with a powder coated finish that can avoid rust from humidity or debris in the listing language.
- Nylon fabric: the BUYYAH trough, described as a thickened nylon fabric feeding trough that catches grass in the listing language.
For a permanent barn feeder, a steel frame is the sturdier choice. A fabric trough trades some durability for a light, flexible catch surface, so check the trough for wear during daily chores and keep the frame on level ground.
Grain trays and 2-in-1 designs
All the listings in this guide are 2-in-1 designs in title or bullets. The NANANARDOSO feeder pairs a hay rack with a removable feed tray for grain. The lesolar feeder holds 30 gal hay and 5 gal grain in the unit with roughage and concentrate kept separate and clean in the listing language. The Kojem feeder pairs a hay rack with a feeding pan that places grain and collects hay dropped during feeding, reducing feed waste in the listing language. The BUYYAH feeder is listed as 2 in 1 with a grass trough and a shredded grass capacity of 10 gallon alongside 60 gallon grass. A tray also catches some of the hay animals pull out, though none of these listings measures how much. If grain is fed at a separate time and place, a plain rack without a tray is simpler to clean.
Read the listing twice
Feeder listings often contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones needed to plan the install:
- NANANARDOSO: 24.8" L x 24.4" W x 12.6" H in the bullets against 24.8 inches x 12.6 inches x 24.4 inches in the spec table, with the same figures in a different order, and Model NX4784-B1 against PartNumber NX4784-S1.
- BUYYAH: 60 Gallon in the title against 60 gallon grass and 10 gallon shredded grass in the bullets, so the title alone does not show the full capacity picture.
- Kojem: a title that ends with Grain & and a spec table with no dimensions, against dimensions of 47 x 22.50 x 38 inches in the bullets.
- lesolar: 35 Gallons in the title against 30 gal hay and 5 gal grain in the bullets as separate compartments, with spec table dimensions of 31.1 inches x 21.65 inches x 28.74 inches.
Measure the wall or pen before ordering and allow for the larger figure where dimensions conflict. Some listings also make health claims about feeding habits or growth; those are left out here, because a feeder is equipment, not a health product.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers feeder hardware only. It does not cover how much hay an animal needs, hay types or any health question. Ask a veterinarian or local extension office about rations and animal health.
FAQs from goat keepers
Do goats and sheep need different feeders?
No separate design appears in this set. All the listings name goats and sheep, so pick by feeder style, stated capacity, mounting and material rather than by animal name alone.
How big should a goat feeder be?
Listings state capacity in gallons or cubic feet, from 35 Gallons on the lesolar title and 60 Gallon on the BUYYAH title to 2.5 cu.ft on the NANANARDOSO listing, while the Kojem listing states no capacity in gallons. Compare gallons between feeders in gallons, leave room at the rack for every animal in the pen, and use stated dimensions where no gallon figure is given.
Are wall racks or freestanding feeders better for a mixed herd?
It depends on the pen. A wall rack such as the NANANARDOSO suits a barn with a solid wall, while a freestanding feeder such as the lesolar or BUYYAH suits a pasture or open pen, and each names goats and sheep.
Do these feeders come with mounting hardware?
Some do. The NANANARDOSO listing includes tools and hardware with screws, the lesolar listing states included hardware, and the BUYYAH listing says assembly needs some screws and takes 10 minutes. The Kojem listing states assembly instructions and pre-drilled holes, with hardware inclusion Not stated.
More from the barn
See every hay feeder guide and all feeding and water guides.
More picks: best hay feeders for goats, goat mineral feeders, heated water buckets and goat shelters.
