Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Plastic vs Wood Dog House: Which One Should You Buy?

Plastic vs wood dog house: four plastic shelters compared on size, vents, floors and assembly, with the wood side judged on upkeep.

Plastic vs Wood Dog House: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Fancyango Large Dog House with Weatherproof RoofFancyango Large Dog House with Weatherproof Roof9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Fancyango Dog House Outdoor Indoor for Small Medium DogsFancyango Dog House Outdoor Indoor for Small Medium DogsView on Amazon
  3. 3Fancyango Large Dog House Outdoor Indoor for Medium Large DogsFancyango Large Dog House Outdoor Indoor for Medium Large DogsView on Amazon
  4. 4Fancyango Small Dog House Outdoor IndoorFancyango Small Dog House Outdoor IndoorView on Amazon
  5. 5Bifanuo Dog House Outdoor Indoor for Small DogsBifanuo Dog House Outdoor Indoor for Small DogsView on Amazon
  6. 6ATMELT 30 Inch Medium Dog House Outdoor/IndoorATMELT 30 Inch Medium Dog House Outdoor/IndoorView on Amazon
  7. 7ATMELT 43 Inch Large Dog House Outdoor/IndoorATMELT 43 Inch Large Dog House Outdoor/IndoorView on Amazon

A farm dog needs a dry place to sleep, and the plastic vs wood dog house question comes up every time the old shelter starts to leak. This guide compares the two materials on cleaning, weather, weight and assembly. All four houses in this guide are plastic, and no wood house is in this set, so the wood side is judged on the same needs: what the material has to do in the yard. On the stated facts, plastic is the lower-upkeep pick: every house here cleans with a damp cloth or a rinse of water, while a wooden house needs more upkeep.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Plastic vs wood dog house: the short answer

Plastic wins on upkeep. All four houses here are plastic with elevated floors, and three are listed as waterproof. Three wipe clean with a damp cloth while the fourth rinses clean with water. Wood needs more upkeep: the ATMELT house contrasts its resin surface with high-maintenance wooden houses. Choose plastic for a yard shelter that dries fast and cleans with a cloth; choose wood only if the wood look matters more than the extra upkeep.

For a ranked set of outdoor houses, the best outdoor dog house roundup scores five houses on these points.

Four plastic houses compared

House Size Weight Vents Floor Assembly
Fancyango Blue 26.18 x 24.02 x 25.98 in 11.9 lb Air vents Elevated About 20 minutes
Bifanuo Classic Grey 26 x 23.6 x 25.8 in 11.9 lb Hidden vents Elevated Tool-free, in minutes
Bifanuo Small Grey 18 x 22.4 x 22.2 in 8.6 lb Hidden ventilation Elevated Tool-free, under 3 minutes
ATMELT Grey 26.26 x 25.83 x 24.57 in Not stated Front and rear vents Elevated Snap-together, 20 minutes

Size and fit

Size decides whether the dog fits. The small Bifanuo house measures 18 x 22.4 x 22.2 inches and is listed for small dogs only. The Fancyango blue house measures 26.18 x 24.02 x 25.98 inches and the Bifanuo Classic Grey measures 26 x 23.6 x 25.8 inches, and both are listed for small and medium dogs. The ATMELT house measures 26.26 x 25.83 x 24.57 inches and is listed as a medium dog house, while the maker also says it fits large dogs; the stated dimensions are the safer guide. Measure the dog and the spot before ordering, and allow for the larger figure where the numbers differ.

Cleaning and upkeep

Cleaning is where plastic pulls ahead. The Fancyango, Bifanuo Classic Grey and small Bifanuo houses wipe clean with a damp cloth, and the ATMELT house rinses clean with water. The Fancyango and Bifanuo houses use smooth plastic surfaces, and the ATMELT house uses a stain-proof waterproof resin surface. A wooden house needs more upkeep: the ATMELT house contrasts its resin surface with high-maintenance wooden houses. For daily chores, a wipe-down after rain keeps a plastic house fresh.

Weather, vents and floors

Three of the four houses are listed as waterproof, and the small Bifanuo house is listed as weather-resistant. All four lift the dog off the ground on an elevated floor. The Fancyango house adds a ground nail that holds it in strong wind, and its vents move air through the house. The Bifanuo Classic Grey and small Bifanuo houses use hidden vents, and the ATMELT house pairs removable windows with hidden front and rear vents. The ATMELT roof is steeply sloped to drain rain and snow, and the small Bifanuo roof is sloped to shed rain. For cold nights, the elevated floor keeps the house off cold, damp ground; see the best insulation for dog house picks for adding warmth.

Assembly

Assembly is tool-free on three of the four houses. The Bifanuo Classic Grey and small Bifanuo houses need no tools, and the small one goes together in under 3 minutes. The ATMELT house snaps together with no special tools and finishes in 20 minutes. The Fancyango house assembles in about 20 minutes.

Check the numbers before ordering

Two size figures are published for the Bifanuo Classic Grey house: 26 x 23.6 x 25.8 inches and 26.18 x 24.03 x 25.98 inches. The ATMELT house is published at 30 inches and at 26.26 x 25.83 x 24.57 inches. Both Bifanuo houses carry the model number TT057 with different sizes, so check the size line before ordering. Measure the spot before ordering and allow for the larger figure.

FAQs from goat keepers

Is a plastic dog house waterproof?

Three houses here are listed as waterproof, and the small Bifanuo house is listed as weather-resistant with a sloped roof that sheds rain. The ATMELT house adds a steeply sloped roof that drains rain and snow.

What size dog house does a medium dog need?

The Fancyango house measures 26.18 x 24.02 x 25.98 inches and the Bifanuo Classic Grey measures 26 x 23.6 x 25.8 inches, and both are listed for small and medium dogs. The ATMELT house measures 26.26 x 25.83 x 24.57 inches and is listed as a medium dog house. Measure the dog lying down and allow room to turn around.

Do plastic dog houses need tools to assemble?

Three of the four houses here state tool-free assembly: both Bifanuo houses and the ATMELT house. The Fancyango house assembles in about 20 minutes.

How do you clean a plastic dog house?

Wipe the Fancyango and Bifanuo houses with a damp cloth, and rinse the ATMELT house with water. The elevated floor keeps the sleeping area off damp ground.

Does a plastic dog house stay warm in winter?

The elevated floor keeps the house off cold, damp ground on all four houses here. The Fancyango house lists vents and an elevated floor that keep the interior cozy in winter, and the ATMELT house has removable windows to block cold wind.

More from the barn

See every farm dog gear guide and all farm dogs and barn cats guides.

More picks: best outdoor dog house, best dog house for cold weather, dog house vs dog kennel and best insulation for dog house.