
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Goovilla Large Feed Trough9.5/10View on Amazon - 2
ATERET 5 Gallon Black Metal Bucket & Lever Lock Pail LidView on Amazon - 3
Little Giant® Flat Back Plastic Animal Feed BucketView on Amazon - 4
Little Giant Galvanized Dairy PailView on Amazon - 5
Little Giant Plastic Animal Feed BucketView on Amazon - 6
Plastic Animal Feed BucketView on Amazon
A goat empties a bucket, noses it across the pen and leaves it upside down by the gate, so the bucket filled at feeding time gets more abuse than most barn gear. This guide covers metal vs plastic feed bucket choices by comparing the listings for steel pails and a plastic feed bucket: what each listing states about capacity, size, handles and lids, and where those listings contradict themselves. Every number below comes from a listing, and a gap in a listing is called out rather than filled in.
Also worth comparing
ATERET 5 Gallon Black Metal Bucket & Lever Lock Pail LidCheck price on Amazon
Little Giant® Flat Back Plastic Animal Feed BucketCheck price on Amazon
Little Giant Galvanized Dairy PailCheck price on Amazon
Little Giant Plastic Animal Feed BucketCheck price on Amazon
Plastic Animal Feed BucketCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Metal vs plastic feed bucket: the short answer
For a bucket that hangs on a fence or wall, the flat-back plastic bucket is the only listing shaped for hanging, with a flat back and a wire bail handle with a notch. For feed kept under a lid, the 5 gallon steel pail is the only listing that includes a lever lock lid. For several buckets at once, the galvanized pails sold as a 4 pack are the only listing sold as a pack. The remaining pail is presented by its listing as a drink bucket for parties, so it fits feeding only as a spare.
If you want pans rather than buckets, our best feed pan for goats roundup scores pans on the same points.
The buckets compared
Ranked by how well each listing fits daily feeding, the buckets line up in this order: the flat-back plastic feed bucket, the 5 gallon steel pail with a lid, the 4 pack of galvanized pails, and the party pail.
| Bucket | Material | Stated capacity | Handle and hanging |
|---|---|---|---|
| Little Giant Flat Back Plastic Feed Bucket | Polyethylene resin | 8 quarts | Wire bail handle with notch for hanging |
| ATERET 5 Gallon Black Metal Bucket | Steel with lever lock lid | 5 gallons | Metal handle |
| OBTANIM Galvanized Metal Buckets, 4 Pack | Galvanized metal | 8 quarts each | Metal handle for hanging and carrying |
| BARsics Galvanized Pail | Galvanized steel, 0.28mm | 5 quarts | Not stated |
Little Giant Flat Back Plastic Feed Bucket. The listing states a flat-back plastic bucket made of polyethylene resin that is impact resistant, protects against warpage and helps prevent stress cracks, with stacking ribs so pails come apart easier when stacked. It lists a strong wire bail handle with a notch for hanging in versatile locations. Note the capacity conflict: the title says 8 quarts while the bullets say the bucket holds 20 quarts (5 gallons).
ATERET 5 Gallon Black Metal Bucket. The listing states a 5 gallon steel pail with a lever lock lid, a curling top edge that prevents leakage and deformation during handling, and triple seam construction. The metal handle is described as high strength for carrying heavy loads. It is the only listing here that pairs a bucket with a lid.
OBTANIM Galvanized Metal Buckets, 4 Pack. The listing states galvanized metal pails that are rust proof and leak proof, sold as a 4 pack, with a sturdy metal handle suitable for hanging and carrying. The uses it lists are broad, from drinks and ice to plants and party favors, so it is a general purpose pail rather than a bucket written for feeding.
BARsics Galvanized Pail. The listing states a 5 quart galvanized pail made of 0.28mm steel, with food-grade construction, presented as a bucket for serving chilled drinks that holds up to 6 bottles plus ice. It is the smallest stated capacity here, and no handle is stated, so it ranks as a spare rather than a daily feeding bucket.
Metal buckets: what the listings state
Three of the four listings are metal. The ATERET pail is a 5 gallon steel bucket with a lever lock lid and a metal handle, built for heavy-duty use outdoors and around the house. The OBTANIM pails are galvanized metal, described as rust proof and leak proof with a long service life, and they arrive as a 4 pack. The BARsics pail is galvanized steel of 0.28mm, described as sturdy for repeated use, with food-grade construction for serving family and guests.
Metal brings weight and rigidity, and the listings lean on that: the ATERET listing points to its curled top edge and seam construction, while the OBTANIM listing points to galvanized metal that is not easily cracked or damaged. None of the metal listings states a warranty term, so no warranty claim is made for them here.
Plastic buckets: what the listing states
The single plastic listing is the Little Giant flat-back bucket, made of polyethylene resin. Its flat back is shaped for hanging, its stacking ribs keep stacked pails from sticking together, and its wire bail handle has a notch for hanging. The listing also says these feeding buckets are available in 13 other colors and sizes, such as 2 gallon, 5 gallon and 5.5 gallon, so the 8 quart size in the title is one size among several the maker lists.
Plastic trades rigidity for a shape made for the job: the flat back sits against a fence or wall instead of rolling, and the notch in the handle gives a hanging point. The listing describes the resin as impact resistant and as helping to prevent stress cracks, which matters for a bucket that gets knocked around a pen.
Capacity and size
Capacity is stated in two units across these listings, gallons and quarts, and makers measure it their own way, so compare the stated figures without converting between them. The ATERET pail states 5 gallons. The OBTANIM pails state 8 quarts each. The BARsics pail states 5 quarts. The Little Giant listing states 8 quarts in its title and 20 quarts (5 gallons) in its bullets, so treat its capacity as disputed and check the listing before ordering.
Size figures vary the same way. The ATERET bullets give D 11.69 inches outside by D 10.82 inches inside by H 13.39 inches, while its spec table gives 11.69 inches by 11.69 inches by 13.39 inches. The OBTANIM bullets give 10 by 7.9 by 8.7 inches, while its spec table gives 8.5 inches by 8.0 inches by 10.0 inches. The BARsics bullets give 9 inches wide by 7 inches high, while its spec table carries the same dimensions to many decimal places. Measure your pen and hanging spot against the larger figure in each case.
Handles, lids and hanging
Handles decide how a bucket is carried and whether it hangs. The Little Giant bucket has a wire bail handle with a notch for hanging, and its flat back suits hanging on a fence or wall. The OBTANIM pails have a sturdy metal handle suitable for hanging and carrying. The ATERET pail has a metal handle for carrying heavy loads, plus the lever lock lid that none of the others offers. The BARsics listing states no handle, which is one more reason it sits last for daily feeding.
A lid changes how a bucket is used: with a lid, a pail can hold feed between fillings and keep out bedding and rain, while an open bucket is for feed that goes out and gets eaten right away. Only the ATERET listing includes a lid, so if covered storage matters, that listing is the one to weigh against the hanging plastic bucket.
Read the listing twice
Bucket listings contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones needed to plan the purchase:
- ATERET: D 11.69 inches outside by D 10.82 inches inside by H 13.39 inches in the bullets, against 11.69 inches by 11.69 inches by 13.39 inches in the spec table.
- BARsics: 9 by 9 by 7 inches in the title, against longer decimal figures in the spec table.
- OBTANIM: 10 by 7.9 by 8.7 inches in the bullets, against 8.5 inches by 8.0 inches by 10.0 inches in the spec table.
- Little Giant: 8 quarts in the title, against 20 quarts (5 gallons) in the bullets.
When a listing disagrees with itself, plan around the figure that fits your pen worst, and confirm the size with the seller before ordering.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers bucket hardware only. It does not cover how much feed a goat needs, feed types or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.
FAQs from goat keepers
Which is better, a metal or a plastic feed bucket?
It depends on the job. A flat-back plastic bucket suits hanging on a fence or wall, a steel pail with a lever lock lid suits covered storage, and a galvanized pail sold as a 4 pack suits keeping several buckets on hand.
What size feed bucket suits goats?
Stated capacities here run from 5 quarts on the BARsics pail to 5 gallons on the ATERET pail, with the OBTANIM pails at 8 quarts each and the Little Giant listing disputed between 8 quarts in its title and 20 quarts in its bullets. Pick by the space on your fence or wall and the amount you fill at each feeding.
Do feed buckets come with lids?
Only one listing here includes a lid: the ATERET 5 gallon pail with a lever lock lid. The other listings state no lid, so plan on open buckets unless you buy the lidded pail.
Can a galvanized pail be used as a feed bucket?
It can hold feed, but neither galvanized listing here is written as a feed bucket. The OBTANIM listing presents its pails for drinks, ice, plants and storage, and the BARsics listing presents its pail for serving chilled drinks, so the flat-back plastic bucket is the listing written for feeding.
More from the barn
See every feed pan guide and all feeding and water guides.
More picks: best feed pans for goats, goat mineral feeders, heated water buckets and hay feeders for goats.
