
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
QVVCOOP Heat Lamp for Chickens9.6/10View on Amazon - 2
Fluker's Culinary Coop Infrared Heat Lamp9.3/10View on Amazon - 3
TORCHSTAR 3CCT LED Barn Light9.7/10View on Amazon
A cold snap finds the weak spot in the barn fast, and the heat mat vs heat lamp choice is about where the warmth comes from: a mat warms from below, and a lamp warms from above. This guide lays out the two heat sources and the four mats we compared here, with their stated power, temperature and size, so you can match the heat source to the space.
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Heat mat vs heat lamp: the short answer
Start with where the heat goes, then pick the source, then check power and temperature. A mat sits under the animal or the tray and warms from below. A lamp hangs above and shines heat down, and it gives light as well as heat. A self-warming mat needs no power at all, while an electric mat plugs in and holds a stated temperature. Once the source is settled, compare the stated wattage, the temperature range and whether the listing adds a thermostat, and read the listing twice for conflicting numbers.
If you would rather go straight to the products, our heat lamp vs barn heater comparison covers lamps against heaters.
Two heat sources compared
| Heat source | Example listing | Stated power | Plug |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-warming mat | Mora Pets Self Warming Cat Bed | No plug | Not needed |
| Self-warming mat | WanpeeGoo Self Warming Cat Bed | No plug | Not needed |
| Electric seedling mat | BN-LINK Seedling Heat Mat | 20W | 5.9 ft cord |
| Electric seedling mat, thermostat | BN-LINK Seedling Heat Mat with Thermostat | 20W | 5.9 ft cord |
| Heat lamp | No lamp listing here | Not stated | Not stated |
Self-warming mats
Self-warming mats need no power. The Mora Pets bed uses a carbon-infused cover that absorbs, holds and reflects body heat, and the WanpeeGoo bed uses a heat-reflective foil layer under a fleece surface. Both have a removable washable cover and a non-slip bottom, and both come in three sizes: the Mora Pets bed in 24 x 18, 29.1 x 18.9 and 35 x 23.6 in, and the WanpeeGoo bed in 15 x 19, 18 x 27 and 22 x 34 in. These mats suit a pet bed or a shelter corner where no outlet is nearby, and they give only the warmth the animal brings.
Electric seedling mats
Electric mats plug in and hold a stated warmth. Both BN-LINK mats are 10 x 20.75 in on 20W, ETL listed and IP67 waterproof, with a 5.9 ft cord. Both reach surface temperatures around 70 to 85°F, and the plain mat raises root-zone temperatures 10 to 20°F above ambient. The thermostat model adds a controller that adjusts from 40 to 108°F through a 3-button interface and LED display, with a 3.94 ft power cord and a 4.92 ft probe. These mats suit seed trays and terrariums; neither listing states a livestock use.
Heat lamps
A heat lamp hangs above the space and shines heat down, giving light as well as heat. No lamp listing is in this guide, so no lamp wattage or temperature is stated here. See the heat lamp vs barn heater comparison for lamps against heaters, and match the lamp to the fixture and the space before you buy.
Reading power and temperature
Power on these listings is given in watts, and temperature in degrees Fahrenheit. The two electric mats run on 20W, and the two self-warming mats need no power at all. Temperature is stated only for the electric mats: around 70 to 85°F on the surface, with the thermostat model adjustable from 40 to 108°F. None of these listings converts watts into a temperature for a room or a pen, so treat the stated figures as a way to rank mats against each other, not as a promise for a whole space.
Placement and where the mat goes
Placement decides whether the heat reaches the animal or the tray. A mat sits under the tray or the bed: the plain BN-LINK mat fits standard 1020 seed starter trays, and the self-warming beds suit a sofa, floor, carrier, crate or cat house. A lamp hangs above instead, so it needs a fixture and clearance the listings here do not describe. The BN-LINK mats carry an IP67 waterproof rating and can be wiped clean, while the self-warming beds have removable covers for washing.
Materials and cleaning
Material sets how the mat handles water and washing. The BN-LINK mats use flexible multi-layer PVC, wear-resistant, with an IP67 waterproof rating. The self-warming beds use a soft cover over a heat-reflective layer: the Mora Pets bed has a carbon-infused cover, and the WanpeeGoo bed has a heat-reflective foil layer under fleece. Both self-warming beds have a removable zippered cover that is machine washable, and the WanpeeGoo listing says to remove the aluminum foil insert before washing, as the insert must not be washed.
Read the listing twice
Heat mat listings often disagree with themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan the setup:
- BN-LINK thermostat: the dimensions given for the controller are 3.94 x 2.95 x 1.5 inches, against the 10 x 20.75 in mat in the title and bullets.
- Mora Pets: the listing names three sizes, 24 x 18, 29.1 x 18.9 and 35 x 23.6 in, while the dimensions it gives cover only the 24 x 18 in size.
- WanpeeGoo: the listing names three sizes, 15 x 19, 18 x 27 and 22 x 34 in, while the dimensions it gives cover only the 15 x 19 in size.
Measure the space before ordering. The listings describe warmth in words, so compare the stated sizes, power and temperature figures instead of the adjectives.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers heat sources as equipment only. It does not cover animal health, brooding temperatures or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about animal care and heating a barn.
FAQs from goat keepers
What is the difference between a heat mat and a heat lamp?
A mat warms from below and a lamp warms from above. The mats here sit under a tray or a bed, while a lamp hangs above and gives light as well as heat.
Do heat mats need electricity?
The electric mats here run on 20W with a 5.9 ft cord. The two self-warming beds need no plug or cord at all.
What temperature do seedling heat mats reach?
The BN-LINK mats reach surface temperatures around 70 to 85°F, and the thermostat model adjusts from 40 to 108°F.
Are seedling heat mats waterproof?
The BN-LINK mats state an IP67 waterproof rating and resist splashes and sprays, and they can be wiped clean.
Can I wash a self-warming cat bed?
Yes, both self-warming beds here have a removable zippered cover that is machine washable. The WanpeeGoo listing says to remove the aluminum foil insert before washing.
More from the barn
See the propane vs electric barn heater comparison and the barn cat house vs heated cat house comparison for more on heating a barn space.
More picks: browse barn cat house vs heated cat house, water trough heater vs insulation wrap and heated water hose vs heat tape.
