Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Single vs Double Bucket Milking Machine: Which One Should You Buy?

Single vs double bucket milking machine: how each bucket setup works, which herds each suits, and the listed bucket sizes to compare before you buy.

Single vs Double Bucket Milking Machine: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

Top picks at a glance

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

  1. 1Cow Milking Machine PortableCow Milking Machine PortableView on Amazon
  2. 2Electric Goat Milking MachineElectric Goat Milking MachineView on Amazon
  3. 35L Goat Milking Machine Adjustable Pulsation Electric Milker5L Goat Milking Machine Adjustable Pulsation Electric MilkerView on Amazon
  4. 47L Goat Milking Machine7L Goat Milking MachineView on Amazon
  5. 53L Goat Milking Machine3L Goat Milking MachineView on Amazon
  6. 63L Cow Milking Machine Electric Pulsation Vacuum Pump Cow3L Cow Milking Machine Electric Pulsation Vacuum Pump CowView on Amazon

Two goats waiting at the stand while you empty one bucket is the real question behind single vs double bucket milking machine. A single bucket machine runs one bucket under one pump, so you milk animals one at a time and empty the bucket when it fills. A double bucket machine hangs two buckets (or two clusters) off one pump, so you can milk two animals at once or keep milking while the other bucket is emptied. This guide explains what each setup does, which herds each suits and the listed bucket sizes to check before you buy. Every number below comes from a product listing; where a listing gives no figure, we say so.

Also worth comparing

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Single vs double bucket milking machine: the short answer

Pick a single bucket machine when you milk a few goats and emptying the bucket between animals is no hardship: one pump, one bucket, one set of hoses to clean. Pick a double bucket machine when you milk enough animals that the stand is always full: two buckets share one pump, so the second animal can be milked while the first bucket is emptied and rinsed. If you would rather go straight to the products, our best goat milking machine roundup scores single bucket machines on these points.

How a single bucket machine works

A single bucket machine is one vacuum pump, one bucket and one set of teat cups. The listings we compared are all single bucket machines with buckets from 3L to 25L: the Aowoil goat machine lists a 3L bucket, the Proshine 2-in-1 lists a 7L bucket with two pairs of teat cups (one for goats, one for cows), the MAPOTAD lists a 14L bucket, and the GarveeTech lists a 25L, 6.6 gal bucket on a steel cart. The pump creates the vacuum, the pulsator cycles the cups, and the milk flows into the single bucket until you switch the pump off and carry the bucket away.

Pulsation rates on these listings range from 32 to 42 times per minute on the Aowoil and ZFNWXFP machines, to 45 to 47 times per minute on the Proshine, to 60 to 80 times per minute on the GarveeTech. The buckets are 304 stainless steel on nearly every listing, with food-grade silicone hoses and teat cup liners. One bucket means one thing to wash, which is the main appeal: a single bucket machine has fewer parts to clean after every milking.

How a double bucket machine works

A double bucket machine pairs two buckets with one pump, each bucket with its own cluster of teat cups. While one animal is being milked into the first bucket, the second bucket can be emptied, rinsed and attached to the next animal, or two animals can be milked at the same time on larger herds. None of the reference listings we compared is a double bucket machine; they are all single bucket machines from 3L to 25L, so the figures below about double buckets are the setup explained, not a listed spec.

The trade-off is parts and weight. Two buckets, two lids, two clusters and twice the hoses mean twice the washing after each milking, and a double bucket rig is heavier to move around the barn. For a herd of two or three goats, that extra work buys little; for a herd where the stand never sits empty, it buys a continuous rhythm the single bucket cannot match.

Single vs double bucket at a glance

Setup Buckets Listed sizes Suits Watch for
Single bucket One bucket, one pump 3L, 5L, 7L, 14L, 25L on these listings Two to a few goats, one animal at a time Bucket must be emptied before the next animal
Double bucket Two buckets, one pump Not stated on these listings Larger herds, continuous milking Twice the parts to wash

Which should you buy?

Count your animals and count your buckets. If you milk two or three goats, a single bucket machine in the 7L to 14L range covers a milking: the Proshine 7L lists a battery-powered pump with 4 teat cups, and the MAPOTAD 14L lists a check valve, a 13200 mAh battery with 3 hours of work on a 5 hour charge, and 2 teat cups. A 3L bucket, like the Aowoil 3L goat machine, is small enough that the listing itself warns the capacity shrinks further with a check valve installed, so it has none.

If you milk more animals than one bucket comfortably holds, or you want to keep the stand moving while a bucket is emptied, a double bucket machine is the step up. The GarveeTech 25L machine shows what a larger single bucket covers: 5 to 8 cows per hour on a 64.4 pound cart, which is more than a goat herd needs but shows how bucket size scales with the herd. Read our goat milking machines guides for more on pumps and buckets.

Read the listing twice

Milking machine listings contradict themselves, and the bucket size is the usual place it happens:

  • YPSLZY: the title says a 7L machine while the bullets say the bucket has a capacity of 14 liters.
  • Aowoil 3L: the bullets say the 3L bucket has no check valve because the capacity is too small, while the 7L and 14L buckets have one; confirm the check valve on the size you order.
  • Hantop 12L: this listing is a stainless steel bucket accessory only, not a complete machine, so it has no pump figure to compare.

Trust the title and bullets over the spec table, and confirm the bucket size and the check valve on the listing before you buy: every bucket figure in these listings is named there, not buried in the specs.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers bucket setups only. It does not cover pump sizing, pulsation settings for specific animals or any animal health question. For health questions, ask your veterinarian.

FAQs from goat keepers

How many goats can a single bucket machine milk?

It depends on the bucket size and how much each goat gives. These listings state buckets of 3L, 5L, 7L, 14L and 25L, so a 7L or 14L bucket covers more animals per fill than a 3L one.

What is a check valve on a milking machine?

A check valve stops the milk from flowing into the pump when the bucket is full. The Aowoil listings state a check valve on the 7L and 14L buckets but not on the 3L bucket, and the MAPOTAD 14L listing also states one.

Are the buckets stainless steel?

Nearly every listing here states a 304 stainless steel bucket with food-grade silicone hoses and teat cup liners. The Proshine listing states a SUS304 stainless steel bucket.

Can a milking machine run on battery?

Some do. The Proshine listing states battery powered operation, the YPSLZY listing states a 13200 mAh rechargeable battery for 3 hours of use, and the MAPOTAD listing states a 13200 mAh battery with 3 hours of work on a 5 hour charge.

When does a double bucket machine pay off?

When the stand is always full: with two buckets on one pump, one bucket can be emptied and rinsed while the other keeps milking. For two or three goats, a single bucket machine means less to wash after every milking.

More from the barn

See every goat milking machine guide and all milking guides.

More picks: best goat milking machines, milking guides.