
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
TORCHSTAR LED Barn Light9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
TORCHSTAR 3CCT LED Barn Light9.7/10View on Amazon - 3
TORCHSTAR LED Barn Light9.7/10View on Amazon - 4
LEDVANCE Sylvania LED Barn LightView on Amazon - 5
LED Barn Light 150W SZGMJIA Dusk to Dawn Outdoor LightingView on Amazon - 6
AIKVSXER 200W LED Barn Light Dusk to DawnView on Amazon - 7
HALO Outdoor 650-Watt Equivalent Integrated LED Grey OutdoorView on Amazon - 8
toberich 150W LED Barn Light Dusk to DawnView on Amazon
Morning milking starts before sunrise, and the led vs halogen barn light question decides whether the barn is lit well enough for chores done safely in the dark. A dark barn turns every chore into a slow shuffle with a bucket and a flashlight, and a goat on the fence only adds to the chaos. Every listing compared for this guide is an LED light, and none of them is a halogen listing, so the halogen side below rests on what those LED makers state about the halogen lights their lights replace. The rest of this guide walks through the watts, lumens, color temperature and warranty each maker states, and which LED light fits which barn job.
Also worth comparing
LEDVANCE Sylvania LED Barn LightCheck price on Amazon
LED Barn Light 150W SZGMJIA Dusk to Dawn Outdoor LightingCheck price on Amazon
AIKVSXER 200W LED Barn Light Dusk to DawnCheck price on Amazon
HALO Outdoor 650-Watt Equivalent Integrated LED Grey OutdoorCheck price on Amazon
toberich 150W LED Barn Light Dusk to DawnCheck price on Amazon
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
led vs halogen barn light: the short answer
Choose LED. Every LED listing here states a lower wattage than the halogen light it claims to replace, and every one states a 50,000-hour lifespan with a built-in dusk-to-dawn photocell. The LEDVANCE light draws 40W and claims to replace a 250W traditional light, the SZGMJIA light draws 50W and claims to replace a 500W HPS or halogen bulb, the TIERONE light draws 29W and claims to replace a 250W HPS or halogen bulb, and the Pvilub light draws 150W and claims to replace a traditional HPS or MH light. Pick by brightness: the TIERONE light gives 3,300 lumens at 4000K for a smaller barn area, the SZGMJIA light gives 7,500 lumens at 5000K for a yard or larger barn, the LEDVANCE light suits a general barn door or garage wall, and the Pvilub light gives 22,500 lumens at 5000K for the widest area. The led vs halogen tractor lights comparison reaches the same conclusion for tractor lighting.
The LED lights compared
| Light | Watts | Lumens | Color temperature | Lifespan | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pvilub LED Parking Lot Light | 150W | 22,500 lumens | 5000K | 50,000+ hours | 5 year warranty |
| SZGMJIA LED Barn Light | 50W | 7,500 lumens | 5000K | 50,000 hours | 5 years |
| TIERONE LED Barn Light | 29W | 3,300 lumens | 4000K | More than 50,000 hours | 5-year manufacturer warranty |
| LEDVANCE Sylvania LED Barn Light | 40W | Not stated | 5000K | 50,000 hours | 3 year manufacturer warranty |
Pvilub LED Parking Lot Light
The Pvilub light draws 150W, gives 22,500 lumens at 5000K, and is rated 100-277V. The maker lists UL certification, an IP65 code, a die-cast aluminum housing, 6KV surge protection and a 50,000+ hour lifespan. The adjustable arm moves 0 to 180 degrees, the built-in photocell turns the light on at dusk and off at dawn, and the maker states a 5 year warranty.
SZGMJIA LED Barn Light
The SZGMJIA light draws 50W, gives 7,500 lumens at 5000K with 150LM/W efficacy and CRI 80, and the maker states a 50,000-hour lifespan. The maker lists ETL listing, an IP65 code and a die-casting aluminum body, and states a 5 year warranty. It measures 9.3 x 6.9 x 3.9 inches and is rated 100-277V.
TIERONE LED Barn Light
The TIERONE light uses a 29W LED bulb, gives 3,300 lumens at 4000K on 120Vac, and the maker states more than 50,000 hours of operation. The housing and prismatic lens are polycarbonate, the maker lists cULus listing and an IP65 code for wet locations, and the light covers up to 30 ft. x 30 ft. according to the maker. The maker states a 5-year manufacturer warranty, and the bulb carries a 2-year warranty.
LEDVANCE Sylvania LED Barn Light
The LEDVANCE Sylvania light draws 40W, is rated 5000K with 80 CRI, and the maker states a 50,000-hour lifespan. The housing is heavy-duty die-cast aluminum, the maker lists FCC and CEC compliance with UL listing for wet locations, and the light carries an IP65 code. It measures 7.9 x 3.7 x 10.82 inches, weighs 2.11 pounds, and comes with a 3 year manufacturer warranty.
Reading watts against halogen equivalents
Each maker states the halogen or traditional light its LED light replaces, so watts can be read side by side without guessing. The LEDVANCE light draws 40W against a stated 250W traditional light, the TIERONE light draws 29W against a stated 250W HPS or halogen bulb, the SZGMJIA light draws 50W against a stated 500W HPS or halogen bulb, and the Pvilub light draws 150W as a replacement for a traditional HPS or MH light. Lumens tell the other half of the story: the TIERONE light gives 3,300 lumens, the SZGMJIA light gives 7,500 lumens and the Pvilub light gives 22,500 lumens, while the LEDVANCE listing states no lumen figure. A barn that needs light across a wide yard calls for the higher lumen figures, while a small barn door or a stall area is served by the lower lumen figures.
Photocells, mounting and where the light goes
Every light here has a built-in dusk-to-dawn photocell that turns it on at dusk and off at dawn, so none of them needs a hand on a switch each night. The LEDVANCE light mounts to a wall or a pole with the included mounting hardware, the Pvilub light mounts to a wall or a pole with an adjustable arm, though wall-mount screws and the mounting plate are not included, and the TIERONE light mounts to a wall, a pole or an extension arm. Mount the light where the photocell sees the sky, and keep the sensor clear of other lights; the TIERONE maker warns to keep an appropriate installation distance between lights and to avoid blocking the photocell sensor. The tractor work lights with a switch roundup covers switched options for lights that ride on machines rather than barns.
Lifespan, build and warranty
Every listing here states a 50,000-hour lifespan: the LEDVANCE, SZGMJIA and Pvilub listings state 50,000 hours, and the TIERONE listing states more than 50,000 hours of operation. The TIERONE maker adds a lifespan of more than 23 years at 6 hours per day. Build splits between metal and plastic: the LEDVANCE, Pvilub and SZGMJIA housings are die-cast aluminum, while the TIERONE housing and lens are polycarbonate. Warranties run from a 3 year manufacturer warranty on the LEDVANCE light to 5 year warranties on the Pvilub, SZGMJIA and TIERONE lights, with the TIERONE bulb covered for 2 years.
Read the listing twice
Barn light listings sometimes disagree with themselves or leave a figure out, and the gaps are usually the ones that matter for planning the install:
- SZGMJIA: 100-277V in the title against AC110-277V in the bullets; check before ordering.
- TIERONE: a 2-year warranty on the bulb beside a 5-year manufacturer warranty.
- LEDVANCE: the listing states no lumen figure, so brightness cannot be compared in lumens against the other lights.
- Pvilub: wall-mount screws and the mounting plate are not included.
Measure the wall or pole before ordering.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers barn light hardware only. It does not cover wiring a new circuit, how much light a goat needs, or any health question. Ask a licensed electrician about wiring, and a veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.
FAQs from goat keepers
Is LED or halogen better for a barn light?
On the stated facts, LED. Every LED listing here draws fewer watts than the halogen light it claims to replace, and every one states a 50,000-hour lifespan with a dusk-to-dawn photocell. No halogen listing was compared here, so the halogen side rests on the replacement figures the LED makers state.
How many watts does an LED barn light draw?
The listings here draw 29W to 150W: the TIERONE light draws 29W, the LEDVANCE light draws 40W, the SZGMJIA light draws 50W and the Pvilub light draws 150W. Match the watts to the stated lumens and to the size of the area you need lit.
What color temperature suits a barn?
The LEDVANCE, Pvilub and SZGMJIA listings are rated 5000K daylight white, and the TIERONE light is rated 4000K bright white. The makers describe the 5000K light as mimicking natural daylight.
Do these barn lights turn on by themselves?
Yes. Every light here has a built-in dusk-to-dawn photocell that turns it on at dusk and off at dawn. The TIERONE light also offers switch-controlled on and off, and the Pvilub photocell can be disabled by covering the sensor.
How long do these LED barn lights last?
Every listing states a 50,000-hour lifespan, and the TIERONE maker adds more than 23 years at 6 hours per day.
What warranty comes with an LED barn light?
The LEDVANCE light carries a 3 year manufacturer warranty, and the Pvilub, SZGMJIA and TIERONE lights each state a 5 year warranty. The TIERONE listing also states a 2-year warranty on the bulb.
More from the barn
See every barn and farm tools guide and all barn equipment guides.
More picks: led vs halogen tractor lights, tractor work lights with a switch, magnetic tractor lights and goat shelters.
