Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Pulsator vs Non Pulsator Milker: Which One Should You Buy?

A plain comparison of pulsator and non-pulsator milkers: adjustable rates, 60:40 ratios, outlets and vacuum pumps from the listings, plus the gaps to check.

Pulsator vs Non Pulsator Milker: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

The milking machine is humming, the milk is moving, and the small box on top is doing something you cannot see. Pulsator vs non pulsator milker is the question behind that box, and the short answer is this: a pulsator switches the vacuum on and off in a steady cycle, with listings stating adjustable rates from 50 to 180 ppm and a 60:40 ratio, while a non-pulsator applies steady vacuum with no cycle at all. This guide compares the two approaches on how they work, what the listings state and the gaps to check.

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Pulsator vs non pulsator milker: the short answer

A pulsator is a small device that makes the air pressure change periodically; the Pssopp listing describes it exactly that way, and calls it one of the essential parts of a milking system. It sits between the vacuum pump and the teat cups and alternates the vacuum, so the cups squeeze and release in rhythm. A non-pulsator setup skips that device: the pump pulls steady vacuum through the cups with no on-off cycle, which is simpler but gives the teat no rest phase.

Approach What it does What listings state Adjustability
Pulsator Switches vacuum on and off in a cycle 50 to 180 ppm adjustable (YIHAOSSING, CYSFETENA); 60:40 ratio (Mitty Dairy, CYSFETENA, Mumusuki) Rate screws on the back
Non-pulsator Steady vacuum, no cycle Not covered by these listings Not stated

What a pulsator does

Every pulsator in these listings does the same job: it turns a steady vacuum into a rhythm. The YIHAOSSING and CYSFETENA listings state an adjustable speed from 50 to 180 ppm, set with screws on the back of the unit, and the CYSFETENA bullets explain the idea: a higher rate for high-production cows, a lower rate for sheep or slower animals. The Mitty Dairy, CYSFETENA and Mumusuki listings state a 60:40 or 60/40 pulsation ratio, which is the split of the cycle between the two phases.

Most of these units have 2 outlets: the YIHAOSSING, HAOX, Pssopp, CYSFETENA and Mumusuki listings all state 2 exits or outlets for connecting to a milking machine, while the OUKENS listing states 4 outlets. Materials are consistent: plastic and stainless steel on the YIHAOSSING, HAOX and CYSFETENA listings, a stainless steel top on the Mitty Dairy listing, and a stainless-covered outside on the Pssopp listing. Weights run 12 to 15 ounces, and the Mumusuki listing gives a compact 3.35 x 3.35 inch body with a 0.37 inch outlet diameter. The Mitty Dairy listing notes its pulsator can be adjusted to work for either cows or goats.

What non-pulsator milking looks like

Non-pulsator milkers do not appear in these listings, so this section works from general knowledge and states no figures. Without a pulsator, the vacuum pump pulls directly through the teat cups at a constant level: simpler plumbing, fewer parts to service and nothing to adjust. The trade is the missing rest phase: the cups hold vacuum continuously instead of cycling, which is why most modern machine setups include a pulsator.

In practice, the choice is rarely a philosophical one. If your machine already has a pulsator port, you buy a pulsator; if you are assembling the simplest possible rig, you may start without one and add it later. Either way, the pump underneath matters: the Fockety listing states a 48W 12V vacuum pump at 2.62 pounds, and the Beufee listing states a 12V pump measuring 11.81 x 7.48 x 5.51 inches at 1.17 pounds. Compare complete units in our best goat milking machine roundup.

Reading the specs that matter

Three figures separate one pulsator listing from another. First, the rate: adjustable 50 to 180 ppm on the YIHAOSSING and CYSFETENA listings, set by screws on the back. Second, the ratio: 60:40 or 60/40 on the Mitty Dairy, CYSFETENA and Mumusuki listings. Third, the outlets: 2 on most listings, 4 on the OUKENS. Beyond that, check the materials (plastic and stainless steel is the common pairing), the weight for a portable rig, and whether the listing names your animal: the Mitty Dairy listing names cows and goats, the Mumusuki listing names dairy cows, cattle, goats and sheep.

Do not expect the listings to compare pulsator and non-pulsator for you. None of them discusses the other approach, so treat a missing figure as a gap, not as a win for either side. If you are still choosing the milker itself, our milk pail for goats guide covers what the milk lands in.

Read the listing twice

Pulsator listings are mostly consistent, but a few figures deserve a second look:

  • OUKENS: the spec table gives product dimensions of 0.39 x 0.39 x 0.39 inches and a weight of 0.352 ounces, which cannot describe a 4-outlet stainless steel pulsator.
  • Fockety: the title states 48W 12V while the Beufee pump listing states 12V with no wattage, so the two pumps cannot be compared on power from the listings alone.
  • HAOX and Pssopp: the bullets repeat the same sentences, so read past the duplication to the figures that differ: 13.4 ounces against 12 ounces.

Measure your machine’s ports against the outlet count and the 0.37 inch outlet diameter the Mumusuki listing states before ordering.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers milking hardware only. It does not cover milking technique, udder care or any animal health question. Ask your veterinarian about herd health.

FAQs from goat keepers

What does a pulsator do?

The Pssopp listing describes it plainly: a device that makes the air pressure change periodically, and one of the essential parts of a milking system. It turns the pump’s steady vacuum into an on-off rhythm at the teat cups.

What pulsation rate do the listings state?

The YIHAOSSING and CYSFETENA listings state an adjustable speed from 50 to 180 ppm. The Mitty Dairy, CYSFETENA and Mumusuki listings state a 60:40 or 60/40 pulsation ratio.

How many outlets do pulsators have?

Most listings here state 2 outlets. The OUKENS listing states 4 outlets.

What vacuum pump pairs with these?

The Fockety listing states a 48W 12V pump at 2.62 pounds, and the Beufee listing states a 12V pump at 1.17 pounds. Check the voltage and fittings against your machine before buying.

More from the barn

See every goat milking machines guide and all milking guides.

More picks: goat milking machines, battery milking machines for pasture, milking buckets with strainer and milk pails for goats.