Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Plastic vs Steel Water Trough: Which One Should You Buy?

Plastic vs steel water trough, compared on two 12-gallon plastic troughs and two stainless steel bowls: capacity, size, build and which goat keeper each suits.

Top picks

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

How we score

Plastic vs Steel Water Trough: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1GINDOOR 39-Inch Trough 5-PackGINDOOR 39-Inch Trough 5-Pack9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Lonepetu 5-Gallon Steel BowlLonepetu 5-Gallon Steel Bowl9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3GINDOOR 18-Quart 5-PackGINDOOR 18-Quart 5-Pack9.5/10View on Amazon
  4. 4YUEPET 3-Gallon Steel BowlYUEPET 3-Gallon Steel Bowl9.5/10View on Amazon

The morning round ends at the water trough, and plastic vs steel water trough is the choice that decides how often you haul water and how long the trough lasts. We compared plastic troughs and steel bowls on capacity, size, build and fit, using only what the makers publish. The plastic examples hold more water, while the steel examples are smaller bowls built for dogs, so the honest answer depends on the animals you water.

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Quick verdict: choose plastic if you water a herd and want the most water per trough, as the GINDOOR examples show at 12 gallons and 18 quarts. Choose steel if you water a small group of animals and want a smooth bowl that wipes clean, as the Lonepetu and YUEPET examples show at 5 gallons and 3 gallons. The steel examples here are dog bowls, not full-size livestock troughs, so read this as a comparison of materials first.

The gear we picked

GINDOOR 39-Inch Trough 5-Pack

GINDOOR 39-Inch Trough 5-Pack

GINDOOR9.6/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 5-pack of 39-inch plastic troughs, each holding 12 gallons, with fence tie holes and reinforced walls for farm use.

Pros

  • Each trough holds 12 gallons, or 48 quarts, for feed or water
  • Room for sheep, horses, pigs, goats or cattle to drink at the same time
  • Fence tie holes around the rim take wire or zip ties to hold the trough still
  • Reinforced walls and a thickened base resist cracking, crushing and tipping

Cons

  • At 38.58 inches long it needs a long flat spot in the pen
  • No lid or cover is included, so the water stays open to hay and dirt
  • A 5-pack suits a larger herd, and a keeper with a small group ends up storing spares
  • No warranty term is stated
Lonepetu 5-Gallon Steel Bowl

Lonepetu 5-Gallon Steel Bowl

Lonepetu9.6/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 5-gallon stainless steel bowl with a wide rectangular opening, rounded corners and a dishwasher-safe finish.

Pros

  • Holds 5 gallons, enough food or water for a large dog for a day
  • Food-grade stainless steel with a mirror-polished finish
  • Thicker than a normal dog bowl, so dogs are less likely to kick it over
  • Dishwasher-safe with a smooth inner surface that wipes clean

Cons

  • At 5 gallons it holds less water than the 12-gallon plastic troughs
  • Sized as a dog bowl, so it suits a small group of animals rather than a herd
  • No handle is listed, so a full bowl is awkward to carry
  • The 17.7 x 13.8 inch footprint needs a flat, level spot
GINDOOR 18-Quart 5-Pack

GINDOOR 18-Quart 5-Pack

GINDOOR9.5/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 5-pack of stackable plastic troughs in food-grade polyethylene, sized at 18 quarts with a 22.83-inch length.

Pros

  • Food-grade polyethylene with no harmful chemicals and no sharp edges
  • Stackable design nests the troughs for compact storage
  • PP construction stands up to summer sun and winter frost, per the maker
  • Five troughs in the box cover water, feed and mineral use

Cons

  • At 18 quarts it is the smallest plastic trough here
  • The 4.72-inch depth holds a shallow layer of water
  • No fence tie holes, so it cannot be fixed to a fence the way the 39-inch example can
  • The 22.83-inch length suits small animals and small pens, not a large herd drinking at once
YUEPET 3-Gallon Steel Bowl

YUEPET 3-Gallon Steel Bowl

YUEPET9.5/10 GoatGear Score
i
The GoatGear Score runs from 0 to 10 and weighs performance (35%), build (25%), value (25%), safety (10%, where it applies) and warranty (5%), using only what the manufacturer and the listing publish. How we pick ›

A 3-gallon stainless steel bowl with rounded corners, raised edges and a smooth surface that wipes clean.

Pros

  • Holds 3 gallons for large dogs or more than one dog at a time
  • Stainless steel, durable and rust-proof, per the maker
  • Raised edges keep food and water from spilling out
  • Smooth, non-stick surface wipes clean with a damp rag

Cons

  • At 3 gallons it holds the least water here
  • The 14.2 x 10.6 inch size suits a kennel or a pen corner, not a herd
  • The 5.9-inch depth leaves little room before water spills
  • No warranty term is stated

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Also worth comparing

Plastic vs steel water trough: side by side

Trough GoatGear Score Side Capacity Size Material Pack Amazon
GINDOOR 39-Inch Trough 5-Pack 9.6/10 Plastic 12 gallon 38.58 x 11.81 x 7.09 inches Polyethylene 5-pack View on Amazon
Lonepetu 5-Gallon Steel Bowl 9.6/10 Steel 5 gallon 17.7 x 13.8 x 6 inches Stainless steel 1 View on Amazon
GINDOOR 18-Quart 5-Pack 9.5/10 Plastic 18 quart 22.83 x 12.59 x 4.72 inches Polyethylene 5-pack View on Amazon
YUEPET 3-Gallon Steel Bowl 9.5/10 Steel 3 gallon 14.2 x 10.6 x 5.9 inches Stainless steel 1 View on Amazon

Every spec repeats the brand’s rating from its listing (collected on 20 November 2026).

How each side holds water

Capacity is where the sides part ways. The 39-inch GINDOOR plastic trough holds 12 gallons, or 48 quarts, while the 18-quart GINDOOR example holds 18 quarts. The Lonepetu steel bowl holds 5 gallons, and the YUEPET steel bowl holds 3 gallons. The plastic examples are built as livestock troughs for sheep, horses, pigs, goats and cattle, while the steel examples are built as dog bowls for large dogs and more than one dog at a time, so the capacity gap follows the animals each maker names.

Build and material

Plastic here means polyethylene. Both GINDOOR examples are made from food-grade polyethylene, and the maker states no harmful chemicals and no toxin leaching, even in direct sunlight or high heat. The 39-inch example adds reinforced walls and a thickened base that resist cracking, crushing or tipping when animals step on, kick or lean against it.

Steel here means stainless steel. The Lonepetu bowl is food-grade stainless steel with a mirror-polished finish, and the maker states it is thicker than a normal dog bowl. The YUEPET bowl is stainless steel that the maker calls durable and rust-proof. Both steel bowls have rounded corners, and the YUEPET example adds raised edges that keep food and water from spilling out. For another material, see our galvanized vs plastic water trough comparison.

Size and the box

The plastic troughs are the long ones. The 39-inch GINDOOR example measures 38.58 x 11.81 x 7.09 inches, and the 18-quart example measures 22.83 x 12.59 x 4.72 inches. The steel bowls are smaller: the Lonepetu example measures 17.7 x 13.8 x 6 inches, with an internal size of 16.3 x 12.4 x 6 inches, and the YUEPET example measures 14.2 x 10.6 x 5.9 inches. Both plastic sets come as a 5-pack, so one box covers more than one pen, while each steel bowl comes on its own.

Warranty and listing gaps to check

None of the examples here states a warranty term, so none earns warranty points in the score. The gaps go further: the 18-quart GINDOOR example gives two capacities and two lengths, and the steel examples state no way to fix them to a fence. If any of those points decides your purchase, ask the seller before you order.

Which should you choose?

Choose plastic if you water a herd and want the most water per trough, as the GINDOOR examples show at 12 gallons and 18 quarts. A 5-pack covers more than one pen, and the 39-inch example ties to the fence. See our best water trough for cattle picks for more plastic options.

Choose steel if you water a small group of animals and want a smooth bowl that wipes clean and rinses out, as the Lonepetu and YUEPET examples show at 5 gallons and 3 gallons. Steel suits a kennel, a pen corner or a milking stand where a small bowl is enough. If you want water on tap instead, read our automatic waterer vs water trough comparison first.

Whichever you pick, match the trough to the animals you water, and check the stated capacity before you order.

Around the Barn

  • Tie the 39-inch trough to the fence with wire or zip ties through the rim holes so it stays put at feeding time.
  • Rinse a steel bowl with water or wipe it with a damp rag; the Lonepetu example is dishwasher-safe.
  • Stack the plastic troughs when the herd moves, and keep the spares in the barn.
  • Set the trough where the animals can reach it without crowding, and check the water each morning before turnout.

FAQs from goat keepers

Which holds more water, plastic or steel?

The plastic examples hold more. The 39-inch GINDOOR trough holds 12 gallons, and the 18-quart GINDOOR example holds 18 quarts, while the Lonepetu steel bowl holds 5 gallons and the YUEPET steel bowl holds 3 gallons.

Do plastic water troughs leach chemicals?

The maker states the GINDOOR troughs are food-grade polyethylene with no harmful chemicals and no toxin leaching, even in direct sunlight or high heat. Rinse a new trough before the animals drink from it.

Are steel water troughs hard to clean?

No. The Lonepetu bowl has a smooth inner surface and is dishwasher-safe, and the YUEPET bowl has a smooth, non-stick surface that wipes clean with a damp rag. Rounded corners on both bowls leave nowhere for feed to catch.

Can I tie a plastic trough to a fence?

Yes, the 39-inch GINDOOR example has small holes around the rim for wire rope or zip ties, so you can fix it to a fence, a pen or a post. The 18-quart example states no fence holes, so it rests loose in the pen.

How many troughs come in a pack?

The GINDOOR sets come as a 5-pack, with 5 troughs in the box. Each steel bowl ships in its own box, so order as many as the pens need.

GINDOOR 39-Inch Trough 5-Pack
Still deciding? Our top pickGINDOOR 39-Inch Trough 5-Pack
Check price on Amazon

Behind the Farm Score

Product GoatGear Score Perf. /35 Build /25 Value /25 Safety /10 Warranty /5
GINDOOR 39-Inch Trough 5-Pack 9.6 30 21 21 7 0
Lonepetu 5-Gallon Steel Bowl 9.6 29 21 20 7 0
GINDOOR 18-Quart 5-Pack 9.5 28 20 20 7 0
YUEPET 3-Gallon Steel Bowl 9.5 27 20 19 5 0

We translate each weighted point total onto the 9.2 through 9.8 band; ranks never flip, because the conversion is linear.

The GoatGear Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For water troughs, safety points need stated food-safe material or safe edges; the examples here earn safety points for food-grade polyethylene, food-grade stainless steel and rounded corners, while none states a warranty term, so all score zero on warranty. The 39-inch GINDOOR example leads on capacity and fence fittings, and the steel bowls score well on build and cleaning but lose points for small capacity.

More from the barn

See every water troughs guide and all feeding and water guides.

More picks: water troughs for cattle, feed pans for goats, heated water buckets for goats and water trough covers for winter.