Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Half Gallon vs Gallon Mason Jars: Which One Should You Buy?

Half gallon vs gallon mason jars for goat milk: how size, weight, lids and shelf fit differ, and which jar suits a daily milking routine.

Half Gallon vs Gallon Mason Jars: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Ball 64 oz Wide Mouth Mason JarsBall 64 oz Wide Mouth Mason Jars9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2kitchentoolz 64 oz Half Gallon Mason Jars with White Metalkitchentoolz 64 oz Half Gallon Mason Jars with White Metal9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 364 oz Mason Jars with Lids64 oz Mason Jars with Lids9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4kitchentoolz Half Gallon Glass Mason Jar Wide Mouth withkitchentoolz Half Gallon Glass Mason Jar Wide Mouth withView on Amazon
  5. 5Wide Mouth 64 ozWide Mouth 64 ozView on Amazon
  6. 6kitchentoolz 6 Pack of Half Gallon Mason Jarskitchentoolz 6 Pack of Half Gallon Mason JarsView on Amazon
  7. 7kitchentoolz Half Gallon Glass Large Mason Jars with Airtightkitchentoolz Half Gallon Glass Large Mason Jars with AirtightView on Amazon
  8. 8Ball Wide Mouth Half Gallon 64 Oz Jars with Lids and BandsBall Wide Mouth Half Gallon 64 Oz Jars with Lids and BandsView on Amazon
  9. 9kitchentoolz Half Gallon Mason Jar Wide Mouth with Airtightkitchentoolz Half Gallon Mason Jar Wide Mouth with AirtightView on Amazon

The half gallon vs gallon mason jars question shows up the first week the goats are in milk: how big should the jar be that catches the milk and stores it in the fridge. A half gallon jar holds 64 ounces, per every reference listing here; a gallon jar holds twice as much. The smaller jar is the easier daily jar for most herds, and the bigger jar only wins when the milk volume is large enough to justify the weight and the awkward pour.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Half gallon vs gallon mason jars: the short answer

Pick half-gallon jars when one or two does are in milk and the jars empty out before the next milking. Every reference listing here sizes the half gallon at 64 ounces, which matches a daily routine where jars get washed and refilled twice a day. Pick gallon jars when the milk volume outruns the fridge shelf space: fewer jars, fewer lids to wash, fewer trips. The trade is weight and handling: a full gallon jar is heavy, hard to pour from, and a chore to lift onto a high shelf. The listings also describe smaller options, such as the Ball regular mouth 32-ounce jar, which works for separating out a single milking or a smaller batch.

Size, height and what fits on the fridge shelf

The half-gallon reference jars list these dimensions:

Jar Stated capacity Dimensions Weight stated
Ball 64 oz wide mouth, pack of 4 64 ounces 4.5 by 4.5 by 9 inches 1.7 pounds, per the Ball 64 oz 2-pack
FyndraX 64 oz wide mouth 64 fluid ounces 4.2 by 3.3 by 9.2 inches Not stated
Qianfenie 64 oz, 2 pack 64 ounces 6.7 inches high by 5.7 inches wide Not stated
kitchentoolz 64 oz 64 ounces, 0.5 gallon 5.59 by 5.59 by 6.28 inches 11.86 pounds

Two practical points follow from these figures. First, most half-gallon jars stand about 9 inches tall, so they fit a standard fridge shelf; measure the shelf height before buying, because the 4.5 by 4.5 by 9 inch Ball figure is for one specific listing, not for all half-gallon jars. Second, no gallon-size jar appears in the reference listings, so no dimensions or weight figures are stated for gallon jars; the size comparison above is qualitative, not numeric. The mouth matters too: the Qianfenie lists an 11 cm (4.3 inch) opening that fits a hand, and the Folinstall lists a 4.7-inch opening that fits a standard measuring cup.

Reading capacity against the milking routine

Capacity figures from the listings: a half gallon jar holds 64 ounces; the Ball regular mouth jar holds 32 ounces; the Folinstall jar holds 64 ounces and, per its listing, holds an entire 2-pound bag of brown sugar. Use these figures to plan the routine. If each milking fills about one half-gallon jar, the jar count you need equals the number of milkings between washings, and two milkings a day means the jars turn over fast. Gallon jars make sense when the routine fills several half-gallon jars per milking: fewer jars, fewer lids. But a full gallon jar of milk is heavy and pours poorly, and once it is open the whole volume is exposed to the fridge air. Some keepers split the difference: gallon jars for storage and half-gallon or quart jars for daily use and sharing milk with family.

Lids and seals for daily milking

The lid is the part you handle most. The Ball listings include lids and bands with the jars, and the FyndraX lists a metal lid and band with an airtight seal. The kitchentoolz lists BPA-free screw-on metal lids that create an airtight seal. The Folinstall uses a glass lid with a removable silicone seal: seal in for airtight storage, seal out when air flow is wanted. The FEODSEW pitcher has a flip-top lid with an ergonomic handle and a silicone sealing ring that the listing calls leak-proof. Care claims differ by listing, so read the one you buy: the FyndraX glass is listed as safe for the refrigerator, freezer and dishwasher, while the Ball 64-ounce pack of 4 says hand wash only, and the FEODSEW lid should be hand washed. One heat warning is explicit: the FEODSEW listing says do not pour boiling hot water (50C/122F) directly into the jug, and the Qianfenie listing advises against sudden temperature changes.

Where the listings contradict themselves

Mason jar listings are messy, and the numbers sometimes fight. Examples from these listings:

  • Ball 64 oz pack of 4: the spec table says “Item Volume: 18 liters” and “Capacity: 4 pounds” against a 64-ounce title, and the package dimensions of 14.5 by 2 by 9.5 inches are odd for a four-pack of 64-ounce jars.
  • Ball 64 oz pack of 2: the bullets say “Includes 1 Jar of 64oz” while the title says a pack of 2.
  • Ball 32 oz pack of 2: the spec table says “Item Weight: 0.27 g”, a fraction of a gram, which cannot describe a quart jar.
  • Qianfenie 64 oz: the spec table says “Item Volume: 2350 ml” against a 64-ounce (64 fluid ounce) capacity.

Measure your shelf and trust the title and bullets over the spec table when the two disagree, and allow for the larger figure when ordering.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers jar hardware only: size, lids, dimensions and handling. It does not cover milk handling procedures, storage times or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about goat health and milk safety.

FAQs from goat keepers

Can I store goat milk in a half-gallon mason jar?

Yes, that is what the 64-ounce size suits. The Ball, FyndraX and kitchentoolz listings all include lids, and the FyndraX and kitchentoolz listings state airtight seals.

Can mason jars go in the dishwasher?

Some can. The FyndraX lists glass that is dishwasher safe, while the Ball 64-ounce pack of 4 says hand wash only. Check the listing for the jar you buy.

Can I pour warm milk into a cold jar?

Warm the jar first. The FEODSEW listing warns against pouring boiling hot water (50C/122F) directly into the jug, and the Qianfenie listing advises against sudden temperature changes.

Do the jars come with lids?

The Ball, FyndraX, Galssmagic and kitchentoolz listings include lids with the jars, and the FEODSEW pitcher includes its flip-top lid.

Which jar fits a fridge door shelf?

Measure before ordering. The Ball 64-ounce jar lists 4.5 by 4.5 by 9 inches and the FyndraX lists 4.2 by 3.3 by 9.2 inches, so height is the figure that usually decides it.

More from the barn

See every milk jars and bottles guide and all milking guides.

More picks: half gallon mason jars with lids, milk jar with spout, stainless vs plastic milk pail and kitchentoolz mason jar review.