Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Led vs Fluorescent Barn Light: Which One Should You Buy?

How LED and fluorescent barn lights compare on lumens, color temperature, ballast, weather sealing, ETL listing and warranty.

Led vs Fluorescent Barn Light: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1TORCHSTAR LED Barn LightTORCHSTAR LED Barn Light9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2TORCHSTAR 3CCT LED Barn LightTORCHSTAR 3CCT LED Barn Light9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3TORCHSTAR LED Barn LightTORCHSTAR LED Barn Light9.7/10View on Amazon
  4. 4Upgrade Super Bright 6 Pack 60W LED Shop Lights 4FT 9000LMUpgrade Super Bright 6 Pack 60W LED Shop Lights 4FT 9000LMView on Amazon
  5. 5SLAclite 4FT LED Vapor Tight Light 60W/50W/40WSLAclite 4FT LED Vapor Tight Light 60W/50W/40WView on Amazon
  6. 6Paktonvo 120W LED Barn Light Dusk to Dawn Area Light 5000KPaktonvo 120W LED Barn Light Dusk to Dawn Area Light 5000KView on Amazon
  7. 7toberich 150W LED Barn Light Dusk to Dawntoberich 150W LED Barn Light Dusk to DawnView on Amazon
  8. 82-Pack 150W LED Barn Light Dusk to Dawn2-Pack 150W LED Barn Light Dusk to DawnView on Amazon

The barn is still dark at morning milking, and the old tube over the stalls hums and flickers before it catches, so led vs fluorescent barn light is a question of what the fixture does over years of cold mornings. LED barn lights win on the figures the listings state: no ballast to replace, long stated lifespans, and dusk-to-dawn photocells on the yard lights. This guide compares both types by light output, color temperature, weather sealing, certifications and warranty, using only what the listings publish.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Led vs fluorescent barn light: the short answer

Pick LED. The LED listings here state outputs from 7500 lumens to 18000 lumens, color temperatures of 5000K daylight white, and lifespans of 50,000 hours where the maker states a figure. The SLAclite listing states its fixture has no ballast to replace, and the ELEKICO listing describes its LED light as a replacement for old fluorescent fixtures. Fluorescent fixtures use a ballast, which is a part that can fail and need replacing, while the LED fixtures here list sealed housings, ETL listings and warranties of 2 years to 5 years.

If you would rather go straight to the products, our best LED barn light roundup scores 5 barn lights on these points.

4 LED barn lights compared

Light Watts Lumens Color temp Warranty
SLAclite 4FT Vapor Tight, 4-pack 60W/50W/40W 7800 at 60W 4000K/5000K/6000K 5-year
SZGMJIA 50W Barn Light 50W 7500 5000K 5-year
Paktonvo 120W Barn Light 120W 18000 5000K 5-year
ELEKICO 60W 4FT Shop Light, 2-pack 60W 9000 5000K 2-year

SLAclite 4FT vapor tight light, 4-pack

The SLAclite fixture is the most flexible light here. It offers selectable wattage of 60W, 50W or 40W, with 7800 lumens at 60W, 6500 lumens at 50W and 5200 lumens at 40W, and selectable color temperature of 4000K, 5000K or 6000K. It is 0-10V dimmable, IP65 rated and ETL certified, with a polycarbonate vapor-tight casing for damp and wet locations. The maker states a 50,000-hour lifespan and a 5-year warranty, and describes the fixture as a replacement for 120-200W metal halide or fluorescent fixtures with no ballast to replace. It ships as a 4-pack and measures 45.86 by 3.54 by 3.3 inches.

SZGMJIA 50W barn light

The SZGMJIA barn light lists 50W, 7500 lumens and 5000K daylight white, with a luminous efficacy of 150LM/W and a CRI of 80. It is ETL listed and IP65 rated, with a die-cast aluminum body, and it has a built-in dusk-to-dawn photocell that turns the light on at sundown and off at sunrise. The maker states a 50,000-hour working life and a 5-year warranty, and describes the light as a 500W MH/HPS replacement that saves over 80% on the electricity bill. It measures 9.3 by 6.9 by 3.9 inches.

Paktonvo 120W barn light

The Paktonvo barn light has the highest lumen figure here, with 120W, 18000 lumens and 5000K daylight white. It is ETL listed and IP65 rated, with a cast aluminum housing and a built-in dusk-to-dawn photocell. The maker describes it as an 800W MH/HPS replacement and states a 5-year warranty. It measures 14.0 by 9.0 by 5.0 inches.

ELEKICO 60W 4FT shop light, 2-pack

The ELEKICO shop light lists 60W, 9000 lumens and 5000K daylight in a 4-foot fixture, and it ships as a 2-pack. It offers ceiling or hanging mount options, and the linkable design allows up to 4 units to connect for wider coverage. The maker describes a 10-plus-year working life and states a 2-year manufacturer warranty. It measures 48.0 by 4.5 by 1.9 inches. Neither an ETL listing nor IP65 is stated for this light, unlike the other 3 lights here.

What fluorescent needs that LED skips

The clearest difference in these listings is the ballast. The SLAclite listing states its LED fixture has no ballast to replace, and the ELEKICO listing describes its LED light as a replacement for old fluorescent fixtures. A fluorescent fixture runs its tube through a ballast, so when the ballast fails the whole fixture goes dark until the part is swapped. An LED fixture has no tube and no ballast, which removes that failure point. The LED listings also state lifespans of 50,000 hours on the SZGMJIA and SLAclite lights, while no fluorescent lifespan figure appears in these listings.

Light output and color temperature

Light output here runs from 7500 lumens on the SZGMJIA 50W light to 18000 lumens on the Paktonvo 120W light, with 9000 lumens on the ELEKICO 60W light and 7800 lumens at 60W on the SLAclite fixture. Color temperature is 5000K daylight white on the ELEKICO, SZGMJIA and Paktonvo lights. The SLAclite fixture adds a choice: a switch selects 4000K warm white, 5000K neutral white or 6000K cool white before the fixture goes up. The SZGMJIA listing states a luminous efficacy of 150LM/W and a CRI of 80. Match the lumen figure to the size of the space and the color temperature to the work you do under the light.

Weather sealing, certifications and warranty

The SZGMJIA 50W, the SLAclite 4-foot fixture and the Paktonvo 120W light are ETL listed and IP65 rated. The SZGMJIA light has a die-cast aluminum body, the SLAclite fixture has a polycarbonate vapor-tight casing, and the Paktonvo light has a cast aluminum housing. The ELEKICO light states neither an ETL listing nor IP65. Dusk-to-dawn photocells appear on the SZGMJIA and Paktonvo lights, and the SLAclite fixture is 0-10V dimmable. Warranties run 2 years on the ELEKICO light and 5 years on the other 3 lights. A longer stated warranty and a stated ETL listing are worth more than a bare lumen figure when the fixture lives in a damp barn.

Read the listing twice

Barn light listings contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan around:

  • SLAclite: 9000 lumens in the title against 7800 lumens at 60W in the bullets.
  • Paktonvo: AC110-277V in the title against AC100-277V in the bullets.
  • SZGMJIA: 100-277V in the title against AC110-277V in the bullets.

Check the figure that matters for your wiring before ordering, and plan around the lower lumen figure.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers light fixtures only. It does not cover wiring, circuits or how to mount a fixture to a barn ceiling. Ask a licensed electrician about wiring and circuits.

FAQs from goat keepers

How many lumens does a barn light need?

The lights here range from 7500 lumens to 18000 lumens. Match the lumen figure to the size of the space: the 18000-lumen Paktonvo light suits a large barn, while the 7500-lumen SZGMJIA light suits a yard or a smaller area.

What color temperature is best for a barn?

The listings here use 5000K daylight white. The SLAclite fixture lets you select 4000K, 5000K or 6000K, so you can pick warm white, neutral white or cool white for the space.

Do LED barn lights need a ballast?

No. The SLAclite listing states its LED fixture has no ballast to replace, and the ELEKICO listing describes its LED light as a replacement for old fluorescent fixtures.

Which barn lights have a dusk-to-dawn photocell?

The SZGMJIA 50W light and the Paktonvo 120W light list a built-in dusk-to-dawn photocell that turns the light on at sundown and off at sunrise.

More from the barn

See every barn equipment guide and all barn and farm tools guides.

More picks: best LED barn lights, best solar barn lights, solar vs plug-in barn lights and best LED lighting for pole barns.