Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Oval vs Rectangular Water Trough: Which One Should You Buy?

Oval vs rectangular water trough shapes compared through 4 galvanized listings, with capacities, base designs and the contradictions to read for.

Oval vs Rectangular Water Trough: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Rubermaid 150 Gallon Oval Stock Tank Water Trough Cover withRubermaid 150 Gallon Oval Stock Tank Water Trough Cover with9.5/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Behrens 0-OV 5-1/2-Gallon Oval Steel TubBehrens 0-OV 5-1/2-Gallon Oval Steel TubView on Amazon
  3. 3Behrens Tub 10.5 Gal Oval Galvanized Brand: BehrensBehrens Tub 10.5 Gal Oval Galvanized Brand: BehrensView on Amazon
  4. 4Tuff Stuff Products KMT102 Oval TankTuff Stuff Products KMT102 Oval TankView on Amazon
  5. 5KataiKataiView on Amazon

Goats push, climb and dunk their heads at the water, so the shape of the trough sets how the morning watering goes. This guide answers the oval vs rectangular water trough question for goat pens: which shape suits the pen, what each shape does well and what the current listings actually sell. Every number below comes from the listings themselves, and we flag where those listings contradict themselves or describe something that is not a trough at all.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Oval vs rectangular water trough: the short answer

For goats, the shape matters less than whether the listing describes a real trough. An oval tub suits a small pen because the curved wall sheds bumps and the compact footprint fits tight corners; a rectangular trough suits a larger group because the long straight side lets several goats drink at once and the flat sides sit flush against a fence. But every listing in the current set describes an oval shape, and of the 4 only the Behrens tub states a sealed, watertight build; the other three are raised garden beds, two of which carry “water trough” in the title while the bullets describe an open base. If you want scored picks rather than a shape guide, our oval water trough roundup compares tubs and covers.

Oval and rectangular troughs compared

Shape Example listing Stated capacity Base and seal
Oval Behrens 0-OV steel tub 5.5 gallons Sealed for wet contents, offset bottom
Oval Rakukiri planter box 68 gallons of soil Open bottom
Oval Land Guard 6×3×2ft bed 1019.52 liters Open base
Oval Land Guard 6×3×1.99ft bed 266 gallons Open base
Rectangular No listing in this set Not stated Not stated

Sizes and capacities are the manufacturer’s numbers as each listing states them, pulled 24 October 2026.

Oval tubs

The Behrens 0-OV is the only listing in the set built to hold liquid: the bullets say it is sealed for wet or dry contents and describe a zinc coating that provides a watertight seal, plus an offset bottom that keeps the pail off the ground and horizontal swedging for added strength. It lists hot dipped galvanized steel, a 5.5 gallon capacity and a 7.75 x 13 x 7.3 inch footprint at 3.3 pounds, and the maker says it is made in the USA from 100% sustainable materials. The warranty line says Behrens products are warranted against manufacturer’s defects, with no term stated, so there is no concrete warranty to score.

Oval raised beds marketed as troughs

The other listings are oval raised garden beds, not drinking troughs. The Rakukiri box lists 60×29×11 in, 68 gallons of soil, 0.8mm galvanized sheet with double-layer anti-corrosion galvanizing and an open bottom that the bullets say avoids water accumulation; the title says 5ft while the spec table lists the length as 4ft, and the bullets list 30 day free return and a one year warranty. The two Land Guard beds list Q195 galvanized metal sheet, double-layer anti-corrosion galvanizing, an oval structure and an open base, with 0.78mm average thickness and a thickest part of 1.56mm; the larger lists 72 x 36 x 24 inches, 1019.52 liters and 13.15 kg, the smaller 72 x 36 x 23.8 inches, 266 gallons and 12.88 kg, and both say the bed takes about 5 minutes to assemble. Both Land Guard titles include the words “Galvanized Water Trough”, yet both bullet lists describe an open base, which cannot hold water; trust the open-base description over the title. Neither Land Guard listing states a warranty term.

Reading capacity against your herd

Capacity on these listings runs from 5.5 gallons on the Behrens tub to 266 gallons on the smaller Land Guard bed and 1019.52 liters on the larger one, with the Rakukiri bed listing 68 gallons of soil rather than water. Gallons of space are not gallons of drinking water, and none of these listings converts volume into a daily supply for goats, so treat the figures as a way to rank listings against each other. Match the stated volume to the pen: a compact oval tub fits a small pen with a few goats, while a 266 gallon bed is far more volume than a small herd can drink before the water needs changing. For small herds, see troughs for two goats.

Count the goats that will drink at once and leave room at the rim, since goats jostle. If you keep separate groups, a trough in each pen beats one large trough shared across a fence line.

Base design decides whether it holds water

A trough must hold water, so read the base line before the shape. The Behrens tub states a sealed build with a watertight seal and an offset bottom that keeps the pail off the ground, which reads as a real trough. The raised beds state an open base or open bottom, which drains by design; no liner or plug is mentioned in any of these listings, so read them as planters.

On shape alone, oval suits tight pens: the curved wall has no corners for bedding to pack into and the tub sits easily away from fence lines. Rectangular suits larger groups: the long straight side gives more rim per trough and the flat sides sit flush against a fence or wall. None of the 4 listings describes a rectangular trough, so the rectangular case rests on shape alone while the oval case rests on the listings.

Materials: galvanized steel

All 4 listings use galvanized steel: the Behrens tub lists hot dipped galvanized steel, the Rakukiri box lists a 0.8mm galvanized metal sheet with double-layer anti-corrosion galvanizing and powder coating, and both Land Guard beds list Q195 galvanized metal sheet with double-layer anti-corrosion galvanizing at 0.78mm average. Galvanized and powder-coated finishes suit feeders and water gear that live outdoors or in a damp barn. Thin sheet dents where goats lean and climb: the Rakukiri lists 0.8mm and the Land Guard beds 0.78mm average with a thickest part of 1.56mm.

Read the listing twice

Trough and bed listings contradict themselves, and the conflicts sit in the fields you need for planning:

  • Rakukiri: 5ft in the title against 4ft in the spec table length, with 60×29×11 in in the bullets; plan for the 60 inch figure.
  • Land Guard 6×3×2ft and 6×3×1.99ft: near-duplicate listings of the same oval bed design, with capacities of 1019.52 liters and 266 gallons and weights of 13.15 kg and 12.88 kg.
  • Land Guard titles: “Galvanized Water Trough” in the title against an open base in the bullets; trust the bullets.
  • Behrens: model 0-OV in the title against part number 0-0V in the spec table, a letter O against a zero; the 5.5 gallon capacity is consistent across title and table.

Measure the pen before ordering and allow for the larger figure. Listings that mix planter and trough language deserve a second read of the base and capacity lines.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers trough hardware only. It does not cover how much water a goat needs, water additives or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.

FAQs from goat keepers

Can goats drink from an oval tub such as the Behrens 0-OV?

That listing is the only one in the set that states a sealed, watertight build: 5.5 gallons, hot dipped galvanized steel and an offset bottom. It reads as a real small trough, though no goat-specific capacity guidance is stated.

Can a raised garden bed work as a water trough?

Not as listed. Both Land Guard beds carry “water trough” in the title but describe an open base in the bullets, and the Rakukiri bed lists an open bottom; none of these listings mentions a liner or plug.

What size trough suits a small goat pen?

Match the stated volume to the pen. The Behrens tub lists 5.5 gallons and a 7.75 x 13 x 7.3 inch footprint, while the Land Guard beds list 266 gallons and 1019.52 liters at 72 x 36 x 24 inches and 72 x 36 x 23.8 inches; the beds are built as planters with open bases, not water holders.

Is galvanized steel a good trough material?

All 4 listings use galvanized steel, and the Behrens tub adds a zinc coating the maker says provides a watertight seal. Galvanized finishes suit gear that lives outdoors; check the listing for the coating type and the sheet thickness it states.

How do I keep a small trough clean?

Tip and scrub it on a routine you can keep. The Behrens listing notes an offset bottom that keeps the pail off the ground, which helps the underside dry; keep troughs away from hay racks so dropped hay stays out of the water.

Behind the Farm Score

The GoatGear Score weighs performance, build, value, safety and warranty. For water troughs, safety means a sealed build that holds water and a stable base that sits level. Of the 4 listings, the Rakukiri states a one year warranty, the Behrens states a warranty with no term, and neither Land Guard listing states a warranty term. How we pick explains the weights.

More from the barn

See every water trough guide and all feeding and water guides.

More picks: oval water troughs, troughs for two goats, heated water buckets and automatic waterers vs troughs.