Skip to content
We independently pick everything we recommend. We earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Learn more ›
Amazon Black Friday Week deals

Stainless Steel vs Plastic Kid Bottles: Which One Should You Buy?

A stainless steel vs plastic kid bottle guide, with four stainless steel bottles ranked by stated insulation, lids and durability.

Stainless Steel vs Plastic Kid Bottles: Which One Should You Buy?
On this page

In the stainless steel vs plastic kid bottles question, stainless steel wins, at least among the four bottles compared here: every one of them is a stainless steel insulated bottle, and none is plastic. The listings state cold retention from 12 to 24 hours, BPA-free lids and spouts, and leak-proof designs, which are the features a plastic bottle would have to match. If you are choosing between the two materials, compare any plastic bottle against these same stated points: insulation hours, lid type, whether the spout is covered, and dishwasher-safe parts.

GoatGearLab earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.

Stainless steel vs plastic kid bottles: the short answer

Buy stainless steel if you want the drink to stay cold through the school day: the Owala listing states up to 24 hours of cold retention and the two THERMOS listings state up to 12 hours, all from vacuum-insulated stainless steel. Plastic bottles are not represented in these listings, so there is no stated insulation figure here to compare them against. Where plastic usually argues is weight and price, but those are not stated in these listings either, so judge a plastic bottle on its own listing.

Stainless steel also brings the durability claims: the THERMOS listings describe 18/8 stainless steel built to handle drops and dings, and the Simple Modern listing describes a food-grade 304 (18/8) stainless steel interior. All four listings state BPA-free construction, and the Owala adds lead-free and phthalate-free. A plastic bottle can be BPA-free too, so check the listing rather than the material name.

Insulation: the biggest stated difference

Insulation is where stainless steel bottles put numbers on the listing. The Owala FreeSip Kids 16 oz states double-wall insulation that keeps drinks cold for up to 24 hours. Both THERMOS FUNTAINER 12 oz bottles state vacuum insulation that keeps drinks cold for up to 12 hours. The Simple Modern 14 oz states double-wall vacuum insulation that keeps water cold for hours, without a number.

None of the four bottles here is plastic, so this guide has no plastic insulation figure to quote. When you look at a plastic bottle, check whether its listing states any cold-retention hours at all; if it states none, assume the drink warms to the room. Also note that every one of these four is for cold liquids only: the listings say they are not for hot liquids, and the Simple Modern adds not for carbonated beverages.

Lids, spouts and straws

The lid is the part a kid touches most, and the four listings take four approaches. The Owala uses a push-button FreeSip lid with a lock, a carry loop and a spout that works two ways: sipping upright through the built-in straw or tilting back to swig from the spout opening. The protective lid keeps the spout covered when closed.

Both THERMOS bottles use a push-button lid with a hygienically covered pop-up straw that removes for cleaning, plus an integrated carry handle with a soft-touch grip. The Simple Modern uses a straw lid with a spill-proof nozzle: it stays leak proof when the nozzle is in the closed position, which the listing says survives a backpack or lunch bag. For school use, a covered or closable spout matters more than the straw style, since an open spout is the leak.

The gear: four stainless bottles, ranked

1. Owala FreeSip Kids Stainless Steel 16 oz. The most fully stated bottle here: 16 oz capacity, up to 24 hours of cold retention, a two-way FreeSip spout with a locking push-button lid, and BPA, lead and phthalate-free construction. The lid is dishwasher safe while the cup is hand wash. Ranked first for the longest stated cold retention and the most lid features.

2. Simple Modern Kids 14 oz with Straw Lid. A 14 oz bottle with a spill-proof straw lid that is leak proof when the nozzle is closed, double-wall vacuum insulation, and a food-grade 304 (18/8) stainless steel interior. It is cupholder friendly and both the bottle and the straw lids are dishwasher safe. Recommended for toddlers 2 and up. Ranked second for the spill-proof nozzle design and full dishwasher-safe construction.

3. THERMOS FUNTAINER 12 oz, Teal. A 12 oz bottle with vacuum insulation stated to keep drinks cold up to 12 hours, 18/8 stainless steel construction, a push-button lid with a removable pop-up straw, and a limited 5 year manufacturer warranty stated. Top-rack dishwasher safe, though hand washing is recommended. Ranked third: the same core bottle as the Construction colorway, but the stated warranty moves it up.

4. THERMOS FUNTAINER 12 oz, Construction. The same 12 oz vacuum-insulated bottle with 12-hour cold retention, 18/8 stainless steel, push-button lid and removable pop-up straw, BPA-free and top-rack dishwasher safe. No warranty term is stated on this listing. Ranked fourth only because the identical Teal listing states a 5-year warranty and this one does not.

What to skip or double-check

Skip any listing that does not state the capacity, the insulation type or the lid style; all four listings here state all three, and a bottle that hides them is not worth the gamble. Double-check the dishwasher instructions per part: the Owala cup is hand wash while its lid is dishwasher safe, and the THERMOS listings recommend hand washing even though the bottles are top-rack safe. Double-check the age fit too: the Simple Modern is recommended for toddlers 2 and up, while the others are described for kids generally.

Also double-check that you are buying the right colorway on purpose: the two THERMOS FUNTAINER bottles are the same 12 oz bottle in different colors, and only the Teal listing states a warranty. Read the listing twice before assuming the color you like carries the same terms.

What this guide does not cover

This guide covers kid bottle hardware only: materials, insulation, lids and the four bottles listed above. It does not cover sippy cups for infants, sports bottles for adults, or any health question about materials. It does not review plastic bottles, since none of the four listings is plastic.

FAQs from goat keepers

Are these stainless steel kid bottles dishwasher safe?

It varies by part. The Simple Modern bottle and its straw lids are dishwasher safe, the THERMOS bottles are top-rack dishwasher safe though hand washing is recommended, and the Owala lid is dishwasher safe while the cup is hand wash.

How long do these bottles keep drinks cold?

The Owala states up to 24 hours, both THERMOS bottles state up to 12 hours, and the Simple Modern states hours without a number. All four are for cold liquids only.

Are these bottles BPA-free?

Yes, all four listings state BPA-free construction, and the Owala also states lead-free and phthalate-free. The Simple Modern states a food-grade 304 (18/8) stainless steel interior.

Can kids use these bottles for hot drinks?

No. The Owala, both THERMOS bottles and the Simple Modern all state they are not for hot liquids, and the Simple Modern adds not for carbonated beverages.

More from the barn

See every kid bottles and nipples guide and all feeding and water guides.

More picks: stainless vs galvanized feed pan, metal vs plastic mineral feeder, nipple waterer vs bowl waterer and goat water buckets.