Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Propane vs Electric Barn Heater: Which One Should You Buy?

Propane vs electric barn heater, compared on 4 propane heater listings: heat output, coverage, safety shut-offs, tanks and who each one fits.

Propane vs Electric Barn Heater: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Buyplus Propane Heater 30Buyplus Propane Heater 30View on Amazon
  2. 2LAANPOLE 15000BTU Patio Heater for Outdoor UseLAANPOLE 15000BTU Patio Heater for Outdoor UseView on Amazon
  3. 3Mr. Heater 80Mr. Heater 80View on Amazon
  4. 4PAULINN Propane Heater Indoor Outdoor Patio Heaters 6000 toPAULINN Propane Heater Indoor Outdoor Patio Heaters 6000 toView on Amazon
  5. 5Avenger Portable Outdoor Propane Cabinet HeaterAvenger Portable Outdoor Propane Cabinet HeaterView on Amazon
  6. 6Mr Heater 125Mr Heater 125View on Amazon

A frozen water bucket at morning milking is when the propane vs electric barn heater question stops being theory. Propane wins where the barn has no power or the power goes out: the listings state that a propane heater needs no electricity and no cord, and keeps heating through an outage. Electric wins where a wired outlet is close at hand and no fuel tank is wanted. This guide compares propane heater listings, and judges the electric side on the points the propane listings state.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Propane vs electric barn heater: the short answer

Start with power, then pick the heater. If the barn has no outlet, or the power cuts out in winter storms, propane is the practical pick: it burns from a tank, needs no electricity and moves where the work is. If the barn has a wired outlet near the pens and the heater stays in one spot, electric is the simpler pick, with no tank to swap and no flame to watch. Once the power question is settled, compare the stated heat output, the coverage, the safety shut-offs and the tank size, and read the listing twice for conflicting numbers.

The listings below are all propane, ranked from the strongest output down to the smallest portable unit. For winter water as well as winter heat, see the best heated water bucket for goats guide.

The propane heaters, ranked

Heater Heat output Coverage Safety shut-off Tank
NEWBULIG 48,000 BTU Patio Heater 48,000 BTU 18-ft diameter 45° tip-over shut-off, flame-out protection Standard 20-lb propane tanks
Buyplus 30,000 BTU Tent Heater 30,000 BTU Up to 800 sq ft Tip-over switch, safety mesh guards Tanks not included
Ruasveltan 18,000 BTU Cabinet Heater 6,000 to 18,000 BTU Up to 450 square feet ODS, tip-over protection 20lb liquid propane cylinder
CAMPLUX 12,000 BTU Buddy Heater 12,000 BTU Not stated ODS, tip-over protection 1 lb and 20 lbs propane tanks

NEWBULIG 48,000 BTU patio heater

The strongest listing here. The NEWBULIG heater is an 87-inch tall freestanding patio heater at 48,000 BTU, with broad radiant heat reaching an 18-ft diameter within 1 minute, suitable for 4-8 people. It has a 304 stainless steel burner, one-touch ignition with an adjustable flame, rolling wheels and a side cutout for checking the tank position, plus ground anchors for wind resistance. It fits standard 20-lb propane tanks, with the tank excluded, and lists a 1 Year Manufacture warranty. At 33.0 pounds it is heavier than the CAMPLUX listing, so the wheels and anchors do the work of moving and holding it.

Buyplus 30,000 BTU tent heater

The Buyplus heater lists 30,000 BTU with 3 heating levels at 22,000, 26,000 and 30,000 BTU, and heat for up to 800 sq ft. Both heads rotate 30° for even heat distribution, and the listing describes heavy duty steel construction with safety mesh guards and a tip-over switch that shuts off the gas flow if the heater is knocked over. The listing states it is sold as the propane heater only, without propane cylinders and tanks. Dimensions are 17.32 inches by 7.48 inches by 13.0 inches, and no weight is stated.

Ruasveltan 18,000 BTU cabinet heater

The Ruasveltan heater lists a heat output range from 6,000 to 18,000 BTU across 3 heating modes, High, Medium and Low, with heat for up to 69 hours and rooms up to 450 square feet. It has a built-in piezoelectric ignition, a wireless design with a wide fixed stand, and dual safeguards: an automatic shut off for low oxygen, ODS, or unexpected tip-over, plus a windscreen on the front of the ceramic panel. It needs no electricity, runs on a 20lb liquid propane cylinder, and suits indoor and outdoor use, from garages and patios to camping. The listing also notes it might be misclassified as a non-returnable item, so check the return terms before ordering.

CAMPLUX 12,000 BTU buddy heater

A light portable unit. The CAMPLUX heater delivers 12,000 BTUs from a ceramic plate burner, with up to 6 hours of warmth, and works with both 1 lb and 20 lbs propane tanks, with gas and hose not included. It weighs 9.4 lbs in the bullets, has an easy-grip handle with a built-in LED light, a single control start knob with a piezo igniter, and rapid heating within 1 min. It shuts off automatically for low oxygen, ODS, or unexpected tip-over, and needs no assembly. The spec table lists the weight as 9.5 pounds, against 9.4 lbs in the bullets; the bullets win, and the gap is a listing error, not a real difference.

Heat output and coverage

Heat output on these listings runs from 48,000 BTU on the NEWBULIG down to 12,000 BTU on the CAMPLUX, with the Buyplus at 30,000 BTU and the Ruasveltan adjustable from 6,000 to 18,000 BTU. Coverage is stated in different units, so the figures do not line up directly: the NEWBULIG reaches an 18-ft diameter within 1 minute for 4-8 people, the Buyplus heats up to 800 sq ft, and the Ruasveltan heats rooms up to 450 square feet for up to 69 hours. The CAMPLUX states no coverage area, only up to 6 hours of warmth from the ceramic plate burner.

Read output and coverage as maker claims for the stated space, not as a promise for a whole barn. A tall open barn loses heat faster than a small closed tack room, and none of these listings states a barn size it covers. Match the stated coverage to the space you heat, and pick the larger output when the space is open or drafty.

Safety shut-offs to look for

Every listing here states a shut-off. The NEWBULIG lists a 45° anti-tilt shut-off and flame-out protection that cuts off the gas supply when the heater tips over or the flame goes out. The Buyplus lists a tip-over switch that shuts off the gas flow when the heater is knocked over, plus safety mesh guards to prevent scalding. The Ruasveltan and CAMPLUX listings both list an automatic shut off for low oxygen, ODS, or unexpected tip-over, which matters in enclosed areas.

Look for the shut-off that fits where the heater sits. A tall freestanding heater in a pen with goats needs tip-over protection and ground anchors, which the NEWBULIG lists, though the anchors are not for hard concrete surfaces. A heater used indoors needs the low-oxygen shut-off the Ruasveltan and CAMPLUX listings state. Wind matters outdoors too: the Ruasveltan lists a windscreen on the ceramic panel, and the NEWBULIG lists ground anchors for wind resistance.

Tanks, weight and moving it around

3 of the listings run on standard tanks. The NEWBULIG fits standard 20-lb propane tanks, with the tank excluded. The Ruasveltan runs on a 20lb liquid propane cylinder. The CAMPLUX works with both 1 lb and 20 lbs propane tanks, with gas and hose not included. The Buyplus is sold as the heater only, without propane cylinders and tanks, so the tank is a separate purchase on every listing here.

Weight and wheels decide how often the heater moves. The NEWBULIG weighs 33.0 pounds and lists rolling wheels and a side cutout for checking the tank position. The CAMPLUX weighs 9.4 lbs in the bullets and has an easy-grip handle with a built-in LED light for dark corners. The Ruasveltan describes a wireless design with a wide fixed stand and an ultra-thin shape for storage, and the Buyplus describes a portable design for camping, fishing, hunting, picnicking and hiking. No weight is stated for the Buyplus or the Ruasveltan, so compare those two on size and handles, not on pounds.

Read the listing twice

Heater listings contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan the install:

  • CAMPLUX: 9.4 lbs in the bullets against 9.5 pounds in the spec table.
  • CAMPLUX: dimensions stated to far more decimal places than any tape measure reads, and the bullets give no dimensions.
  • Ruasveltan: a weight stated to far more decimal places than any scale reads.
  • Buyplus: no weight is stated anywhere in the listing.

Measure the spot before ordering and allow for the larger figure. The Ruasveltan listing also notes the product might be misclassified as a non-returnable item, so confirm the return terms before ordering.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers heater hardware only: output, coverage, safety shut-offs, tanks and weight. It does not cover fuel storage, ventilation or any health question, and it does not cover how much heat a barn needs. All 4 listings compared here are propane; no electric heater listing was compared, so the electric side is judged on the points the propane listings state. Ask your local extension office about barn ventilation and heater placement.

FAQs from goat keepers

Which heater puts out the most heat?

The NEWBULIG listing states 48,000 BTU, the highest output here. The Buyplus lists 30,000 BTU, the Ruasveltan lists 6,000 to 18,000 BTU and the CAMPLUX lists 12,000 BTU.

How long will the Ruasveltan heater run?

The listing states heat for up to 69 hours, on a 20lb liquid propane cylinder.

Do any of these heaters need electricity?

The Ruasveltan listing states no electricity is required: it runs on a 20lb liquid propane cylinder. The CAMPLUX listing states no external flame or battery is required for ignition.

What safety shut-offs do these heaters list?

The NEWBULIG lists a 45° tip-over shut-off and flame-out protection. The Buyplus lists a tip-over switch and safety mesh guards. The Ruasveltan and CAMPLUX listings both list an automatic shut off for low oxygen, ODS, or unexpected tip-over.

Which heater is the lightest to carry?

The CAMPLUX, at 9.4 lbs in the bullets, with an easy-grip handle. The NEWBULIG lists 33.0 pounds with rolling wheels. No weight is stated for the Buyplus or the Ruasveltan.

Does the Buyplus heater include a propane tank?

No. The listing states it is sold as the propane heater only, without propane cylinders and tanks.

More from the barn

See every goat shelters guide and all Fencing and Shelter guides.

More picks: heated water buckets, goat shelters, heated water buckets for barn stalls and hay feeders for goats.