Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Bale Spear vs Hay Bale Hooks: Which One Should You Buy?

Bale spear vs hay bale hooks: a tractor spear lifts the whole bale, while hooks move it by hand, so the right tool depends on your tractor and your bales.

Bale Spear vs Hay Bale Hooks: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Titan Attachments C3 47.5 in Square Hay Bale SpearTitan Attachments C3 47.5 in Square Hay Bale Spear9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Lawneagle 11 Inch Hay Hooks for BalesLawneagle 11 Inch Hay Hooks for Bales9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3VEVOR Hay Spear 32" Bale Spear 1350 lbs CapacityVEVOR Hay Spear 32" Bale Spear 1350 lbs CapacityView on Amazon
  4. 4Vevor Hay Spear 49" Bale Spear 4500 lbs CapacityVevor Hay Spear 49" Bale Spear 4500 lbs CapacityView on Amazon
  5. 5Vevor Hay Spear 39" Bale Spear 3600 lbs CapacityVevor Hay Spear 39" Bale Spear 3600 lbs CapacityView on Amazon
  6. 6GarveeLife 49" Hay SpearGarveeLife 49" Hay SpearView on Amazon
  7. 7Vevor Pair Hay Spear 43" Bale Spear 3000 lbs CapacityVevor Pair Hay Spear 43" Bale Spear 3000 lbs CapacityView on Amazon
  8. 8VEVOR Hay Spear Spears 49" Hay Bale Spear SpikeVEVOR Hay Spear Spears 49" Hay Bale Spear SpikeView on Amazon

Hay ends up on the ground by the gate every morning, and the bale that feeds the goats still sits where the truck left it. Bale spear vs hay bale hooks is the choice between a tractor attachment that lifts the whole bale and a hand tool that drags it a short distance at a time. This guide compares the two tools by what they lift, what they mount to and what the listings state, using the bale spears below with stated lengths and capacities.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Bale spear vs hay bale hooks: the short answer

A bale spear wins when a tractor or skid steer does the moving: the spear drives into the bale, the loader lifts it, and the bale rides to the feeder in a single trip. Hay bale hooks win when there is no tractor at hand or the bale only needs moving a short distance: the hook bites into the bale and you drag it by hand. The spears in this guide mount in different ways: the VEVOR 49-inch spear fits a 3-point hitch, the GarveeLife 49-inch spear and the VEVOR 32-inch spear fit quick attach loaders, and the Ag-Rite 43-inch spears bolt onto Conus 2 frames. Capacity separates them too: the GarveeLife spear lists 3000 lbs, the VEVOR 49-inch spear lists 1600 lbs, the VEVOR 32-inch spear lists 1350 lbs, and the Ag-Rite kit states no capacity. Pick the spear that matches your machine, then check the capacity against your bales. For what happens after the bale is open, see hay feeder vs feed pan.

The tools compared

Tool Length Stated capacity Mounting
GarveeLife 49-inch skid-steer spear 49 in 3000 lbs Skid steer quick attach
VEVOR 49-inch 3-point spear 49 in 1600 lbs 3-point hitch
VEVOR 32-inch quick-attach spear 32 in 1350 lbs Buckets and loaders
Ag-Rite 43-inch bolt-on spears, kit of 2 43 in Not stated Bolt-on Conus 2 frames

Bale spears

The GarveeLife spear lists a 49-inch spike with a pair of 17-inch stabilizer spears and a 3000 lbs capacity, and the maker states the frame is 45.6 inches long and 18.9 inches wide. The VEVOR 49-inch spear lists a 1600 lbs capacity with a pair of 17.5-inch stabilizer spears, a 1.18-inch thread diameter and a 2.05-inch thread length, plus a 2-5/16-inch hitch ball diameter. The VEVOR 32-inch spear lists a 1350 lbs capacity in a single spike 1 3/8 inches wide, with a hex nut and sleeve. The Ag-Rite kit holds 2 bolt-on spears of 43 inches with a Conus 2 taper and a black finish, and the kit includes no sleeves. Spring steel shows up in both VEVOR listings, and the GarveeLife spear uses heavy-duty steel.

Hay bale hooks

Hay bale hooks are hand tools: a steel hook on a handle that bites into the bale so you can drag it across the yard or onto a trailer. No tractor, hitch or loader is needed, and no mounting hardware is involved. Hooks suit small bales that a person can move by hand and short moves around the barn, such as pulling a bale from the stack to the feeder. They do not lift a bale onto a trailer bed or carry it across a pasture the way a spear on a loader does. This guide compares spears from listings, so the hook side of this comparison rests on the tool type rather than a listed hook. If the bale stays on the ground and the move is short, hooks cost less effort than carrying loose hay by the armful.

Reading capacity against your bales

Capacity is the number to check, and the listings state it plainly for 3 of the spears: the GarveeLife spear lists 3000 lbs, the VEVOR 49-inch spear lists 1600 lbs and the VEVOR 32-inch spear lists 1350 lbs. The Ag-Rite kit states no capacity, so compare its 43-inch length and bolt-on mount against the other spears rather than against a load figure. Length matters as much as capacity: a 49-inch spike passes through a large round bale, while a 32-inch spike suits smaller bales and tight loader work. The stabilizer spears add grip: a pair of 17.5-inch stabilizers on the VEVOR 49-inch spear and a pair of 17-inch stabilizers on the GarveeLife spear keep the bale from shifting or tipping while it rides. Weight matters when the spear comes off the machine: the VEVOR 49-inch spear weighs 70.98 pounds, the VEVOR 32-inch spear weighs 10.2 pounds, and the GarveeLife spear lists about 122 pounds in its bullets against 113.54 pounds in its spec table.

Mounting and where the spear goes

Mounting decides which machine can carry the spear. The VEVOR 49-inch spear fits 3-point hitch tractors, with a 2-5/16-inch hitch ball diameter and self-locking nuts, external hex screws and anti-loosening pins included. The GarveeLife spear fits skid steers and tractors with a fast-attach system, and the VEVOR 32-inch spear fits buckets, grapples and other skid-steer and tractor attachments. The Ag-Rite spears bolt onto Conus 2 frames and mounts, and the kit includes no sleeves, so it suits setups that already use Conus 2 frames. Check the mount on your machine before ordering: a 3-point spear does not fit a quick attach loader, and a bolt-on spear needs a frame with the matching taper. The spear should also match the bale: round bales ride on a single long spike with stabilizers, while square bales sit steady on a matched pair.

Materials: spring steel, heavy-duty steel and coatings

Material sets how the spear holds up to bending and rust. Both VEVOR spears use spring steel: the 49-inch spear pairs it with a powder coating, and the 32-inch spear is forged and heat-treated with a red coating. The GarveeLife spear uses heavy-duty steel with a reinforced design and a powder-coated finish, and the maker states it resists rust and wear. The Ag-Rite spears carry a black coating that helps resist corrosion and surface wear from outdoor exposure. Coatings matter because a spear lives outdoors on a loader or a tractor, and the listings describe powder coat and black finishes as protection against rust and wear.

Stabilizer spears and matched pairs

Stabilizers keep a round bale from rolling or shifting on the main spike. The VEVOR 49-inch spear ships with a pair of 17.5-inch stabilizer spears, and the GarveeLife spear ships with a pair of 17-inch stabilizer spears. The VEVOR 32-inch spear is a single spike with a hex nut and sleeve, so it carries the bale without stabilizers. The Ag-Rite kit holds 2 spears of 43 inches, which work as a matched set on frames built for more than one spear. Check whether your frame has mounts for another spear before counting on the pair.

Read the listing twice

Hay spear listings contradict themselves on the numbers you need for the install, so read the bullets against the spec table before ordering. The GarveeLife spear weighs about 122 pounds in its bullets and 113.54 pounds in its spec table, so allow for the heavier figure when lifting it on and off the machine. The same listing gives the frame as 45.6 inches long and 18.9 inches wide in its bullets and 46.46 inches long in its spec table, while the spike itself is 49 inches. The VEVOR 49-inch spear lists 49 inches in its title and 49.21 inches in its spec table, a small gap that matters only if the mount is tight. The VEVOR 32-inch spear lists a width of 1 3/8 inches in its title and 1.4 inches in its spec table. Measure your mount and allow for the larger figure.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers spear hardware only. It does not cover tractor driving, loader capacity beyond the stated figures, or how much hay a goat needs. Ask your equipment dealer or local extension office about tractor and loader safety and about rations and goat health. For the racks that hold the hay once the bale is open, see corner hay rack vs round hay rack.

FAQs from goat keepers

Which should you buy, a bale spear or hay bale hooks?

Buy a spear when a tractor or loader does the moving: the spear lifts the whole bale in a single trip. Buy hooks when there is no tractor at hand and the bale only needs moving a short distance by hand. The spears in this guide mount to tractors and loaders, while hooks need no machine at all.

What bale spear size fits your machine and bales?

Match the spear to your machine and your bales. The spears in this guide run 32, 43 and 49 inches long, with stated capacities of 1350, 1600 and 3000 lbs. Check the mount on your machine, then pick the capacity that covers your bales.

What hitch does a bale spear need?

It depends on the spear. The VEVOR 49-inch spear fits a 3-point hitch, the GarveeLife spear fits skid steers and tractors with a fast-attach system, and the VEVOR 32-inch spear fits buckets and loaders. The Ag-Rite spears bolt onto Conus 2 frames.

Do bale spears come with stabilizer spears?

Some do. The VEVOR 49-inch spear ships with a pair of 17.5-inch stabilizer spears, and the GarveeLife spear ships with a pair of 17-inch stabilizer spears. The VEVOR 32-inch spear is a single spike, and the Ag-Rite kit holds 2 spears with no sleeves.

More from the barn

See every hay feeder guide and all feeding and water guides.

More picks: best hay feeders for goats, goat mineral feeders, heated water buckets and goat shelters.