Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Hay Rack vs Hay Feeder: Which One Should You Buy?

Hay rack vs hay feeder: hay rack and feeder listings compared by capacity, mounting and feeding control, with how to choose for goats.

Hay Rack vs Hay Feeder: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Wall Mount Hay Rack 16 Gallon 27'' Long Livestock Hay FeederWall Mount Hay Rack 16 Gallon 27'' Long Livestock Hay Feeder9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Pasture Hay Feeder 45 Gallon for Farms Hay Grain LivestockPasture Hay Feeder 45 Gallon for Farms Hay Grain Livestock9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3BUYYAH 2Pcs Goat Hay FeederBUYYAH 2Pcs Goat Hay Feeder9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 42Pcs Hay Feeder Goat 22 Gallon Hay Rack2Pcs Hay Feeder Goat 22 Gallon Hay RackView on Amazon
  5. 5VEVOR Wall Mounted Hay RackVEVOR Wall Mounted Hay RackView on Amazon

The hay rack vs hay feeder question is about open access against controlled feeding: a rack is a wall-mounted open cradle that holds hay for free-choice eating, while a feeder adds a grain tray or a mesh that slows intake and cuts waste. For goats, a rack suits free-choice hay and a feeder suits measured rations. This guide explains both using figures from hay rack and feeder listings.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Hay rack vs hay feeder: the short answer

Pick a rack for free-choice hay: the Scenic Road wall hay rack is 25 by 27 by 10 in with a 1/3 bale capacity, and the Lazaluking wall rack is 35.5 by 13 by 17 in with a 67 gallon capacity. Pick a feeder for controlled feeding: the YXJSTO is a 2-in-1 hay and grain feeder at 21.5 by 13.1 by 23.6 in with a 15 gallon capacity and a 4 by 4 in hay mesh that prevents overflow. Every number below comes from one of these listings.

How a hay rack works

Open cradle, free choice

A rack is an open cradle mounted on the wall or fence that goats pull hay from freely. The Scenic Road rack holds 1/3 of a bale in powder-coated American steel with rounded edges stated to eliminate injury. The BUYYAH rack is 31.5 by 15.5 by 22.5 in with 24 gallon capacity per rack, stated as long-lasting carbon steel that is rust-proof and BPA-free.

Waste is the tradeoff

Open racks waste more: goats pull hay out and trample it. The Harhana feeder, at 9.7 by 4.7 by 6.6 in, states its sealed bottom contains hay and prevents spills, and the YXJSTO’s 4 by 4 in mesh keeps hay from overflowing. A rack suits owners who accept some waste for the simplicity of filling once. For rack picks, see our best hay rack for sheep.

How a hay feeder works

Mesh and grain in one unit

A feeder slows the goat down. The YXJSTO combines a hay rack with a grain feeder: the 4 by 4 in hay mesh design prevents overflow while the bottom groove holds grain, with galvanized sheet and 304 stainless steel screws stated. The Lazaluking rack’s open slats are stated to slow feeding speed, reducing the risk of stomach issues. The listing states a 1 year warranty.

When a feeder wins

A feeder wins for measured rations, grain supplementation and waste control. The BUYYAH 2-pack states a 2 year manufacture warranty and rust-resistant construction. The YXJSTO states a 2 year warranty description and holds 15 gallons. Small-animal cage feeders like the CAIQINLI at 6.8 by 6.7 by 6.6 in are a different size class and suit rabbits, not goats. For feeder picks, see our best hay feeder for goats.

Sizing for goats

Size the unit to the herd: the Lazaluking at 35.5 by 13 by 17 in states multiple goats, cows or horses can feed at once, and the BUYYAH states 8 horses can eat at the same time. Wall mounting, stated on the Scenic Road, Lazaluking and BUYYAH, keeps the unit off the ground and out of the bedding. For choosing help, see our how to choose a hay feeder for goats.

What this guide does not cover

This guide does not cover hay nets, grain-only feeders or mineral feeders, which are separate tools. It does not cover feed pans or water buckets. For nets, see our hay feeder vs hay net.

FAQs from goat keepers

Which is better for goats, a hay rack or a hay feeder?

For free-choice hay, a rack: the Scenic Road holds 1/3 of a bale and the Lazaluking holds 67 gallons. For measured rations and grain, a feeder: the YXJSTO is a 2-in-1 hay and grain unit with a 15 gallon capacity.

How much hay do these hold?

The Scenic Road rack holds 1/3 of a bale, the Lazaluking holds 67 gallons, and the BUYYAH holds 24 gallons per rack. The YXJSTO feeder holds 15 gallons.

Do these mount on the wall?

The Scenic Road, Lazaluking and BUYYAH are all wall-mounted, per their listings. The YXJSTO hangs with a double L-hook at adjustable distance.

Which listings state a warranty?

The Lazaluking states 1 year, the BUYYAH states 2 year manufacture, and the YXJSTO states 2. The Harhana states 120 days and the RAYFARMO states 3 months. The others state no concrete term.

What is the difference between a hay feeder and a hay net?

A feeder is a rigid unit with a mesh or tray, while a net is a flexible bag that slows eating further. For the full comparison, see our hay feeder vs hay net.

More from the barn

See every hay feeder guide and all feeding and water guides.

More picks: hay feeders for goats, hay feeders for baby goats, goat feeders with hay rack and hay net vs hay rack.