
On this page
Top picks at a glance
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
- 1
Suwdjpwo 2000W Portable Immersion Water Heater with Digital9.7/10View on Amazon - 2
Farm Innovators H-419 Ice Chaser Submersible Stock Tank9.5/10View on Amazon - 3
Airmax Stock Tank Defense Livestock Water Trough Cleaner9.5/10View on Amazon
A frozen trough at morning chores means hauling water by hand until the ice breaks, and that is the job a water trough heater vs stock tank de-icer is built for. The short answer is that the two names describe the same kind of submersible heater: a unit that sits in the trough and keeps the water from freezing. The four units in this guide split across the two names, with the GANDONE and the Pwgel sold as water trough heaters and the two API units sold as de-icers, so the choice comes down to wattage, tank size, thermostat control and cord, not the name on the box.
GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
Water trough heater vs stock tank de-icer: the short answer
Pick the heater by the size of the trough, not by the name on the box. The GANDONE states 500 watts for containers of 25 to 50 gallons, and the API 2002DP states 1500 watts for 100 to 300 gallons, so a small goat trough takes the smaller unit and a large stock tank takes the larger one. All four units here are submersible heaters with a thermostat that switches the power on and off. If you would rather compare ready-scored picks, our best water trough heater for goats roundup scores five heaters on these points.
Two names, one kind of heater
Makers use the words heater and de-icer for the same kind of unit: a heating element that goes under the water and keeps the surface from freezing. The GANDONE and the Pwgel are sold as water trough heaters, and the two API units are sold as de-icers, but all four are submersible and all four use a thermostat. The table below lays out wattage, stated tank size, thermostat detail, cord and safety listings in ranking order.
| Heater | Wattage | Tank size | Thermostat | Cord |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| API 2002DP | 1500 watts | 100 to 300 gallons | Thermostatic, over-temperature protection | 6 foot anti-rub cord |
| GANDONE IDH 500 | 500 watts | 25 to 50 gallons | On below 35°F, off near 77°F | Cold and heat resistant cord |
| API W500 | 500 watts | Not stated | Thermostatic, over-temperature protection | 6 foot anti-rub cord |
| Pwgel 419 | 1500 watts | Not stated | Automatic on and off | PVC cord, bite-resistant cover |
Water trough heaters
The GANDONE IDH 500 is a 500 watt submersible unit in cast aluminum with an anti-rust coating, made for containers of 25 to 50 gallons and for water as cold as 12°F. The Pwgel 419 is a 1500 watt submersible unit in one-piece cast aluminum with a bite-resistant cord cover, made for larger farm animals such as horses, cows, sheep and large dogs. Neither states a warranty, and only the GANDONE states a tank size.
Stock tank de-icers
The API W500 is a 500 watt automatic waterer de-icer with a heating element the maker calls safe for plastic water tanks, a large surface that runs at a lower overall temperature and a 6 foot anti-rub cord. The API 2002DP is a 1500 watt stock tank de-icer with a stainless steel heating element, a patented drain-plug adapter for a 3/4 inch drain hole and a 6 foot anti-rub cord, recommended for 100 to 300 gallons. Both API units are CSA and UL listed.
Wattage and tank size
Wattage and tank size move together in the two listings that state both: 500 watts for 25 to 50 gallons on the GANDONE, and 1500 watts for 100 to 300 gallons on the API 2002DP. A 500 watt unit suits a small goat trough or a poultry waterer, while a 1500 watt unit suits a large stock tank shared by bigger animals. The API W500 and the Pwgel state no tank size, so their wattage is the only guide to the size of trough they suit: 500 watts for the W500 and 1500 watts for the Pwgel. Our water trough sizes guide lists gallons and dimensions for common troughs.
Thermostats, cords and safety listings
A thermostat is what keeps a submersible heater from running all day. The GANDONE states its numbers plainly: the heater turns on when the air falls below 35°F (2°C) and the power disconnects as the air approaches 77°F (25°C). The Pwgel states that its thermostat switches the power on and off automatically, and shuts the unit off when the water runs too low or the temperature runs too high or too low. The two API units are thermostatically controlled with over-temperature protection.
Cords and outlets matter as much as watts. The GANDONE cord is made of cold and heat resistant material, and the maker notes to use a GFCI outlet or an extension cord marked with the suffix letter W, such as SJTW cords. The Pwgel cord is high-quality PVC with a bite-resistant cover that the maker states resists wear and limits electrical leakage. Both API units come with a 6 foot anti-rub power cord, and both are CSA and UL listed, the only safety listings stated in this guide. A heated water bucket vs stock tank heater comparison covers the other way to heat winter water.
The GANDONE listing states one use rule plainly: the de-icer must be fully submerged in water during use, and plugging it in dry will damage the unit. The same listing rates the unit for use at temperatures above -40°F, with a note that colder use risks wires hardening or turning brittle, which may cause short circuits.
The gear: four heaters and de-icers, ranked
The four units below are ranked from the most complete listing to the thinnest, judged on wattage, stated tank size, thermostat detail, cord and safety listings, with the API 2002DP first and the Pwgel last.
API 2002DP: 1500 watts for 100 to 300 gallons
The API 2002DP is the strongest listing here. It states 1500 watts, a recommended range of 100 to 300 gallons, a stainless steel heating element that discourages rusting and corrosion, a patented drain-plug adapter for a 3/4 inch drain hole, a 6 foot anti-rub cord and CSA and UL listings. It weighs 2.0 pounds and measures 14.25 by 4.63 by 6.63 inches. No warranty term is stated.
GANDONE IDH 500: 500 watts for 25 to 50 gallons
The GANDONE IDH 500 states 500 watts for containers of 25 to 50 gallons, with freezing prevented in temperatures as low as 12°F. Its thermostat turns the heater on below 35°F (2°C) and disconnects the power near 77°F (25°C). The body is cast aluminum with an anti-rust coating, and the maker states it suits plastic, structural foam and metal tanks. It weighs 1.5 pounds and measures 0.7 by 4.7 by 7.48 inches. No warranty term is stated.
API W500: 500 watts for plastic tanks
The API W500 states 500 watts with thermostat control and over-temperature protection, a heating element safe for plastic water tanks, a large surface that runs at a lower overall temperature and a 6 foot anti-rub cord. It is CSA and UL listed and weighs 1.0 pounds. The listing states no tank size and no dimensions.
Pwgel 419: 1500 watts with no tank size stated
The Pwgel 419 states 1500 watts in a one-piece cast aluminum body with a bite-resistant PVC cord cover, automatic thermostat control and a stated maximum temperature of 15 degrees. The maker states it suits troughs for larger farm animals such as horses, cows, sheep and large dogs, and that it is safe for plastic. It measures 9.0 by 9.5 by 4.0 inches. No tank size, weight, warranty term or safety listing is stated.
What this guide does not cover
This guide covers heater hardware only. It does not cover how much water a goat needs, winter feeding or any animal health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.
FAQs from goat keepers
What is the difference between a water trough heater and a stock tank de-icer?
Very little: both names describe a submersible heater that sits in the trough and keeps the water from freezing. The GANDONE and the Pwgel are sold as water trough heaters and the two API units are sold as de-icers, so choose by wattage, tank size, thermostat and cord.
What size heater does a goat trough need?
The GANDONE states 500 watts for containers of 25 to 50 gallons, and the API 2002DP states 1500 watts for 100 to 300 gallons. The API W500 and the Pwgel state no tank size, so their wattage is the only guide to the trough they suit.
Do these heaters turn off by themselves?
Yes, all four use a thermostat. The GANDONE turns on below 35°F and disconnects near 77°F, the Pwgel switches on and off automatically, and both API units are thermostatically controlled with over-temperature protection.
Can a de-icer go in a plastic tank?
Yes, where the maker states it. The GANDONE suits plastic, structural foam and metal tanks, the API W500 heating element is safe for plastic water tanks, and the Pwgel is safe for plastic.
Do I need a GFCI outlet for a trough heater?
The GANDONE listing notes to use a GFCI outlet, or an extension cord marked with the suffix letter W, such as SJTW cords. The other three listings state no outlet guidance.
Must the heater stay under water?
The GANDONE listing states the de-icer must be fully submerged in water during use, and that plugging it in dry will damage the unit. The other three listings state no submersion rule.
More from the barn
See every water trough guide and all feeding and water guides.
More picks: water trough heaters for goats, heated water buckets, goat water buckets for winter and hay feeders for goats.
