
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Fortex CR-8509.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Hydralis 6-Pack Trough9.6/10View on Amazon - 3
Geelin 4-Pack Trough9.6/10View on Amazon - 4
GINDOOR 4-Pack Pan9.5/10View on Amazon
The rubber vs plastic water trough question comes up the first morning the water is frozen solid and the trough has to take a beating. Both sides hold water for goats; the difference is whether the trough flexes, bounces back and survives being dropped, as the rubber Fortex and GINDOOR listings claim, or whether it comes in big rigid multi-packs with stated non-toxic or bite-resistant plastic, as the Hydralis and Geelin listings claim. We compared these four listings on capacity, pack size, cold-weather claims, placement options and the gaps each page leaves, using only what each Amazon listing publishes.
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Quick verdict: choose the rubber side if the trough will see freezing mornings and rough handling, as the Fortex example shows with its 15 gallons, crack and crush resistance and flexibility to low temperatures. Choose the plastic side if you need to water several pens at once, as the Hydralis 6-pack of 12-gallon troughs and the Geelin 4-pack of 4.5-gallon troughs with hanging holes show. The two sides also sit in different pack sizes, so read this as a comparison of materials first and of individual listings second.
Two examples
| # | Product | GoatGear Score | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Fortex CR-850 | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 | Hydralis 6-Pack Trough | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 | Geelin 4-Pack Trough | 9.6/10 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 | GINDOOR 4-Pack Pan | 9.5/10 | Buy on Amazon |

Fortex CR-850
A 15-gallon rubber tub with fiber reinforcement and crack and crush resistance, listed as flexible to low temperatures.
Pros
- 15 gallon capacity is the largest single tub here
- Real rubber with fiber reinforcement, per the listing
- Crack and crush resistant, and bounces back to shape immediately
- Flexible to low temperatures, per the listing
Cons
- The warranty field reads only Warranty, with no term stated
- The title tacks on ceramic tile soaking and feeding salt, uses the listing never explains

Hydralis 6-Pack Trough
A 6-pack of 12-gallon plastic troughs stated to resist extreme cold, heat and animal bites.
Pros
- 12 gallons per trough is the largest plastic capacity here
- Six troughs in the pack cover multiple pens or a large herd
- Sturdy plastic stated to resist extreme cold, heat and animal bites
- Safe, reliable plastic that does not harm livestock, even in extreme heat
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- The after-sales bullet mentions a brooding box for baby chicks, a copy-paste error from another listing
- The 24.45 lb figure describes the package, with no per-trough weight stated
- The bullets give 38.6 x 11.8 x 7.1 in while the product details give 38.9 x 11.8 x 7.1 in

Geelin 4-Pack Trough
A 4-pack of 4.5-gallon tempered plastic troughs with a hole design for hanging or ground placement.
Pros
- Non-toxic plastic is stated, safe and harmless to all animals
- Tempered PP stated to endure harsh conditions without cracking or wear
- Resistant to chewing and capable of withstanding sun and freezing temperatures
- Hole design lets each trough sit on the ground or hang
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- 4.5 gallons per trough is smaller than the Hydralis 12 gallons
- The listing notes that plastic is not as elastic as rubber

GINDOOR 4-Pack Pan
A 4-pack of rubber pans, two 2-gallon and two 1-gallon, with thickened walls that flex and stack.
Pros
- Two sizes in one set: two 2-gallon and two 1-gallon pans
- Thickened barrel walls, flexible and stackable for storage
- Withstands low temperatures, per the listing
- Deep enough to prevent spillovers, per the listing
Cons
- No warranty term is stated
- The listing warns the pans may smell on arrival and advises ventilated storage for a few days
- Smallest capacities here at 2 and 1 gallons
- The color field reads Black-4Quart+8Quart, which is awkward but consistent with the sizes
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Also worth comparing
Sadnyy 4 Pcs Rubber Feed PanCheck price on Amazon
3 Pcs Rubber Feed PanCheck price on Amazon
6Pcs Rubber Feed PanCheck price on Amazon
Farm Innovators FB-15R Heated Rubber BucketCheck price on Amazon
Farm Innovators FB-15R Heated Flat-Back Rubber BucketCheck price on Amazon
Rubber vs plastic water trough: side by side
| Trough | Side | Capacity | Pack | Dimensions | Weight | Amazon |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fortex CR-850 | Rubber | 15 gallons | 1 | 25.5 x 25.5 x 9.75 in | 10.9 lb | View on Amazon |
| Hydralis 6-Pack Trough | Plastic | 12 gallons each | 6 | 38.6 x 11.8 x 7.1 in | Not stated | View on Amazon |
| Geelin 4-Pack Trough | Plastic | 4.5 gallons each | 4 | 22.83 x 11.81 x 4.72 in | 6.17 lb | View on Amazon |
| GINDOOR 4-Pack Pan | Rubber | 2 x 2 gallon, 2 x 1 gallon | 4 | 14.52 x 4.52 in, 10.63 x 4.1 in | Not stated | View on Amazon |
These are maker ratings taken from the goat gear listings on 20 October 2026, not our own measurements.
Capacity and pack size
Capacity decides how often you haul the hose. The Fortex is a single 15-gallon tub, the largest single vessel here. The Hydralis pack holds six 12-gallon troughs, the Geelin pack holds four 4.5-gallon troughs, and the GINDOOR set holds two 2-gallon and two 1-gallon pans. One big tub means fewer fill trips for a main pen; a pack of smaller troughs means each pen or each kid group gets its own. Match the layout to the herd, not the other way around.
Material and cold-weather claims
Rubber’s case is flexibility. The Fortex listing claims real rubber with fiber reinforcement that is crack and crush resistant, flexible to low temperatures and bounces back to shape immediately. The GINDOOR listing claims thickened rubber walls that flex under compression and withstand low temperatures. Plastic’s case is rigidity plus stated durability: the Geelin listing claims tempered PP that endures harsh conditions without cracking, resists chewing, and withstands sun exposure and freezing temperatures, while noting that plastic is not as elastic as rubber. The Hydralis listing claims sturdy plastic that resists extreme cold, heat and animal bites. For winter water duty beyond the trough itself, see our best heated water bucket for goats picks.
Size, weight and placement
The Fortex measures 25.5 by 25.5 by 9.75 inches at 10.9 pounds, a square tub that sits wherever it is put. The Hydralis troughs run 38.6 by 11.8 by 7.1 inches each, long and low for a fence line. The Geelin troughs run about 22.83 by 11.81 by 4.72 inches at 6.17 pounds, and their hole design lets them hang on a fence or sit on the ground. The GINDOOR pans are the smallest at 14.52 by 4.52 and 10.63 by 4.1 inches, and they stack for storage. A trough that holds its level matters as much as its gallons; pair a large trough with a water trough float valve for small troughs and the water refills itself.
Listing gaps to check
The Fortex warranty field reads only Warranty, with no term in years or months, and none of the other three listings state a warranty term at all, so every unit scores zero on warranty. The gaps go further: the Fortex spec table calls the tub a bucket and lists a rubber handle that the title never describes; the GINDOOR listing warns of an odor on arrival; the Hydralis after-sales bullet mentions a brooding box for baby chicks; and the Geelin bullet dimensions disagree with its spec table. If any of those points decides your purchase, ask the seller before you order.
Which should you choose?
Choose a rubber water trough if the trough will freeze, get dropped and get kicked, and you want it to flex back into shape, as the Fortex CR-850 shows with its 15 gallons and crack and crush resistance, or the GINDOOR 4-pack shows with its stackable pans for kids and small groups.
Choose a plastic water trough if you want to set up several pens at once from one order, as the Hydralis 6-pack of 12-gallon troughs shows, or you want a trough that can hang on the fence, as the Geelin 4-pack shows with its stated non-toxic plastic and hanging holes.
Whichever you pick, rinse a new trough before the first fill; the GINDOOR listing advises ventilated storage for a few days because of the new-rubber odor.
Around the Barn
- Scrub troughs regularly; algae grows quickest in the sunniest corner of the pen.
- Stack the GINDOOR pans or nest spares out of the weather when the herd is on pasture.
- Check hanging troughs like the Geelin for wear at the hanging holes each season.
- Dump and refill rather than topping off, so the water stays fresh.
FAQs from goat keepers
Is rubber or plastic better for freezing weather?
Both sides make cold claims. The Fortex states flexibility to low temperatures, the GINDOOR states it withstands low temperatures, the Geelin states it withstands freezing temperatures, and the Hydralis states it resists extreme cold. For heated options, see our heated water bucket picks.
Which trough holds the most water?
The Fortex holds 15 gallons in a single tub. The Hydralis holds 12 gallons per trough, the Geelin 4.5 gallons per trough, and the GINDOOR pans hold 2 and 1 gallons.
Which listings come in packs?
The Hydralis comes as a 6-pack, the Geelin and GINDOOR as 4-packs, and the Fortex as a single tub.
Do any of these state a warranty term?
No. The Fortex warranty field reads only Warranty with no term, and the other three listings state no warranty at all.
Are the plastic troughs stated non-toxic?
The Geelin listing states non-toxic plastic, safe and harmless to all animals. The Hydralis listing states safe, reliable plastic that does not harm livestock, even in extreme heat.
Behind the Farm Score
| Product | GoatGear Score | Perf. /35 | Build /25 | Value /25 | Safety /10 | Warranty /5 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fortex CR-850 | 9.6 | 30 | 22 | 20 | 7 | 0 |
| Hydralis 6-Pack Trough | 9.6 | 30 | 21 | 20 | 7 | 0 |
| Geelin 4-Pack Trough | 9.6 | 29 | 20 | 20 | 7 | 0 |
| GINDOOR 4-Pack Pan | 9.5 | 28 | 20 | 20 | 7 | 0 |
A score of 9.2 marks the weakest point total on our scale and 9.8 the strongest; totals in between are placed proportionally.
The GoatGear Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For water troughs, safety points need stated safety-relevant features such as crack resistance, low-temperature flexibility or non-toxic materials; all four listings state at least one of these. No listing states a warranty term, so all four score zero on warranty. The Fortex leads on single-tub capacity and stated cold flexibility, and loses points for the thin warranty field and the spec table errors. The Hydralis scores well on pack size and per-trough capacity and loses points for the copy-paste after-sales bullet. How we pick explains the weights.
More from the barn
See every water trough guide and all feeding and water guides.
More picks: stock tanks for goats, water trough covers for winter, automatic waterer versus stock tank.
