Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Rubber vs Plastic Water Bucket: Which One Should You Buy?

Four water buckets compared by material, capacity, freeze resistance and handles, to pick between rubber and plastic for goats.

Rubber vs Plastic Water Bucket: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1API 742G Bucket Water HeaterAPI 742G Bucket Water Heater9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Little Giant® Rubber PailLittle Giant® Rubber PailView on Amazon
  3. 34 Pack Rubber Feed Pan4 Pack Rubber Feed PanView on Amazon
  4. 4Little Giant® Flat Rubber BucketLittle Giant® Flat Rubber BucketView on Amazon
  5. 5Little Giant Flat Rubber Bucket Rubber Flat Back BucketLittle Giant Flat Rubber Bucket Rubber Flat Back BucketView on Amazon
  6. 62 Pcs Rubber Feeder Bucket2 Pcs Rubber Feeder BucketView on Amazon
  7. 7Farm Innovators FB-15R Heated Rubber BucketFarm Innovators FB-15R Heated Rubber BucketView on Amazon

Rubber wins in freezing weather because it flexes instead of cracking; plastic wins for light daily carrying, easy measuring and collapsible storage. In this rubber vs plastic water bucket guide we compared four listings: three plastic buckets and one rubber pail, using only what each listing publishes.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Rubber vs plastic water bucket: the short answer

Pick rubber if your buckets live outside through winter: the Little Giant listing calls its corded rubber pail freeze-proof, crack-proof and crush-proof. Pick plastic if you want light weight, molded measuring marks or a bucket that folds flat: the Rubbermaid, BIDFUL and Tubtrugs listings are all plastic. None of the four listings states a warranty term.

Four buckets compared

The Rubbermaid Commercial Brute is a 10-quart (2.5-gallon) heavy-duty plastic bucket with molded-in graduations, a pouring spout and a corrosion-resistant bail with a plastic grip. The BIDFUL is a 5-gallon collapsible PVC canvas bucket with dual reinforced handles and a drainage ring for pouring. The Tubtrugs SP26GBK is a 6.8-gallon flexible plastic bucket with comfort grip handles, reinforced ribbing and non-toxic, toy-safe material. The Little Giant is an 8-quart (2-gallon) corded rubber pail with a pouring lip and a heavy-duty steel handle.

Reading capacity against your herd

Capacities here run 2 gallons to 6.8 gallons. The Little Giant holds 8 quarts (2 gallons) and the Rubbermaid holds 10 quarts (2.5 gallons), so both suit a small pen or a kid group. The BIDFUL holds 5 gallons and the Tubtrugs holds 26 liters (6.8 gallons), so both suit a larger pen or fewer refills. Match the bucket to the number of animals drinking from it.

Materials: rubber or plastic

The Little Giant is the only rubber bucket here: the listing states a corded rubber body that is freeze-proof, crack-proof and crush-proof, which suits outdoor winter use. The plastic three use high density polyethylene (Rubbermaid), PVC canvas (BIDFUL) and flexible recycled plastic (Tubtrugs). The Tubtrugs listing states 100 percent recycled construction with non-toxic, toy-safe material. The BIDFUL folds flat for storage, which the rigid three cannot do.

Handles, spouts and pouring

The Rubbermaid has a corrosion-resistant bail with a comfortable plastic grip and a spout for pouring. The Little Giant has a heavy-duty steel handle with a rugged eyelet and a pouring lip. The Tubtrugs has 2 comfort grip handles and flexible sides. The BIDFUL has dual reinforced handles and a drainage ring. If you carry water far, the grip and handle style matter as much as the capacity.

Read the listing twice

The Little Giant spec table lists capacity as 3 gallons while the title and bullets say 8 quarts (2 gallons); the title and bullets take precedence, so treat it as a 2-gallon pail. The Rubbermaid spec table lists unit count as 12 while the number of items is 1, so treat it as a single bucket. The BIDFUL lists 20 liters and 5 gallons for the same bucket, which match.

Cold mornings and summer heat

Winter is where the two materials split. The Little Giant listing states its rubber body is freeze-proof, crack-proof and crush-proof, so it suits buckets left outside overnight. The three plastic listings state no freeze rating: the BIDFUL instead warns to avoid heat and sharp objects to protect its folding integrity, and its PVC canvas is built for sun and mud rather than ice. If your buckets stay out through freezing nights, rubber is the safer material; if they come inside or you live where it rarely freezes, plastic is fine.

Weight matters on the walk back from the tap. The Tubtrugs weighs 1.4 pounds empty, the Rubbermaid 1.1 pounds and the BIDFUL only 250 grams, so the collapsible bucket is the lightest carry of the four. The Little Giant is 2.8 pounds empty, the heaviest here, but its steel handle and pouring lip make the carry and pour easier. A full 5-gallon bucket is heavy whatever it is made of, so the 2-gallon and 2.5-gallon sizes suit anyone who refills often.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers buckets only, not heated buckets, automatic waterers or trough heaters. For winter water that stays liquid, see a heated option. For mounting or plumbing, follow the listing’s instructions.

FAQs from goat keepers

Which bucket is best for freezing weather?

The Little Giant listing calls its rubber pail freeze-proof, crack-proof and crush-proof; the plastic listings state no freeze rating.

Which holds the most water?

The Tubtrugs lists 26 liters (6.8 gallons), the most here, followed by the BIDFUL at 5 gallons.

Which bucket folds flat?

The BIDFUL collapsible bucket folds to a slim profile for storage; the other three are rigid.

Do any state a warranty?

No: the Little Giant listing has a warranty description field with no stated term, and the other three state none.

More from the barn

See every feed pan guide and all goat feeding guides.

More picks: goat feed pans and goat feeding guides.