Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Manure Fork vs Shovel: Which One Should You Buy?

Manure fork vs shovel compared by tines, length, weight and handle, with 4 forks ranked for stall cleaning and the jobs each tool suits.

Manure Fork vs Shovel: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1YITAMOTOR 4000 lbs Skid Steer Pallet Fork AttachmentYITAMOTOR 4000 lbs Skid Steer Pallet Fork Attachment9.7/10View on Amazon
  2. 2YINTATECH 60 in 4000 lbs Clamp on Pallet Forks withYINTATECH 60 in 4000 lbs Clamp on Pallet Forks with9.6/10View on Amazon
  3. 3VORTEXTOVE 46 in Quick Attach Pallet ForksVORTEXTOVE 46 in Quick Attach Pallet Forks9.6/10View on Amazon
  4. 4COSITA Pitch Fork for GardenCOSITA Pitch Fork for GardenView on Amazon
  5. 5VEVOR Manure ForkVEVOR Manure ForkView on Amazon
  6. 6Little Giant® DuraFork Pitch ForkLittle Giant® DuraFork Pitch ForkView on Amazon
  7. 7Lasnten 3 Sets Blue ABS Manure Fork with Long Metal HandleLasnten 3 Sets Blue ABS Manure Fork with Long Metal HandleView on Amazon
  8. 8Lasnten 3 Sets Black ABS Manure Fork with Long Metal HandleLasnten 3 Sets Black ABS Manure Fork with Long Metal HandleView on Amazon
  9. 98Pcs Manure Fork Head Pitch Fork with Angled Tines for8Pcs Manure Fork Head Pitch Fork with Angled Tines forView on Amazon

Manure fork vs shovel comes down to what you are moving: a manure fork lifts loose manure and soiled bedding on tines that let fine, dry material fall through, while a shovel scoops and carries wet, heavy, packed material on a solid blade. For daily stall cleaning the fork does most of the work, and the shovel follows for the wet spots and the final scrape. This guide compares the tools by tines, length, weight and handle, using the forks whose listings state the figures.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Manure fork vs shovel: the short answer

Use a manure fork when the material is loose: dry manure, soiled straw and hay lift cleanly on tines, and the fines sift back to the floor instead of filling the barrow. Use a shovel when the material is wet, packed or heavy: soaked bedding, trampled piles and the last scrape of the stall floor need a solid blade that holds the load. Most barns keep both tools by the door, and the fork sees daily use while the shovel waits for the wet jobs. The 4 forks below are ranked with the VEVOR first, followed by the COSITA, the Nohovu 10-tine and the Nohovu 5-tine, on tines, length, weight and handle.

4 forks compared

Fork Tines Length Weight Handle
VEVOR Manure Fork 18 angled 61 in 2.56 lb Fiberglass
COSITA Pitch Fork 10 44 in 5 lb Fiberglass, D-grip
Nohovu 10-Tine Pitchfork 10 56 in 1.0 lb Fiberglass
Nohovu 5-Tine Pitchfork 5 58 in 3.88 lb Fiberglass, 2 grips

VEVOR Manure Fork, 18 angled tines

The VEVOR leads the ranking because it is the only fork here built and named as a manure fork. It lists 18 angled tines on a head 15.75 by 13.19 inches, a fiberglass handle and a total length of 61 inches as the title and bullets state, at 2.56 pounds. The angled, pointed teeth are stated to grip loose material and reduce spillage, and the reinforced connection is stated to hold without loosening or wobbling. It is easy to assemble and take apart for storage. The listing states it is not suitable for digging, so packed ground still calls for a shovel.

COSITA Pitch Fork, 10 tines

The COSITA is a wide 10-tine fork with a 44-inch fiberglass handle and a D-grip, weighing 5 pounds. The carbon steel tines are stated to resist breaking and deformation under heavy loads, and the wide head carries more grass, feed or other material in a single scoop. The thickened fiberglass shaft is stated to reduce muscle strain, and unlike wooden handles it is weather-resistant, with no splintering, warping or corrosion. It assembles in seconds with no tools, and the reinforced joint locks the steel head and fiberglass shaft in place. At 44 inches it is the most compact length here, which gives leverage for heavy lifting and tipping.

Nohovu 10-Tine Pitchfork, 56 inches

The Nohovu 10-tine fork lists a curved design with ten evenly spaced tines, forged high-carbon steel and finely ground tine tips that dig into compost and loose material. The fiberglass handle is stated to combine strength and flexibility, and the non-slip grip improves control when handling heavy loads. Key connection points are held with double rivets. The listing states a 56-inch length. The spec table lists a weight of 1.0 pounds and dimensions of 56.0 by 1.0 by 1.0 inches, figures that give no usable head width, so treat the weight and size figures with care.

Nohovu 5-Tine Pitchfork, 58 inches

The Nohovu 5-tine fork is the longest fork here at 58 inches, with a head 8.26 inches wide and a weight of 3.88 pounds. The longer size is stated to reduce the bending angle and back stress, and the handle carries 2 non-slip grips. The head is carbon steel with a rust-resistant coating, stated to hold up in a humid environment. 5 tines carry less per scoop than 10 or 18, so this fork suits lighter loads of hay, manure, grain, mulch and leaves.

Tines: how many and what shape

Tine count sets how much each scoop holds. The VEVOR lists 18 angled tines, the COSITA and the Nohovu 10-tine list 10 each, and the Nohovu 5-tine lists 5. More tines hold more loose material per scoop and spill less, which is why the 18-tine VEVOR leads for stall cleaning. Shape matters too: the VEVOR tines are angled and pointed to grip material, and the Nohovu 10-tine tines are curved to follow natural body movement, with finely ground tips that dig into compost. A fork is not a digging tool: the VEVOR listing states it is not suitable for digging, so packed ground and the final scrape still call for a shovel. For a different fork job, see hay fork vs bale spear.

Length and weight

Length runs from 44 inches on the COSITA to 61 inches on the VEVOR, with the Nohovu forks at 56 and 58 inches. A longer fork means less bending: the Nohovu 5-tine listing states the longer size reduces the bending angle and back stress, and the VEVOR listing states its 61-inch fork is easy to manage. The COSITA at 44 inches gives leverage for heavy lifting and tipping. Weight runs from 1.0 pounds on the Nohovu 10-tine to 5 pounds on the COSITA, with the VEVOR at 2.56 pounds and the Nohovu 5-tine at 3.88 pounds. Treat the 1.0-pound figure with care: it sits beside dimensions of 56.0 by 1.0 by 1.0 inches, which give no usable head width.

Handles and grips

All 4 forks list fiberglass handles. Fiberglass is stated to be lightweight and sturdy, and the COSITA listing states it is weather-resistant, with no splintering, warping or corrosion, unlike wooden handles. Grips differ: the COSITA has a D-grip and a thickened shaft, the Nohovu 5-tine has 2 non-slip grips, and the Nohovu 10-tine has a non-slip grip. Joints differ too: the COSITA joint locks the steel head and fiberglass shaft in place, the VEVOR connection is reinforced to hold without loosening or wobbling, and the Nohovu 10-tine connection points are held with double rivets. The COSITA assembles in seconds with no tools, and the VEVOR is easy to assemble and take apart for storage.

Read the listing twice

Fork listings contradict themselves on the figures you need to plan around:

  • VEVOR: 61 inches in the title and bullets against 59.84 inches in the spec table. This guide uses 61 inches, the figure the title and bullets state.
  • Nohovu 10-tine: 1.0 pounds in the spec table beside dimensions of 56.0 by 1.0 by 1.0 inches, which give no usable head width.
  • Nohovu 5-tine: 58 inches, a head 8.26 inches wide and 3.88 pounds agree between the bullets and the spec table.
  • COSITA: 44 inches and 5 pounds agree between the title, bullets and spec table.

Measure your stall and your barrow before ordering, and allow for the larger figure where a listing disagrees with itself.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers fork hardware only. No shovel listing was in the set compared, so the shovel side here is about the job: a solid blade for wet, packed material and the final scrape. It does not cover wheelbarrows or carts for hauling the load away, or bedding types. Ask your local extension office about stall management and bedding.

FAQs from goat keepers

Should I use a manure fork or a shovel for stall cleaning?

Use a fork for loose manure and soiled bedding, and a shovel for wet, packed loads and the final scrape. The VEVOR fork lists 18 angled tines stated to grip loose material and reduce spillage, while a solid shovel blade holds wet material that would fall through tines.

How many tines should a manure fork have?

The forks here list 5 to 18 tines: 18 angled tines on the VEVOR, 10 on the COSITA and the Nohovu 10-tine, and 5 on the Nohovu 5-tine. More tines hold more per scoop, so the 18-tine fork suits daily stall cleaning and the 5-tine fork suits lighter loads.

What length manure fork should I buy?

Lengths here run from 44 to 61 inches. The Nohovu 5-tine at 58 inches states its longer size reduces the bending angle and back stress, the VEVOR at 61 inches states it is easy to manage, and the COSITA at 44 inches states it gives leverage for heavy lifting and tipping.

Are fiberglass handles good for manure forks?

All 4 forks here list fiberglass handles. The COSITA listing states fiberglass is weather-resistant with no splintering, warping or corrosion, and the Nohovu 5-tine listing states its thickened fiberglass handle is lightweight, sturdy and not easy to break.

More from the barn

See every barn equipment guide and all barn and farm tools guides.

More picks: best wheelbarrow, hay fork vs bale spear, rubber vs foam stall mats and horse stable supplies.