Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Quart vs Gallon Mason Jars: Which One Should You Buy?

Quart and gallon mason jars compared for goat milking, by stated size, lid type, care and the pack counts of four quart jar listings.

Quart vs Gallon Mason Jars: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Mihlapi 32 oz Mason Jar Pitcher with LidMihlapi 32 oz Mason Jar Pitcher with Lid9.6/10View on Amazon
  2. 2Ball 64 oz Wide Mouth Mason JarsBall 64 oz Wide Mouth Mason Jars9.7/10View on Amazon
  3. 3Ball Wide Mouth Glass Mason Jars with Lids and BandsBall Wide Mouth Glass Mason Jars with Lids and BandsView on Amazon
  4. 4Ball Wide Mouth Clear Glass Canning Quart 32 Oz Mason JarsBall Wide Mouth Clear Glass Canning Quart 32 Oz Mason JarsView on Amazon
  5. 5Ball Regular Mouth Glass Mason Jars with Lids and BandsBall Regular Mouth Glass Mason Jars with Lids and BandsView on Amazon
  6. 6SEWANTA Wide Mouth Mason Jars 32 oz [4 Pack] With Mason JarSEWANTA Wide Mouth Mason Jars 32 oz [4 Pack] With Mason JarView on Amazon
  7. 7Ball Glass Mason JarsBall Glass Mason JarsView on Amazon
  8. 8ComSaf 32 oz Wide Mouth Mason Jars 2 Pack Large Glass JarsComSaf 32 oz Wide Mouth Mason Jars 2 Pack Large Glass JarsView on Amazon

Morning milking fills the pail, and the jar you pour it into decides how much fridge space the day’s milk takes. For quart vs gallon mason jars, the quart jar is the everyday milking jar, while the gallon jar suits bigger yields and bulk storage. Every jar in the gear section below is a quart jar, so this guide compares the quart listings side by side and explains where a gallon jar fits instead.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Quart vs gallon mason jars: the short answer

Start with the day’s yield. A quart jar takes a milking from a modest producer, while a gallon jar takes a bigger haul without switching jars mid-chore. Wide mouth jars in quart size are easy to fill, scoop, pour and clean, and all four quart listings below use a wide mouth. If the herd grows or a doe gives heavily, a gallon jar saves jar swaps; for a small herd, quart jars stay easier to lift, chill and store.

If you want gallon jars specifically, our gallon mason jars roundup compares gallon jars on their own.

Quart jars compared

The jars below are listed in rank order, from the strongest milking pick to the weakest, on stated lids, care and pack size.

Jar Pack Lids Care
YEBODA 32 oz Wide Mouth Mason Jars 6 jars Two-piece metal lids and bands Dishwasher safe bodies, microwave safe without lids
Ball Wide Mouth Mason Jars, SureTight Lids 8 jars SureTight lids and bands Dishwasher safe
SEWANTA Wide Mouth Mason Jars 4 jars Lids and bands Dishwasher safe
Ball Wide Mouth Mason Jars, 24 Pack 24 jars Lids and bands Hand wash only

YEBODA 32 oz Wide Mouth Mason Jars, 6 Pack

The YEBODA listing gives 6 wide mouth jars at 32 ounces each, with matching metal lids and bands. The broad opening makes the jars easy to fill, scoop, pour and clean, and the listing suits them to meal prep, pantry storage, overnight oats, salads, sauces and dry goods, as well as jam, jelly, honey, pickling and sourdough starter. The jar bodies are dishwasher safe and microwave safe without the metal lids, and the listing says to wash and dry the lids promptly after use. Note the mismatch: the title and bullets say 6 jars, while the spec table says 4 PCS/SET, so count on the title figure and check the listing before ordering.

Ball Wide Mouth Mason Jars, 8 Pack, SureTight Lids

The Ball listing gives 8 wide mouth jars at 32 ounces each, with SureTight lids and bands that create an airtight seal for up to a year of preserving. The wide mouth design suits whole fruits and vegetables, and the jars are freezer and refrigerator safe for long-term food storage and dishwasher safe for easy cleanup. The construction is completely BPA-free. Note the mismatch: the title says 8-pack, while the spec table Unit Count says 1, so count on the title figure.

SEWANTA Wide Mouth Mason Jars, 4 Pack

The SEWANTA listing gives 4 wide mouth jars at 32 ounces each, with lids and bands, embossed measurement markings for precise filling and a label line for writing dates. The glass is soda-lime glass described as USDA approved, heat-tempered for water bath canning, and microwave and dishwasher safe. The listing suits the jars to canning, pickling, preserving and fermenting, and says to fill only to 12 ounces for freeze capacity. Note the mismatch: one bullet says canned goods seal for up to 18 months, while another says fresh preserve and store up to 1 year, so treat the longer figure with care. The listing also says to refrigerate up to 3 weeks.

Ball Wide Mouth Mason Jars, 24 Pack

The Ball listing gives 24 wide mouth jars at 32 ounces each, with lids and bands, for canning, pickling, juice, jam and jelly. The jars are glass, airtight and BPA-free, and the listing notes the jars are made in USA. The drawback for daily milking use is care: this listing says hand wash only, while the other quart listings are dishwasher safe. Note the mismatch: the spec table gives capacity as 2 pounds, while the title and item volume give 32 ounces and 946 ml.

Reading the size: quart against gallon

Every quart listing here states 32 ounces, and the Ball 24-pack also gives 946 ml for the same size. A gallon jar is the bigger jar in this comparison: it holds a larger haul in the same jar, which suits bulk storage and bigger yields. Quart jars suit the everyday milking routine because they are easier to handle one at a time, easier to fit on a fridge shelf and simpler to rotate through washing. A gallon jar suits a herd that fills quart jars too fast, or a kitchen that stores milk in bulk. The tradeoff is handling: a full gallon jar is heavier and takes more fridge space than a quart jar, so match the jar to the yield, not to the biggest size on the shelf.

Pack counts change the math of a purchase without changing the jar size. The Ball 24-pack gives the most jars in one order, while the SEWANTA 4-pack gives the fewest, and the YEBODA 6-pack and Ball 8-pack sit between them. Count the jars against the milking routine: enough clean jars to cover each milking plus washing time, with spares for preserving and storage.

Lids, seals and care

Lids decide whether a jar seals and how it washes. The YEBODA jars use two-piece metal lids and bands, and the Ball 8-pack uses SureTight lids with bands; both create an airtight seal. The SEWANTA listing gives lids and bands with a sealing compound, and the Ball 24-pack uses a screw closure with lids and bands. Care splits the four: the YEBODA bodies, the Ball 8-pack and the SEWANTA jars are dishwasher safe, while the Ball 24-pack is hand wash only. The YEBODA bodies are also microwave safe without the metal lids, and the Ball 8-pack is freezer and refrigerator safe. For freezing, the SEWANTA listing says to fill only to 12 ounces, so leave headroom in any jar headed for the freezer.

For freezing milk specifically, our glass milk jars for freezing guide compares jars for that use.

Read the listing twice

Mason jar listings often contradict themselves, and the numbers that conflict are usually the ones you need to plan the purchase:

  • YEBODA: the title and bullets say 6 jars, while the spec table says 4 PCS/SET.
  • Ball 8-pack: the title says 8-pack, while the spec table Unit Count says 1.
  • SEWANTA: one bullet says sealed for up to 18 months, while another says store up to 1 year.
  • Ball 24-pack: the spec table gives capacity as 2 pounds, while the title and item volume give 32 ounces and 946 ml.
  • YEBODA: the spec table dimensions of 2 by 2 by 2 inches do not match a quart jar, so ignore that line when planning storage.

Measure the jars on arrival and allow for the larger pack figure when the listing disagrees with itself. When a figure matters for the milking routine, check it against the title and bullets first, since those match the product more often than the spec table.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers jar hardware only. It does not cover how much milk a goat gives, milk handling beyond the jar, or any health question. Ask your veterinarian or local extension office about rations and goat health.

FAQs from goat keepers

Should I milk into a quart jar or a gallon jar?

Use a quart jar for everyday milking and a gallon jar for bigger yields and bulk storage. All four jars in the gear section are quart jars at 32 ounces each, so start there for a small herd.

Are wide mouth jars better for milking?

All four listings use a wide mouth, and the YEBODA listing says the broad opening makes the jars easy to fill, scoop, pour and clean. A wide opening also makes it easier to pour milk in from the pail without spilling.

Can quart mason jars go in the dishwasher?

Three of the four listings say dishwasher safe: the YEBODA bodies, the Ball 8-pack and the SEWANTA jars. The Ball 24-pack listing says hand wash only, so check care before ordering.

How long does a sealed jar keep?

The Ball 8-pack listing says its airtight seal lasts up to a year of preserving. The SEWANTA listing says sealed for up to 18 months in one bullet and store up to 1 year in another, so treat the two figures as a range to check. The Ball 24-pack listing states an airtight seal without a duration.

More from the barn

See every milk jars and bottles guide and all milking guides.

More picks: gallon mason jars, glass milk jars for freezing, milk jar brushes and milk cans vs milk pails.