Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Hay Fork vs Bale Spear: Which One Should You Buy?

Hay fork vs bale spear comes down to the load: pitchforks lift loose hay by the tine, while a bale spear lifts a whole bale from a loader.

Hay Fork vs Bale Spear: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1YITAMOTOR 4000 lbs Skid Steer Pallet Fork AttachmentYITAMOTOR 4000 lbs Skid Steer Pallet Fork Attachment9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2VEVOR 49" Hay SpearVEVOR 49" Hay SpearView on Amazon
  3. 3Pitch Forks for Garden with 18 TinesPitch Forks for Garden with 18 TinesView on Amazon
  4. 4Truper 5-Tine Barley Fork with 48-Inch Ash HandleTruper 5-Tine Barley Fork with 48-Inch Ash HandleView on Amazon
  5. 5VNIMTI Pitch Fork Heavy DutyVNIMTI Pitch Fork Heavy DutyView on Amazon
  6. 6GarveeLife 49" Hay SpearGarveeLife 49" Hay SpearView on Amazon
  7. 7Vevor Pair Hay Spear 43" Bale Spear 3000 lbs CapacityVevor Pair Hay Spear 43" Bale Spear 3000 lbs CapacityView on Amazon

Hay on the ground after feeding is a daily chore in any barn, and the tool in your hand decides whether the job is quick or slow: hay fork vs bale spear is the choice between lifting loose hay by the tine and lifting a whole bale from a loader. The tools in this guide show what the listings state about tines, length, handles and capacity. Read on for the differences that matter before you pick a tool.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Hay fork vs bale spear: the short answer

Pick a fork for loose hay and a spear for whole bales. A pitchfork lifts hay, manure, compost and mulch by the tine, and the listings here run from 4 to 10 tines. A bale spear lifts a whole bale from a skid steer loader or tractor, and the VEVOR listing states a 1600 lbs load capacity with a 49 inch shaft. A fork works by hand in the barn and garden; a spear needs a loader with a quick attach system.

Forks and a spear compared

Tool Tines Length Handle or mount Weight or capacity
VEVOR 49 inch Hay Spear 49 inch shaft, 2 stabilizer spears 49 inches Quick attach mount 1600 lbs capacity
Nohovu 5 Tine Pitchfork 5 tines 58 inches Fiberglass 3.88 pounds
COSITA 10 Tine Pitchfork 10 tines 44 inches Fiberglass 5 pounds
COSITA 4 Tine Pitchfork 4 tines 44 inches Fiberglass Not stated

Pitchforks

Pitchforks lift loose material by the tine. The Nohovu listing states 5 tines, a head 8.26 inches wide, a 58 inch fiberglass handle and 2 non-slip grips, and a carbon steel head with a rust-resistant coating. The COSITA 4-tine listing states a heat-treated steel head, a fiberglass handle with a non-slip cushion grip and a D-grip, and a 44 inch length. The COSITA 10-tine listing states a wide 10-tine carbon steel head, a 44 inch fiberglass handle with a D-grip, and a weight of 5 pounds. More tines carry more in each scoop, while fewer tines pierce dense hay more easily.

Bale spears

A bale spear is a loader attachment, not a hand tool. The VEVOR listing states a 49 inch shaft, 2 stabilizer spears of 17.5 inches, a 1600 lbs load capacity, and a 2.36 inch diameter shaft. The spear fits skid steer loaders and tractors with a quick attach system, and the listing states self-locking nuts and external hex screws hold the spears. The listing states a weight of 126.76 pounds for the attachment.

The gear in this guide

The 4 tools below are ranked from the strongest listing to the weakest: the VEVOR spear leads on stated capacity, then the Nohovu fork on stated length and weight, then the COSITA 10-tine fork, then the COSITA 4-tine fork, which states no weight.

VEVOR 49 inch Hay Spear

The VEVOR listing states a 49 inch spring steel shaft with a 1600 lbs load capacity, 2 stabilizer spears of 17.5 inches, and a 2.36 inch diameter. The spear fits skid steer loaders and tractors with a quick attach system, and the listing states self-locking nuts and external hex screws hold the spears. It weighs 126.76 pounds. Who it is for: a loader owner who moves whole bales. Who should skip it: anyone without a loader, since the spear is a loader attachment, not a hand tool.

Nohovu 5 Tine Pitchfork

The Nohovu listing states 5 tines, a head 8.26 inches wide, a 58 inch fiberglass handle with 2 non-slip grips, and a carbon steel head with a rust-resistant coating. The fork weighs 3.88 pounds and measures 58.0 by 8.26 by 4.1 inches. The listing states the fork moves hay, manure, compost, grain, mulch and fall leaves. Who it is for: a gardener or farmer who wants the longest fork here for loose material. Who should skip it: anyone who needs to lift a whole bale, which needs a spear.

COSITA 10 Tine Pitchfork

The COSITA listing states a wide 10-tine carbon steel head, a 44 inch fiberglass handle with a D-grip, and a weight of 5 pounds. The listing states the fork lifts hay and straw, turns leaves, spreads mulch, cleans chicken coops and turns compost. Who it is for: a barn owner who wants the widest scoop here for loose material. Who should skip it: anyone who needs to pierce dense hay, where the 4-tine fork suits better.

COSITA 4 Tine Pitchfork

The COSITA listing states a 4-tine heat-treated steel head, a 44 inch fiberglass handle with a non-slip cushion grip and a D-grip, and tool-free assembly with a reinforced joint. The listing states the fork lifts dense hay, straw and compost, and warns it is not recommended for compacted soil or clay. No weight is stated in the listing. Who it is for: a farmer who wants piercing power for dense hay. Who should skip it: anyone who needs a stated weight or a wide scoop.

Reading length against the job

Length sets the leverage and the reach. The Nohovu fork runs 58 inches, and the COSITA forks run 44 inches. The Nohovu listing states the longer size reduces the bending angle and reduces back stress. The VEVOR spear runs 49 inches, and its length is the reach into the bale, not a handle to hold. Match the length to the work: a longer fork for lifting from a pile, a shorter fork for close work in a coop or stall. See the dimensions of hay bale guide when you size the bale to the tool.

Materials: steel, fiberglass and spring steel

Heads are carbon steel on the Nohovu and COSITA 10-tine forks, heat-treated steel on the COSITA 4-tine fork, and spring steel on the VEVOR spear. Handles are fiberglass on the forks, and the Nohovu head carries a rust-resistant coating while the VEVOR shaft carries a powder coating. Fiberglass handles will not splinter, warp or corrode, as the COSITA listings state, and the D-grip on the COSITA forks gives a firm hold.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers hay handling tools only. It does not cover how much hay a goat needs, hay types or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health. See do goats eat hay for the feeding side.

FAQs from goat keepers

Can a pitchfork lift a whole hay bale?

No. A pitchfork lifts loose hay by the tine, while a whole bale needs a spear: the VEVOR listing states a 1600 lbs load capacity with a 49 inch shaft for a loader.

How many tines should a hay fork have?

The listings here run from 4 to 10 tines: the COSITA 4-tine fork for dense hay, the Nohovu 5-tine fork for general work, and the COSITA 10-tine fork for a wider scoop. More tines carry more in each scoop.

What is a bale spear for?

A bale spear lifts and moves whole hay bales from a skid steer loader or tractor with a quick attach system. The VEVOR listing states 2 stabilizer spears of 17.5 inches beside the 49 inch shaft.

Are fiberglass handles better than wood?

The listings here state fiberglass handles that will not splinter, warp or corrode, and the COSITA listings state a non-slip grip and a D-grip. No wooden handle is stated in these listings.

More from the barn

See every Hay Handling guide and all Barn and Farm Tools guides.

More picks: dimensions of hay bale, how to use a moisture meter on hay bales, do goats eat hay and goat hay feeder ideas.